AnswerID: 202532 Submitted: Thursday, Nov 02, 2006 at 12:16
Member - Tonester (VIC)
replied:
Don't like to say it, but from the way I read your description you'll have trouble proving you're missus was in the right unless you got a witness or other evidence. Right hand turned gives way to left, and if he denies running a red light and you don't have a witness...
A truck hit my right rear quarter once at a place, and it was most definitely not my fault. Unfortunately it happened near a left lane merge spot (hence used in truckies story). And the truck driver also left the scene within a few seconds.
1. Reported to cops with rego and lodged claim
2. Truckie apparently said to cops he left the scene cause he was in fear of his personal safety from me (like, huh...?) and cops let him go. Total fabrication to cops & insurance.
3. Insurance said cause damage was on the side and not on rear, with no witnesses, there is nothing they can do to prove it was not my fault. So no payout on claim. (I did spit it totally with them, and a compromise was reached in the end)
I take my learnings from this to your spot... You'll need a witness if you want to prove your story, unless the other guy is honest (by the sounds he is not), and you will be liable if you can't.
Personally, I'd set the cops on him and lodge a claim and let them sort it out. BUT don't get the damage fixed yet (esp if you are not very concerned with it). Without the cost of damage repair already incurred, you can drop your claim. The pressure of cops & insurance may make the guy see the light.
Reply 9 of 9