AnswerID: 36 Submitted: Tuesday, Nov 21, 2000 at 00:00
Greg Jones
replied:
Ive lost count of the tales of woe from people who have towed loads greater than a ton in overdrive with manuals and autos. Turbodiesels are usually the worst offenders due to the peak torque being developed at 1700 - 2000 rpm. The driver thinks the whole rig is doing it easily because things quiet down nicely in OD and how would he know if hes overfuelling anyway.
Try to remember that OD is costing 5-10% in efficiency and this has to be paid for in fuel and converted to heat. The heat goes into your gearbox oil and eventually stuffs the gearbox.
The 20% drop in rpm is not enough to compensate for the extra energy required to run OD at near full load and that is why people are surprised that you often burn the same fuel or more when running in OD than direct.
I wouldnt run my wagon in 5th unless the tailwind was pretty strong. Isuzus dont seem any worse than other 4X4s but I know of a newish TD Jackaroo that crapped its gearbox recently - yes, using 5th to tow.
Cheers Greg.
Reply 3 of 4