AnswerID: 118531 Submitted: Saturday, Jul 02, 2005 at 11:37
Keith_A (Qld)
replied:
Hi Babs - you asked about Land Rover Discovery. I have owned a Landcruiser, a new Discovery TDI and now a Nissan Patrol. Two friends also owned Discoveries. Perhaps we were just VERY unlucky, but from bitter experience I will never buy one again, or recommend one to anyone. Constant faults from new. Serviced by the book by the LR dealer. Final straw was when the big ends chewed the chemically hardened crankshaft at 120k. Cost $8000 to rebuild.
Friends TDI blew a head gasket at 140k - $7000 rebuild.
At a recent campertrailer get-together, a fellow camper was bemoaning his new TD5 (with the BMW diesel) - same story - can't afford to keep it once out of warranty.
This is not a flame - my experince, as a careful owner with full history and receipts.
They are one of the nicest 4WD to drive, and very capable -but Quality control on parts is hopeless, and very costly.
I have no experince with the petrol V8 models.
My appologies in advance if this post upsets LR people. My experience only.
Reply 10 of 15
FollowupID: 373700 Submitted:
Saturday, Jul 02, 2005 at 14:48
Bob of KAOS posted:
Keith
your experience relates to the TDi. I have had two TD5s and they have been excellent. I am quite sure a lot of the quality issues from the early TDi were addressed in the series 2. The 5 pot TD5 engine has plenty of torque, is economical, and hasn't let me down once. I have driven it all over the place (literally), often with trailer, and I would have no hesitation in setting off again tomorrow without any special preparation. The 20,000km service interval (possible because of the centrifugal oil filter and synthetic oil) suits me well.
There has also been quite a bit of discussion regarding the Patrols engine problems - maybe you have been lucky to escape that.
FollowUp 1 of 1