Site Search
Print Page Setup Profile Login
You have 4 items in your shopping cart
Section Image

4WD have a bad name + Harold Scruby

Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 16:56

Cowgal

Hi there,
I've worked for with a recognisable 4WD manufacturer and now am in a gig undertaking research into the perceptions of 4WD's.

Where do you think this negative perception comes from - is it just Harold Scruby? or is the north shore kind of Toorack tractor perception of the vehicles?

Do youthink people really understand what a 4Wd is meant for?

Is there a difference between driving a 4WD in the city and in the outback?

Throw whatever you want at me - opnions, research, articles whatever - I am acompiling a report so I'd love to post your input
Advertisement
ThreadID: 28577 Replies: 26
Views: 1632 FollowUps: 15
This Thread has been Archived
Thread Summary
Thread Watch Back To Forum Alert Moderator FAQ
AnswerID: 142160   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 17:06

Lone Wolf replied:

Pretty hard to take you on seriously, when you can't spell, use correct punctuation, and capital letters where lower case should be.

This alone, tells me you aren't what you say you are.

Wolfie
Reply 1 of 26
AnswerID: 142161   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 17:17

Member - Ian H (NSW) replied:

I had the same thought. If you can not spell how are you going to put together a readable report?

Click Image to Enlarge
When you talk you only hear something you already know.
Reply 2 of 26
AnswerID: 142162   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 17:27

Member - Pezza (QLD) replied:

Yep, thought exactly the same thing, think it might be one of Scruby's dippy mates digging for info to make it easier to fight their silly little war against us by thinking they then know where our weak spots are.

Avagoodn
Pezza

Click Image to Enlarge
" NO FEAR " means you're not going fast enough!
Reply 3 of 26
FollowupID: 395817   Submitted: Saturday, Dec 03, 2005 at 07:13

old mate posted:

You honestly think this is some sort of conspiracy? What piffle!
FollowUp 1 of 1
AnswerID: 142164   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 17:33

Cowgal replied:

End of a long day.
I said throw whatever you would like at me - you can be part of this or not - it is up to you ...

Lets begin again

I've worked in the automotive industry, I now represent the industry and I am preparing a research report into the perceptions of 4WD's. Here is a sample of the work which has gone to a wide cross section of people including Government Ministers, CEO's of major insurance companies, roads and traffic authorities, lobby groups and high profile journalist. It is usually conducted in a one on one style so that more effective material can be gathered.

1. On scale of 1 to 5, 1 being very low and 5 being very high, please rate your level of concern about the following vehicle and road safety issues?

1.1 Driver fatigue
1.2 Speeding
1.3 Drink driving & drug driving
1.4 Inexperienced drivers (P Platers)
1.5 4WD safety
1.6 Truck driver fatigue
1.7 Mobile phone use whilst driving

2. On a scale of 1 to 5, 1 being strongly disagrees and 5 being strongly agree, rate the following statements:


4.1 4WD’s are safe
4.2 4WDs are unsafe
4.3 4WD’s safety should be better regulated
4.4 Safety is primarily the drivers responsibility
4.5 If a pedestrian is hit by a 4WD they are twice as likely to be killed
4.6 4WDs are safer than other vehicles

3. Thinking about the statements above, what factors help form your opinion of vehicle safety?

4. On a scale of 1 to 5, 1 being strongly disagrees and 5 being strongly agree, rate the following statements:

4WD use more petrol than other vehicles
4WD’s should be banned from urban areas
4WD owners need to undertake a specialised driving skills course
It is the North Shore (Toorack) 4WD drivers who are unsafe

5. Thinking about the statements above, it is often touted that this 4WD safety issue is predominately a ‘North Shore’ (Toorack) problem - what are your thoughts on that?

So ball is in your court - send me your opinions, articles, research or not - just berate me - that is fine - I am only trying to help balance out the Scruby's of this world.

