Brazing question
Submitted: Wednesday, Aug 02, 2017 at 15:44
ThreadID:
135327
Views:
2625
Replies:
5
FollowUps:
1
This Thread has been Archived
Keith B2
I hope someone can help me. I am making a water-heated towel rail out of 20mm copper fittings and want to attach some heavy brackets to keep it on the wall. Brass bar 6mm x 75mm is the preferred choice to make the bracket and it would be attached to the copper tube by fusing it along the 75 x 6 edge to the bar, along its length. .
The options to join them are are silver solder or brazing. It is going into a little off road caravan and I am wondering if anyone can tell me which is the strongest way to attach - silver solder or brazing?
Many thanks
Keith
Reply By: Member - Rob S (NSW) - Wednesday, Aug 02, 2017 at 17:49
Wednesday, Aug 02, 2017 at 17:49
Hi Brazing will be stronger but probably no where as neat as silver solder.
If i was doing something like that i would use silver solder.
And use the correct silver solder, there are many different types ,basically the silver content changes,but just use a general purpose silver solder.
Plus the bracket design to the rail with a good surface area for solder.
75 x6mm bar will certainly strong enough, 3mm would be adequate?
You could use soft solder, if you drilled a 20mm hole through the 75 mm plate to put the tube through, and solder, look at car radiators they are soft soldered and go for years of service.
All depends on your fabrication and soldering skills!
Rob
AnswerID:
612827
Reply By: Ron N - Thursday, Aug 03, 2017 at 11:21
Thursday, Aug 03, 2017 at 11:21
I found 45% silver solder is great to work with (provided you clean the surfaces properly and use the right flux) and gives a high-strength weld.
Used this rod to solder up high pressure (2000-3000psi) hydraulic fittings on construction equipment for decades, and never had a failure.
In addition to pressure, the soldered hydraulic fittings have to cope with serious vibration, particularly on bulldozers.
Good soldering results always require spotlessly-clean surfaces to be joined, no matter what the type of solder used.
Lastly, close-fitting tolerances of the components to be joined, also assists in final strength.
Cheers, Ron.
AnswerID:
612832