Site Search
Print Page Setup Profile Login
Section Image

GU Patrol 2.8 TDI .... Pros & Cons?

Submitted: Tuesday, Jul 01, 2008 at 23:27

Shaker

There is heaps written about 3.0 Patrols being "grenades", & the desirabilty & big price tag for 4.2 diesels.

So, I am interested to know what the 2.8 is like, any comments would be appreciated.
ThreadID: 59421 Replies: 8
Views: 959 FollowUps: 4
This Thread has been Archived
Thread Summary
Thread Watch Back To Forum Alert Moderator FAQ
AnswerID: 313375   Submitted: Wednesday, Jul 02, 2008 at 06:54

Stephen M (NSW) replied:

HI Shaker, the only real negative thing Ive heard/read about is the gearbox isnt as strong as the 4.2 D and a bit of turbo lag but that can be fixed up. Other than that all the other running gear the same (so Ive read). Im sure when Stefan gets home this arvo he will fill you in as he has one..... Red book figures .....4.2D Power 85kW @4000rpm Torque 264Nm .......2.8TDPower 85kW @ 4400rpm
Torque 235Nm
There was some talk/issues of head gaskets but as Stefan found out with a lot of searching (1 to 2 years on) with his it turned out to be a header tank after he also was told his head had gone so maybe not such an issue. Regards steve M

Click Image to Enlarge
What A Life
Reply 1 of 8
AnswerID: 313377   Submitted: Wednesday, Jul 02, 2008 at 06:56

Kiwi & "Grenade" replied:

Stefen has one (nsw member) so Im sure he'll be on here sooner or later to give his run down on them.
I cannt see how a 2.8lt would go well in a big patrol.
The GPS!!
Click Image to Enlarge
'Why be difficult when with a little extra effort you can be bloody impossible'
Reply 2 of 8
AnswerID: 313379   Submitted: Wednesday, Jul 02, 2008 at 07:27

Malleerv replied:

We have had a 99 Patrol with a 2.8TD for the last 3 years and have had no probs with it. Has now done 190thou/km with just general maintenance. Also my folks had a 98 from new and the only extra thing needed was a set of glow plugs as it was smoky and rough at startup. Was told there is a mod to the fuel pump to help this also but our 99 model has no problems.
They are sluggish on take off until the revs come up and the turbo kicks in. This is more noticeable when towing but you tend to allow for it after a while. We have towed a camper trailer quite bit and a car trailer also. Once your on the road and up to speed it is fine and has plenty of go even enough to pass. I can't fault ours and am happy with the amount of fuel it uses ( would always like it to use less of course) . I cant give you a mileage as I have not taken one for a while.

Cheers Matt
Reply 3 of 8
AnswerID: 313380   Submitted: Wednesday, Jul 02, 2008 at 07:39

Grungle replied:

Hi Shaker,

The gearbox is strong for the motor and has no issues. It is only if you decide to do a conversion up to a 4.2T or Chev V8 that you will "probably" encounter problems if you want bucket loads of torque. Even then the main problem is that the stub pattern to bolt them up is different and there are no adaptor kits.

The early 4.2 gearboxes had the only issues in the Patrol lineup.

Unfortunately it is an urban myth and because the 2.8 gearbox is the same one used in the 300ZX people associate it with being light duty.

I tested mine out pretty well with a Motsons box, Marks crawler gears, 4.88 diffs, 35" tyres towing a 1.5 ton camper and she stood the task well. I also navied for a guy who had one as his comp truck for the ASCC (now Tuff Tracks) and Gold Coast 2000 and we had no problems.

The only bad points that I have experienced and heard about is lack of power on take off and the odd cracked head.

I did do a big end bearing on the motor back in 2004 as it was driven hard. I then did a conversion to a TD42T and have never looked back.

Regards
David

Click Image to Enlarge
I have taken a vow of poverty...To annoy me send me money ;-)
Reply 4 of 8
Activities Index
Whole Day Fly Fishing Trips on Kiewa River for 2 Whole Day Fly Fishing Trips on Kiewa River fo
Wine and High Country - VIC
Come and join us, fly fishing for wild-bred trout in the unspoiled mountain streams of Victoria's al
The Sydney City Tour (231) The Sydney City Tour (231)
Sydney - NSW
This tour is the quintessential introduction to Sydney, making its way around the city (with a stop
Aussie offRoad Photography Tour Aussie offRoad Photography Tour
Outback Queensland - QLD
10 Day Adventure Tag Along - A travelling workshop for Photography for enthusiasts.
Digital SLR Photography 8 Weeks - Sydney Digital SLR Photography 8 Weeks - Sydney
Sydney - NSW
A practical and fun 'hands-on' 8 week evening course.
Book Now - Things To Do
AnswerID: 313387   Submitted: Wednesday, Jul 02, 2008 at 08:50