Hi there,
I've worked for with a recognisable 4WD manufacturer and now am in a gig undertaking research into the perceptions of 4WD's.

Where do you think this negative perception comes from - is it just Harold Scruby? or is the north shore kind of Toorack tractor perception of the vehicles?

Do youthink people really understand what a 4Wd is meant for?

Is there a difference between driving a 4WD in the city and in the outback?

Throw whatever you want at me - opnions, research, articles whatever - I am acompiling a report so I'd love to post your input
Reply 4 of 26
FollowupID: 395757   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 17:37

Lone Wolf posted:

Well, I do take my hat off to you for coming back, and not with a vengeance.

You certainly do have a thick skin, and maybe, your heart is in the right place.

I take back some of what I said, and I wish you well in your research.

Ian
FollowUp 1 of 3
FollowupID: 395761   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 17:54

joc45 posted:

If you're doing that sort of survey, wouldn't it be better to give an address for members to submit their views, rather than create an enormously long post here?
And, umm, there are a few states that don't have a North Shore or Toorack (sic). And don't have a Harold Scruby either ;-)
Some questions are a bit ill-worded; eg, petrol question - a lot of 4wds out here are diesel - makes a lot of difference to the answer given, esp if you are after accurate stats.
Gerry
FollowUp 2 of 3
FollowupID: 395766   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 19:16

Exploder posted:

I will respond with words for some.

1.1 Driver fatigue> It’s the same as any other vehicle why is a 4WD more dangerous.

1.2 Speeding> Not a big problem in my book’s, half the roads in this country could do with a speed increase. The government just like getting money from fines, with the amount of car’s on the road and k’s travelled each year the road toll is fairly good. They lower speed limit’s make it harder to get a license police the bleep out of us spend money on adds ECT and has the road toll changed.

1.3 Drink driving & drug driving>4

1.4 Inexperienced drivers (P Platers)> They have to learn some time, You what to teach P platers to drive get them on a ball bearing gravel road’s in a rear wheel drive car, 6cyl or above, You teach people to drive at speed on those types of roads at a young age you will have a country of A1 drivers who can handle a car. You don’t learn how to control a car putting around with a driving instructor or on a Computer.

1.4 4WD safety> ?? I didn’t by my 4Wd for safety I brought it so I could go to out of the way placers and explore the bush! As for if a small car and a 4WD have a crash of corse the small car will come out worse it’s basic Physics, and if this is a persons sole resin for hating 4WD’s well I am sorry but they are a dip bleep .

1.5 Truck driver fatigue>2
1.6 Mobile phone use whilst driving>2

. On a scale of 1 to 5, 1 being strongly disagrees and 5 being strongly agree, rate the following statements:

4.1 4WD’s are safe, If you are buying a 4WD just because you think it is the safest you are buying for the wrong resins, their are plenty of cars that are safer than a 4WD.

4.2 4WDs are unsafe, Compleat bleep , I can name 4 of my friend’s who would be dead now if they weren’t in a 4WD, and offcourse a 4WD will implement more damage to a smaller car so why should this make a small car safe and a 4WD dangerous. More to the point any car is unsafe when driven badly.

4.3 4WD’s safety should be better regulated>1
4.4 Safety is primarily the drivers responsibility> a big 5
4.5 If a pedestrian is hit by a 4WD they are twice as likely to be killed> If any car hit’s you at speed you will be dead or seriously injured, tell me how many people have been killed by being hit by a 4WD this year, Now tell me how many 4WD were involved in animal strikes I.E Cow, Roo, Emu, Goat and how many of those people would be dead or injured if they were not in a 4WD.

4.6 4WDs are safer than other vehicles> depends what Vehicles and under what conditions. I have a mate who was recently involved in a LEGAL Drag racing accident where the front left side of the car hit the wall at 160km/h in his street legal Supercharged Commodore now if we believe all the Government adds he should be Dead so why did he walk away with only a bruised nee and well a written off car.
I also know someone who hit a Cow head on wile travelling at 110km/h at night in the country and if he wasn’t in a 4WD he would be Dead if this was a commodore or a small car he would have been dead. Get were I am going with this?

