Friday, Feb 14, 2014 at 21:39
Hi Coldee
I know you don't see it as a issue but it may help others.
A number of things to consider when mounting things.
• Strength of item being attached
• Strength of attachment system
• strength of material being attached to
In motorsport we used to work on a 25 times guideline. That is the retention system had to withstand a force a minimum of 25 times the weight of the object. This guideline was based on things not coming loose in the event of a crash and reflected the sort of forces involved.
On that basis a 1Kg extinguisher, in a crash, weighs at least 25Kg and the force that generates needs to be resisted in all directions. The extinguisher needs to stay in its bracket. The bracket needs to stay attached to the vehicle and the bolts holding it all together need to be strong enough to withstand the forces applied.
The forces can apply in any direction so fitting into pockets or hollows can leave a missile if (when) it comes loose, think roll-over.
Most brackets supplied are not very strong and do not retain the extinguishers very
well as they were designed as wall mounts for buildings, not for vehicles.
We have seen snapped brackets, broken self tappers used to hold brackets, tek screws pulled through floors and weak vehicle attachment points torn out.
Keeping them out of the passenger compartment is the safest practice but totally impractical if it is needed in a hurry so the traditional way is to bolt it to the floor just in front of the drivers
seat where it can be accessed quickly by the driver. Your backup units can go somewhere else because hopefully by you have enough time to access it.
Another consideration
Dry powder fire extinguishers used to have a terrible habit of powder compaction so that when they were set off the propellant came out and the powder stayed in.
The modern versions apparently have a coating on the powder that inhibits that compaction, however practical experience has found it is not perfect. So extinguishers should be pulled from their brackets occasionally and given a good shake to ensure the powder remains loose.
Regards
A
AnswerID:
526471