Friday, Apr 29, 2016 at 15:01
Phil, with the amount of alloy in engines and cooling systems today (close to 100% in many cases - and those that are only 95%, use 5% plastic resins for the other components), any company or manufacturer who says you can go 5 years without even looking at the coolant is on a par with the manufacturers and oil-floggers who reckon you can go 20,000 or 30,000kms between oil changes.
It's all about getting the marketing edge. If the manufacturer states that coolant only needs to be changed every 5 years, it's all about reducing maintenance periods and costs, and thereby gaining an edge over the opposition.
They don't give the proverbial rats rear end about protecting the engine and cooling system to give extended life. They're quite happy to have your block/head/gaskets develop corrosion after 5 or 6 years - because by then its
well out of warranty and they can sell lot of parts to fix the problem. And parts is where they make their money.
In over 50 years of owning, buying and selling probably 250-300 vehicles (I assist with vehicle purchasing for associates, friends and family), finding cooling system neglect and corrosion is so common, it's not funny.
I back away, holding out a cross, any time I look at a used vehicle with corrosion in the cooling system.
It's also the largest single reason for vehicle stoppages and recoveries - around 40-45% of vehicle failures are cooling system related.
All ready-mixed coolants and additives are glycol-based. The only difference is the minor additives. There's no silver bullet in additives that allows alloy engines and components to operate for many years without attention. They all need a regular flush and coolant replacement.
In my experience, Toyota make the best coolant for performance when it comes to protection.
I have owned 15 yr old Toyotas with part-alloy engines that still haven't had a single cooling system or engine cooling component replaced - because I religiously flush the cooling system every 3 years, and then add new Toyota coolant with a 40%/60% mix with rainwater or distilled water.
It's a formula that works for me - it's cheap insurance - and following this regimen has never let me down, as regards cooling system failures or corrosion.
Cheers, Ron.
FollowupID:
868548