3. Thinking about the statements above, what factors help form your opinion of vehicle safety?, I will be honest I have never even looked at the safety rating on a vehicle when buying, I buy what will best suet my need’s and the vehicle I Like.

4. On a scale of 1 to 5, 1 being strongly disagrees and 5 being strongly agree, rate the following statements:

4WD use more petrol than other vehicles> Ever driven a Turbo diesel Nissan, Toyota, Jeep or even a ford F250 you will be impressed. My 4.0Ltr V6 4WD (Petrol engine) uses around 14Ltrs per 100k’s driving around the metro aria. My Mum’s 2.2ltr Honda gets around 10ltrs per 100k’s around the metro aria, and I can go a lot of places the Honda can’t go and carry a lot more equipment and people in comfort as well.

4WD’s should be banned from urban areas 1
4WD owners need to undertake a specialised driving skills course> Should be a option if a first time buyer
It is the North Shore (Toorack) 4WD drivers who are unsafe> Don’t know don’t life there.

They are my opinions like it or hate it.
FollowUp 3 of 3
Activities Index
Team Building on a Americas Cup Class Yacht Team Building on a Americas Cup Class Yacht
Sydney - NSW
Hoist the sails and get on the grinders.
V8 Race Buggy and WRX Rally Car - 32 Lap Combo V8 Race Buggy and WRX Rally Car - 32 Lap Comb
Gold Coast - QLD
The ultimate in dirt driving!
Phillip Island Wildlife & Penguin Experience Phillip Island Wildlife & Penguin Experience
Phillip Island and Gippsland - VIC
This tour is the ultimate experience for those interested in Australian animals and Phillip Island.
Wine and Canapes Dinner Cruise on a Tall Ship Wine and Canapes Dinner Cruise on a Tall Ship
Sydney - NSW
Thank goodness it's Friday!
Book Now - Things To Do
AnswerID: 142165   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 17:40

Member - Jack replied:

It will be a massive thread if you want us to repond here ... got an email address we can send this off to?
Jack
All power corrupts, but we need the electricity.
Reply 5 of 26
AnswerID: 142169   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 18:25

Footloose replied:

Diving right on in.........
What is the aim of your report ? What are your other data sources? What are the likely outcomes of this report ?
What sort of stakeholder are you in this report ? What qualifications/experience do you have in this area ?
...........................
Possibly 17 million of our population live in cities I'm told. City dwellers are not necessarily aware of the useage of 4wds by non farmers.
Many 4wds are big (hard to get round and speed), because they're big then they must use more fuel (not true empirically) and emit more "greenhouse gas". (They've never stood behind a cow!). They can't see behind themselves (vision in most is better than many cars) and if they hit me in my smartcar then I die not them. (not fair). They cost more than a second hand Holden and the rich buggars can buy them because the tariff is ls less (than what ?). They ruin the air, they ruin my driving pleasure, I can't afford one, and the pedestal council rekkons they're unsafe. Gotta have something to whinge about while I gulp my sandwhich down in Martin Place eh ? Gotta be po liti cally and environ mental ly correct ? See; there's another article in the paper and its just what I said (as if that turns the world).
No 4wds in cities I rekkon. What's that ? You want to restrict my holiday choices ? Buggar off !
I'm sure there's a bit of accurate city dweller perception in there somewhere.

Fuelled by what ? The media? Tick. Harold media sl*t Scooby Do ? Tick. The explosion in numbers of them on the road ? Tick. That big shiny one in my rich neighbours garage ? Tick. It's cool to criticize them ? Tick. They make a great excuse to vent my shortcomings on the road ? Tick.

