Thursday, Jan 02, 2020 at 11:12
Here is my take Norm. Some of this information may be a little old.
VKS737
Very large network. Lots of members, ( 3000?) Can get very busy in winter, great listening. Easy to get weather, local conditions etc. Good Skeds
Quite structured. Not very flexible, expensive, especially for things like phone calls etc
HF Radio Club.
Very clubby, seems to be dominated by a handful of people who know each other very
well. It's like sitting next to old friends talking about something you have no interest in at the pub. You can't and don't want to get a word in.
Quite innovative. Less expensive than VKS but fewer base stations. Very helpful. Only 4 base stations.
HF OZ / Radtel
Never heard many users on this. No Skeds.
Reids
Many channels Expensive calls. Mainly for phone calls from what I can figure out. I don't think they have skeds.
HF touring club.
I think this is a spin off of the
HF radio club. Inexpensive. Don't know much else.
Austravel Safety network.
Seems innovative, they have a few skeds and 6 base stations. Inexpensive, $80 plus $40 for phone calls GPS logging etc. Phone calls are free once you pay for acccess. Less busy than VKS 737 Supports emergency call buitton on most radios. Like VKS they will tell you conditions like weather etc if you ask.
IMHO the Austravel Safety network offers the best compromise of price, critical mass of users and
services.
VKS is the best for lots of base stations and users but it is rigid and it can be hard to get a word into the skeds in winter at times.
It would be interesting to see what others think too. I think all offer things like SMS / messaging and phone interconnects these days. Also some like
HF radio club and Austravel offer location tracking. All may do that these days too.
If you want
AnswerID:
629296
Follow Up By: Nifty07 - Thursday, Feb 20, 2020 at 21:39
Thursday, Feb 20, 2020 at 21:39
I was a member of VKS and you are correct, it is large and does not offer any facilities such as GPS logging. They do have lots of bases and run skeds where you call them on the radio but that does not get through to family/friends.
I then tried the other groups you mentioned and ended up with HFRC because they are the only network to offer fully implanted ALE/CALM, have GPS logging, radio to mobile phone text messaging, email and you can make a phone call.
All the groups run skeds where you call into an operator, provide telephone interconnect and they all cost about the same to join.
VKS is the only network not offering GPS, mobile phone texting or email
services.
What convinced me was the fully implemented ALE/CALM. This is where the radio works out the best base and channel to use. In the past two years of extensive travels this makes it so much easier and reliable to be able to send you GPS, send SMS or email and make phone calls. Very glad I joined the HFRC.
FollowupID:
905423