Monday, Feb 23, 2004 at 07:21
I think it is important to remember the primary reason for using an engine retatrder is to HELP maintain a constant speed while descending a
hill. BTW I live in country Victoria, not a capitial city!! So I know the bush.
I have been a heavy vehicle driver trainer since 1987. Working with many national and international tranport companies, so the information I give is
well tested. The information I will give below I will relate to 4 wheel drives, not trucks.
1. The important part of descending any
hill is to have the correct gear selected before you go down, it is always best to have a lower gear than necessary if you ar unsure on the steepness of a
hill.
2. It is always best to go down a
hill without using brakes, but we all know this is not always possible.
3. For those times when it is not possible to go down a
hill without using the brakes and when you have an engine retarder turned on (in 2 wheel drive) you are slowing down your drive wheels (normally rear), if you put your foot on the brake you have all wheels working as brakes, in normal terms this means 2 wheels (with engine reatrder), versus 4 wheels or more with a horse float (that would be required to have brakes on, either electric or hydraulic over cable) with your foot on the brake.
4. There has been extensive testing about which is the best way to use brakes when going down a
hill, one thought was slow steady pressure all the way down the
hill is the best method, and this was taught to truckies for years, but the general consensus these days is the let the revs SLOWLY(see note below) build to engine governed speed (remember it is only at high reves that you get the best engine restrdation) and then gently apply brake pressure till the revs drop down fairly low, then let the revs build a again (remember what I said in my first post, that when 4X4ing I yet to come across a
hill that 1st gear low range won't cope with (although I am sure there are some), but generally there aren't too many.
NOTE: If you have a very low gear slected then the revs WILL build slowly, if you are in a too high a gear, then the revs will build fast. Most people (particularly in urban driving) want to go down hills FAST, not SAFELY.
5. Engine retarders were designed for heavy vehicles, but some manufacturers have modified the idea for 4X4s.
6. If you see truckies using engine reatrders on flat ground they are doing it for show, not for practicality. They will get some retardation, but not as much if they put their foot on the brake (2 axles with retarder, versus 6 axles with foot on the brake.)
Wayne if you drive in hilly terrain all the tim, might I suggest that if you go down a
hill in 3rd and you have use the brakes too much, then go down the
hill in 2nd with the revs up high, I am sure you will be surprised at the results, in fact keep an eye on your speedo in both circumstances and you will probably see not much difference in road speed.
Good Luck.
AnswerID:
47676
Follow Up By: Wayne (NSW) - Monday, Feb 23, 2004 at 07:42
Monday, Feb 23, 2004 at 07:42
Big Trev,
Thankyou for your detail answer.I will keep the exhaust brakes as a bad idea and not worry about them. Just one point about the exhaust brakes only slowing the drive wheels when applied. I have a constant 4wd, there fore I would think all four wheels would would be slowed. The cost and trouble of trying to fit exhaust brakes is not worth it, I will just hone my braking skills when driving down hills.
Wayne Always Out'N About
FollowupID:
309655
Follow Up By: Big Trev - Monday, Feb 23, 2004 at 08:10
Monday, Feb 23, 2004 at 08:10
Actually Wayne, I hadn't considered all wheel drive when writing my response, but yes it is easier and cheaper to just drive to the conditions.
People always want to go somewhere faster, not safer.
FollowupID:
309659