"Is there a difference between driving a 4WD in the city and in the outback? " What sort of question is that to ask in this forum? Can you be just a tad more specific ? What sorts of difference are we looking at ? Outside of a city they are almost the difference between walking and driving. Without them you don't get far if it rains etc. And that's on our "roads". Most people here are serious 4wd people. That means that they travel far from the Martin Place Mob madness. To get there they need a 4wd. I know that this is probably new to you but most of Australia is empty space, to get anywhere you can't walk or take public transport. And although from point A to point B might be 4000K, there usually isn't a road as city dwellers know them. It takes a big (forget motels and garages, you have to carry everything !) tough (a normal car would be shaken apart ) vehicle to get there and back in 1 piece. And we haven't even touched on main hazards of the tracks.

Bullbars ? Now don't get me going ............:))

Reply 6 of 26
FollowupID: 395767   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 19:34

Exploder posted:

Good one.LOL

Will there be a part 2.
FollowUp 1 of 2
FollowupID: 395770   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 19:46

Footloose posted:

Mate, I rekkon I should of stopped and waited for his answers at the firsdt line of dots......... I could then have adopted a clinically academic approach, instead of trying in inject some humour into what the 4th estate sees as a life and death struggle between fat hairy 4wd owners and po litically and environmentally correct would be if I could be wannabee pushbike riders.
Oh sorry. Am I being a bit biased here ? Thast was the newspaper on the phone, they want me to do a story .............:)))))))))
FollowUp 2 of 2
AnswerID: 142175   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 19:39

Motherhen replied:

Cowgal give us an email address and i will respond. I don't want to bore everyone here, and as has already been said. it will be too long a thread, and not relevant to the purposes of the forum at this stage. There would be a lot of repetition, so the thread will get monotonous.

Better still from your point of view would be an interactive website - one of those tick the boxes PLUS endless room for comments. Much easier to collate, and statistics like that can be used in your report as they are substantiated. Various comments from forum members is harder to collate, not as clear and precise, therefore not a provable or even useful statistic for you study. I cannot see that research carried out using opinions gathered from the forum would be accepted by any organisation/body/government. You have not said who you are working for - yourself? I can see why your first post was not taken seriously.

By all means let us see a summary of your results. Road safety has always been a major concern of mine. A farmers, my family spend a lot of time on the road, almost all of it in 4WDs.

Who the **** is Harold Scruby does anyone care?

Near the Stuart Highway NT
Click Image to Enlarge
Home to reality - The dream trip is over
Lifetime Member: My Profile  My Blog  Send Message
Reply 7 of 26
FollowupID: 395772   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 19:51

Footloose posted:

Scruby ?... noun...look under pedestal council..look under media mistress....look under "I drive a 4wd and my wife can't park it"....look under I vant to be a politician (again).....look under bullbar....oops that last one wasn't nice Footy !!!!!
FollowUp 1 of 3
FollowupID: 395775   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 20:17

Footloose posted:

For more see WHO ??</a
FollowUp 2 of 3
FollowupID: 395776   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 20:18

Footloose posted:

Sorry, try http://home.iprimus.com.au/jimshire/mr_who.htm
FollowUp 3 of 3
AnswerID: 142178   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 19:48

Member - Ian W (NSW) replied:

Cowgal,

Nice comeback after a very shaky start - Congrats on that.

HOWEVER!

If you are serious about your survey and if you have no hidden agenda then how bout being totally upfront?

Who are you?

Exactly who do you represent? etc:, etc:, etc:

Sorry if I sound a little cynical but you are still more more than a little vague about where you wish to take this exercise

Ian
Reply 8 of 26
AnswerID: 142180   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 20:13

Member - Oldplodder (QLD) replied:

I think you need to add more detail to the term '4wd' in this survey.

Your answer will assist me in answering your survey, in particular the 1 to 5 grading of anwers.

I prefer not to give my definition first, as it will influence your answer.

