Towing Vehicle - Camper Trailer
Submitted: Friday, Nov 07, 2014 at 11:37
ThreadID:
110063
Views:
4512
Replies:
14
FollowUps:
8
This Thread has been Archived
Pales
Hi all,
We are in the process of researching a capable vehicle to tow a Jayco camper trailer, or similar, and are hoping for some suggestions/advice, as there is probably something we have overlooked.
The car we'd go for also would also be a daily commuting vehicle for my wife, so a hilux or landcruiser or similar is out of the question...
Obviously, we want to tow legally and safely, so good towing capacities, both overall and tow ball, is imperative, but keeping in mind, we don't want to go overboard.
Is something like a Forester/Outback or CX-5 viable? They seem to have decent capacities considering what we intend to tow, and aren't too bad price wise (initial price + fuel consumption).
Any input is more than welcome, and thanks in advance.
Nathan
Reply By: Zippo - Saturday, Nov 08, 2014 at 12:25
Saturday, Nov 08, 2014 at 12:25
I agree with Manfred completely - you need to decide on the camper first, as it WILL dictate what you need as a towing vehicle.
If I read your requirement correctly, it sounds like your commuting use will be most of the tow vehicle's life. I would certainly agree that if you want a "daily commuting vehicle" then you will need to be selective in what CT's you consider. Heavy CT's and "daily commuting vehicle" don't really belong in the same sentence, just as LandCruisers don't suit most people as suburban commuters.
If you can find a suitable CT then I'd personally consider the "Japanese soft-roader" class, as they drive like a car. Just to put softroaders into perspective, I checked the Hayman-Reese listings for the Forester. Their HD bar is rated 1800/180kg for all 1997-on models. For our MY07 (which has a registered tare weight of 1355kg) the plated figures are GVM of 1950, GALR:Front 1010 and GALR:Rear 1035kg.
I have towed with this, and it tows nicely, but I wouldn't want to pull a 1500kg trailer around Australia - you would certainly know it was there.
AnswerID:
541424
Reply By: Peter T9 - Saturday, Nov 08, 2014 at 18:06
Saturday, Nov 08, 2014 at 18:06
Hi Nathan
Having towed a small 750kg camper with a manual Forester to
Darwin and back from Nthn NSW I would not recommend towing anything heavier and in fact would say avoid these smaller SUV's altogether.
As mentioned tow ball weight is a major problem with a fully loaded camper plus all the extra stuff in the back of the car. Fuel usage is also terrible when towing and you can expect about 15-16 litres/100km. Combine that with a 60 litre tank and you need to stop at just about every servo.
Agree also on problems with manual Forester. It is nearly impossible to reverse uphill or over a gutter without burning the clutch. We eventually had to replace our clutch at about 190,000km which wasn't too bad all considering.
We still own our Forester and can honestly say it is a good vehicle however not for what you want to do with it. Because we want to do more trips we have actually purchased an older Landcruiser and have found it to be ideal for long journeys and far less stressful towing a trailer
Do yourself a favour and get a decent sized tow vehicle. It will be a lot safer to tow with and give you more room for your stuff.
Peter
AnswerID:
541434
Follow Up By: Sigmund - Sunday, Nov 09, 2014 at 07:56
Sunday, Nov 09, 2014 at 07:56
Peter I'd hardly call normal wear and tear "problems with manual Forester".
Re fuel consumption, on the highway dropping the top speed by 5-10 kmh makes a lot of difference, and the absolute worst figures we got towing with an SG manual was 15 lph on the
Birdsville Tk when it was 4WD only and was mostly 3rd/4th gear work. All through the outback over three trips we typically got 400 k out of a tank before the warning light came on.
Gross trailer weight and ball weight are certainly important; folk also need to bear in mind how much load they put in the vehicle rear.
FollowupID:
827552