Member - Glenn G (QLD) replied:

Shaker
I have a 98 GU 2.8 TD and it is sluggish at take off but gets going at about 2200rpm.I drop it into low range to pull the boat out at the ramp to save the cluth.Once you are moving it is fine.I also replaced the Dual Mass flywheel and clutch with a solid flywheel and Excedy cluth.for a big, car not too bad on fuel.

Cheers
Giffo
Reply 5 of 8
AnswerID: 313398   Submitted: Wednesday, Jul 02, 2008 at 10:06

Member - Fred replied:

I think Stephen is quoting power/torque figures for GQ Patrol - not intercooled
My recollection is that GU 2.8 is 96 kW and 252 Nm
Mine has done 220 000 km with no dramas - not towing more than the rubbish to the dump
Reply 6 of 8
AnswerID: 313453   Submitted: Wednesday, Jul 02, 2008 at 16:12

stefan P (Penrith NSW) replied:

Well they said it would happen.....here I am :):)

Underated car,

bloody cheap to buy

Bit slow off the mark...free flow exhaust helps alot my turbo comes on around 500-700 rpm sooner than before

once rolling you will out accelerate 4.2's

You MUST be in the right gear for the situation or you will pay the price. Drop below 2000rpm and its all over red rover

Keep the coolant services up and you should have no dramas

one of the quietest and smoothest diesels going around

I am very happy with mine now 175k old and very happy with the $20000 extra in my top pocket from buying the 2.8 and not the 4.2

Cheers Stefan
getting her toes wet...was a hot day :)
Click Image to Enlarge
aussie day fun
Reply 7 of 8
FollowupID: 579511   Submitted: Wednesday, Jul 02, 2008 at 17:33

93 Navara posted:

Stefan,
A mate is kicking around the idea of doing the exhaust on his. Did you alter boost or the like or just do the exhaust? He doesn't want to go overboard and is overall very happy with his.
Ben
FollowUp 1 of 2
FollowupID: 579520   Submitted: Wednesday, Jul 02, 2008 at 18:33

stefan P (Penrith NSW) posted:

G'day Ben

Just the exhaust at the moment, I have been told by people in the know that they respond very well to a SMALL increase in boost...like around 2 psi increase. The exhaust didn't make it much quicker overall BUT the improvment in drivability was most welcome.....pulls from 1000 rpm in third from corners ect without any dramas....and no turbo lag....plus sounds fantastic :):)

Now if you want to go nuts.....bigger turbo, larger intercooler, chip it ect ect

Cheers Stefan
getting her toes wet...was a hot day :)
Click Image to Enlarge
aussie day fun
FollowUp 2 of 2
AnswerID: 313492   Submitted: Wednesday, Jul 02, 2008 at 19:47

Member - Old Girl (QLD) replied:

Well all we can say is we know 5 that have all **** themselves. Not one of them was used for touringTheir opinions were the cruiser is too expensive. We shrugged our shoulders with oh well. we bought one of them and are currently putting a Gen3 motor to play with. As a cruiser owner we would have had great pleasure in saying I Told You So but wasnt game.
The Snatchem broke
The Snatchem broke
Toyota Spa Bath
Click Image to Enlarge
Toyota Spa Bath
Reply 8 of 8
FollowupID: 579541   Submitted: Wednesday, Jul 02, 2008 at 20:05

madfisher posted:

You have confused the 4 cylinder 3lt with the 6 cylinder 2.8.
Yes we all know about the 3lt, but the 2.8s had no where near the problems.
Cheers Pete
FollowUp 1 of 2
FollowupID: 579547   Submitted: Wednesday, Jul 02, 2008 at 20:24

Member - Old Girl (QLD) posted:

Pete
Sorry but one was a 6 the others were 4. Forgot about one that got dust in the motor over WA. That makes 6.
A couple of ph calls would reveal more details, but not worth reminding them of the amount of $$ they have lost. I will only get abused. Any how thats that.
Go the Blues.
Toyota Spa Bath
Click Image to Enlarge
Toyota Spa Bath
FollowUp 2 of 2