Click Image to Enlarge
John C - aka Oldplodder
In touring mode, the way it should be.
Reply 9 of 26
AnswerID: 142182   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 20:16

BorisK replied:

Cowgal are you a year 7 or 8 student by any chance?
Reply 10 of 26
AnswerID: 142185   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 20:37

Old Nick replied:

Give us an email address,or option two, change your name to CLOWNGAL!!
Reply 11 of 26
AnswerID: 142188   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 21:15

Brian B (QLD) replied:

Hi Cowgal,

As some of the other replies have said, I think you will need to be up front with who you represent etc as people blindly answering surveys has an annoying habit of coming back to haunt them later on.

I don't think random email surveys add a lot of credibility to the task at hand.

Our 2004 Hilux SR5
Click Image to Enlarge
Cheers

Brian
Reply 12 of 26
Activities Index
Sydney Whale Watching Adventure & Lunch x2 Sydney Whale Watching Adventure & Lunch x2
Sydney - NSW
Ride the surf and swell out of the harbour and enjoy the greatest adventure whale watching tour in S
Dolphin Watch from Glenelg Dolphin Watch from Glenelg
Adelaide - SA
Dolphins are one of the Earth's most fascinating and curious creatures.
Sydney Morning City Sights and Bondi Tour J6 Sydney Morning City Sights and Bondi Tour J6
Sydney - NSW
Discover Sydney Highlights on AAT Kings' half day tour, see the historic Rocks area, the heads of th
Dreamworld - One Day Pass Dreamworld - One Day Pass
Gold Coast - QLD
MTV will plug into Dreamworld with some of the nation's coolest celebrities!
Book Now - Things To Do
AnswerID: 142198   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 23:09

Trekkie replied:

My My aren't we a touchy lot - lil ole Cow Gal gets on OUR forum and asks us a question and look at the defensive results she got. Even when she comes straight back, we still question her - I say what does it matter who she represents or even if she is a 7th grade student or even Harold's wife.

I thought this would be our opportunity to tell her as we see it (and that could be seen as right or wrong - good or bad - by the majority of road users -who cares) Personally I probably will not particpate, but I was surprised at the reaction she got.

If we react like that to all road users !!! ....... but I am sure we dont, maybe we are just a little sick of being attacked by a vocal minority and some idiot journos who probably dont know a turbo from a dip stick ... now I am getting wound up so I will just hit the Submit Reply button and go back to looking on ebay for a cat
That Would Be Bad
Click Image to Enlarge
Trekkie
Beam me up Scottie !!!
Reply 13 of 26
FollowupID: 395799   Submitted: Friday, Dec 02, 2005 at 23:46

Motherhen posted:

Hi Trekkie - I am sure many of us would give Cowgal feedback if she gives us a website or email addy. Research conducted in the manner proposed on the forum would have no clout, and anyone involved in research would know this. I have come back to the post to check for a bit more info and that web or email address - but no more Cowgal. Before responding, I, like others on the post would like to know more about this Cowgal doing research for some nebulous unclarified group.
Near the Stuart Highway NT
Click Image to Enlarge
Home to reality - The dream trip is over
Lifetime Member: My Profile  My Blog  Send Message
FollowUp 1 of 1
AnswerID: 142204   Submitted: Saturday, Dec 03, 2005 at 01:28

muzzgit (WA) replied:

Haven't you guys figured it out....cowgal IS harold screwbey.

Reply 14 of 26
AnswerID: 142224   Submitted: Saturday, Dec 03, 2005 at 08:19

V8Diesel replied:

Hi there, got stuff to do so I won't answer all your questions but here's my Readers Digest condensed version in point form..............

1. I could not earn my living without a 4WD. I also view it as a safety factor with solo travel in often remote places.

2. I've walked away from two serious collisions (both not my fault BTW) and firmly believe I'd be in a real mess if I hadn't been travelling in a full-size commercial vehicle. You cannae change the laws of physics.

