Piranha Dual Battery Systems
Submitted: Sunday, Dec 05, 2004 at 21:27
ThreadID:
18345
Views:
11780
Replies:
6
FollowUps:
5
This Thread has been Archived
GazzaS (VIC)
Hi all
I saw acouple of replies to a DBS question querying the reliability of these systems. As I am about to purchase a DBS I thought to maybe make it a topic in itself. I looked at the Piranha and it sure looks simple to install - but I don't want to do it more than once.
Have also looked at the TJM system and it looks just like a P - is it?
We have a 90 series Prado TD and I want a system that will protect the electronics as
well as the DBS function. Inclined then to the "black box" type rather than the solenoid type. I have seen several posts on the Redarc (?) as a good system but not sure on its "protection" capabilities.
Comments or suggestions appreciated.
Thanks
Reply By: Member - Captain (WA) - Sunday, Dec 05, 2004 at 22:13
Sunday, Dec 05, 2004 at 22:13
Hi GazzaS
My understanding of the DBS system is that it has a "smart" control box inside the cab with LED's to show battery voltage for each battery and simply operates an ordinary solenoid, unlike the Piranha DBE isolator which is a fully electronic isolator. I do not know if the DBS has spike protection (the DBE does). I haven't used either of these systems as I have found the redarc to be a more cost effective solution.
The redarc is a solenoid but has a "smart" controller that isolates at ~12.6V and joins at ~13.6V. It is fully spike protected and at ~$100 trade price, is far better value for $ IMHO. I have
mine wired up such that a LED in the cab lights up when the batteries are isolated. This has the added benefit that if the LED comes on in normal operation, you know there is a problem with one of your batteries before its too late.
Also, I have a manual switch to join both batteries together in the event the main battery is flat (or using the winch and want both batteries in curcuit). I believe the DBS system also has this feature, but not the DBE.
Cheers
Captain
AnswerID:
87387
Follow Up By: David Au - Monday, Dec 06, 2004 at 00:40
Monday, Dec 06, 2004 at 00:40
I would buy the Redarc in preference to any other 12v battery isolator system. Here is the
information about the Redarc spike protection
None of the all electronic battery isolators let the auxiliary battery charge to full capacity.
FollowupID:
346194
Follow Up By: Member - Jeff M (WA) - Monday, Dec 06, 2004 at 17:33
Monday, Dec 06, 2004 at 17:33
My Home made Jaycar kit bit the dust the other week and I replaced it with an Arrid Smart Relay from the 12v
Shop. Very similar to the redarc but instead of being voltage sensitive it has a preset delay before switing charge onto the Aux battery.
Works fine for me as I have a 17 Plate starter battery which charges very quickly to recover from starting, then the deep cycle get's the full 14.4V off the alternator with no voltage drop.
$135 inc GST you can't go wrong IMO.
I looked at all the fancy shmancy stuff and thought that the $500 could be better spent on other things. I already have a volt meter and alarm on the dash for the aux and the surf's engine is full of ECU electronics and the smart relaly hasn't damaged anything yet...
FollowupID:
346273