3. Lifestyle benefits. This morning I'm heading off with some good friends to go 4WD'ing and BBQ'ing in some beautiful countryside that the general public would find very hard to get to for some peace & quiet after a very heavy week of work. If I wanted to sit shoulder to shoulder with a thousand other picnickers (?) I'd go to Kings Park like everyone else.

4. My petrol 100 series when running on LPG is cheaper to operate than my wife's passenger car and its exhaust emmissions are significantly more environmentally friendly to boot. My diesel V8 75 series frequently returns better fuel economy than many popular passenger vehicles.

5. I expect both my vehicles will be running efficiently in another 20 years time whereas most cheaply constructed cars would only be fit for the scrap heap.

6. I just like it. I can have more fun at 1km/h crawling up a hill than at speed on the bitumen.

Hope this helps.

Reply 15 of 26
AnswerID: 142226   Submitted: Saturday, Dec 03, 2005 at 08:24

Sand Man (SA) replied:

Different Tack,

I'm not going to "rate" my perception of 4WD vehicles because I am biased.
I Love my 4WD and the flexibility it provides for me to travel just about anywhere I wish. I understand its own particular "limitations" and drive accordingly.

There are probably more 4WD owners/drivers that never take their vehicles off road to the extent that most of us do. Probably don't even use 4WD.

These are the people most likely to get themselves into difficulty with their vehicle because they don't have experience in driving their vehicles "off road" and learn to recognise and appreciate any limitations ANY vehicle may have. And these are also the people, in the main, that may project a negative image of what a Four Wheel Drive vehicle is, what it can do and what it (or the driver) can't do.

And Harold (who?).......He doesn't even count. I put him in the same category as Ray Martin and colleagues.


Click Image to Enlarge
HooRoo !


I'm diagonally parked in a parallel Universe!
Reply 16 of 26
AnswerID: 142227   Submitted: Saturday, Dec 03, 2005 at 08:32

Graham replied:

Cowgal said: "Here is a sample of the work which has gone to a wide cross section of people including Government Ministers, CEO's of major insurance companies, roads and traffic authorities, lobby groups and high profile journalist"

Bzzzzz - Government Ministers, and members of parliament for that matter, do not, repeat, do not, complete surveys like this under any circumstances!

To state this is the case is, quite simply, a fabrication!

It may have gone out to them, they did not get a completed survey back!

Regards

Graham
Reply 17 of 26
AnswerID: 142237   Submitted: Saturday, Dec 03, 2005 at 10:56

Flash replied:

I go along with the line that even if Cowgal is Harold's wife (poor girl!) then what harm does it do to tell her.....
BTW We have four cars in this family.... of six people, five drivers licences.
Two are 1.4litre fours.
One is a 1.8 litre four.
One is a 4.2 litre turbodiesel 4WD, with a large bull bar, lots of heavy towing and 4WD gear. That's basically all it does- 4WDing and towing.
Now if I have a gripe it is why doesn't the government have "transferable" rego so more people could afford to leave the 4WD in the garage during the week and have a cheap "enviromentally friendly" little car for dropping off the kids and commuting. I do that, but it's an expensive exercise due to the "fixed" costs like rego and insurance. (I don't really care much about depreciation as we hold on to our cars for a long time, eg: my 4WD, bought new, is about to hit sixteen years old, and one of the 4cyl cars is nearly 25 years young.)
Give us an email address for the rest Cowgal.
Cheers
Reply 18 of 26
AnswerID: 142257   Submitted: Saturday, Dec 03, 2005 at 14:59

GaryInOz (Vic) replied:

My 2c worth????

Our bad rap stems from the "mum's taxi" and "shopping centre gymkhana" ppl. Basicallyit is the ppl that have them as trophy vehicles to try to assert status on themselves that are our main source of bad reputation for lousy driving skills.

The irony is that the ppl that say 4WD's are dangerous are the husbands/wives of those ppl that do the shopping in them, or pick up the kids from school.

As a general observation (living in very close proximity to a major shopping ctr in Melb) the drivers have no concept of the length and width of their vehicles and cannot park or manoever them with any degree of accuracy. My guess would be that the majority of accidents reported to the insurance co's would be low speed fender-benders by ppl with low levels of driving skills and high levels of distractions (kids, talking, looking for parking spot, etc.)

I think the level of reported "off-road" incidents to the insurers would be numerically significantly lower, but of higher repair cost.

Most of us accept that a bit of rock rash is an inevitable part of our pastime, and would seldom report it to our insurer, choosing to privately repair it ourselves, unless it was a disabling kind of damage.

Most ppl that use their 4WD for recreation have good driving skills, which are needed to minimize damage and operate safely. They tend to be more in tune with their vehicle and its characteristics.

Now if we could get the manufacturers of the so-called "crossover" vehicles to give REALISTIC representations of the capacity of their vehicles in their advertising.............
Reply 19 of 26
AnswerID: 142264   Submitted: Saturday, Dec 03, 2005 at 15:58

Motherhen replied:

Cowgal - you've certainly got everyone's interest - look at the number of people who have read this post! Then you disappeared. Where are you?
Near the Stuart Highway NT
Click Image to Enlarge
Home to reality - The dream trip is over
Lifetime Member: My Profile  My Blog  Send Message
Reply 20 of 26
FollowupID: 395850   Submitted: Saturday, Dec 03, 2005 at 17:44

Mr Fawlty posted:

Probably gone off to regroup... or log in under another name....maybe even decided that the "statistics" he/she wanted were not going to favour his/her agenda so we have been abandoned...I'm kind of amazed because the "Government" never gets it's stats / data by interviewing a known vested interest....Especially as the only agenda of any goverment is to increase motoring costs....
FollowUp 1 of 1
Activities Index
Dreamworld - One Day Pass Dreamworld - One Day Pass
Gold Coast - QLD
MTV will plug into Dreamworld with some of the nation's coolest celebrities!
Helicopter Island Day Adventure Helicopter Island Day Adventure
The Whitsundays - QLD
Spend a day living it up by enjoying a scenic helicopter flight over the amazing Whitsunday Islands
Renewal Spa Treatment For Him Or Her Renewal Spa Treatment For Him Or Her
Perth - WA
How does a full body steam, aromatic shower, massage and facial sound to renew the body?
Ocean Beach Horse Riding Ocean Beach Horse Riding
Mornington / Bellarine - VIC
No experience necessary! Enjoy the exhilaration of horse riding along beautiful St.
Book Now - Things To Do
AnswerID: 142291   Submitted: Saturday, Dec 03, 2005 at 20:40

Member - Bill F (VIC) replied:

Hi Cowgal,

Can you give a definition of a 4wd that suits you research?

Bill

also check 4wd polli
Behind Lake Mountain VIC July 07
Click Image to Enlarge
Fay'd away from the crowd
Reply 21 of 26
AnswerID: 142301   Submitted: Saturday, Dec 03, 2005 at 21:35

Member - Roachie (SA) replied:

TROL

Click Image to Enlarge
There's only one thing more painful than learning from experience and that is NOT learning from experience!
Reply 22 of 26
AnswerID: 142315   Submitted: Sunday, Dec 04, 2005 at 01:50

Trekkie replied:

I think I have figured it out

Cowgal is actually Willem
That Would Be Bad
Click Image to Enlarge
Trekkie
Beam me up Scottie !!!
Reply 23 of 26
FollowupID: 395896   Submitted: Sunday, Dec 04, 2005 at 13:56

Motherhen posted:

Willem - is that you with your finger on the trigger?

Near the Stuart Highway NT
Click Image to Enlarge
Home to reality - The dream trip is over
Lifetime Member: My Profile  My Blog  Send Message
FollowUp 1 of 3
FollowupID: 395897   Submitted: Sunday, Dec 04, 2005 at 13:57

Motherhen posted:

Oops - what happened to the picture i posted?
Near the Stuart Highway NT
Click Image to Enlarge
Home to reality - The dream trip is over
Lifetime Member: My Profile  My Blog  Send Message
FollowUp 2 of 3
FollowupID: 395898   Submitted: Sunday, Dec 04, 2005 at 13:58

Motherhen posted:

I give up - this website deletes anything to do with cats
Near the Stuart Highway NT
Click Image to Enlarge
Home to reality - The dream trip is over
Lifetime Member: My Profile  My Blog  Send Message
FollowUp 3 of 3
AnswerID: 142430   Submitted: Monday, Dec 05, 2005 at 07:35

Cowgal replied:

Thank you very much for your input. Part of the reason the questiosn seem to be a bit east coast centric- is that is where the media firestorm on four wheel drives is usually generated.

email address for further submission
fourwheeldrivesurvey@hotmail.com
Reply 24 of 26
FollowupID: 395962   Submitted: Monday, Dec 05, 2005 at 09:00

Member - Tonester (VIC) posted:

or email thisweekstattslottoresults@hotmail.com. Seriously, fair dinkum.
FollowUp 1 of 1
AnswerID: 142436   Submitted: Monday, Dec 05, 2005 at 09:01

Member - Oldplodder (QLD) replied:

Cowgal,

You didn't get back to me with your definition of a 4wd.

First, these are my views, and therefore can only be quoted in part of full with my permission. Contact me at auscadatgildotcomdotau.

I don't think this discussion that the media is pushing is a 4wd versus others, or others versus 4wd discussion. That is why most 4wd drivers won't give you a definite answer, they see a bigger picture. Not the narrow one that is almost darwinian in nature by trying to break up modes of transport into good and bad, and trying to push the demise of one type of transport by portraying it as floundering for survival, in this case a rampant elephant in surburbia. Elephants are one of the most gentle and cautious creatures I know.

Looking at the issues you raised, it is really is the mind set of the driver, whether it is a large 4wd , small 4wd, all wheel drive, large 2wd, or small 2wd, or motor bike.

Safety is also a driver/pedestrian mindest. I had to do a very quick stop the other day because a pedestrain stepped off the kerb in front of me at some pedestrain lights. They had a red don't walk and I had a green light. I pulled up in time. I don't think they saw me and decided to cross against the red. As a pedestrian I always wait for the 'walk' sign, even though others cross against the 'don't walk'.

I don't drive or think any differently when I drive the 74 bettle or the newer 1.8l golf in the family.
Our family of four drivers car pool the cars in the family. Son needed to move furniture for a friend, so he took the Pajero. Pajero is good for carrying 7 people too instead of taking 2 cars (used to be good for running 5 kids to school in our parents car pool). If just one or two of us, we often take a smaller car.

Have travelled (for business and pleasure) around most of eastern and central australia in the Pajero. A 2wd car would have been a lot riskier from a mechanical point of view with ground clearance and protection of the underside like sumps and fuel tanks.

Pajero gets about the same economy as a commodore or Falcon, and will last twice as long, therefore the total environmetal cost of the lifecycle of the vehicle is most probably less. The 86 pajero has more kilometres on the dial than the 74 beetle or 78 golf. The golf and beetle are on thier 2nd engines, Pajero still going strong on it's first. After all, the largest 'car' on the road, and least effecient is a 2wd.

Look forward to hearing from you, and seeing the results of your survey.

Click Image to Enlarge
John C - aka Oldplodder
In touring mode, the way it should be.
Reply 25 of 26
AnswerID: 142438   Submitted: Monday, Dec 05, 2005 at 09:09

Truckster (Vic) replied:

smells like c o w s h i t to me.

And how pathetic, trying with a HOTMAIL address? FFS..
Reply 26 of 26