Monday, Jun 20, 2005 at 08:48
Hi Mainey,
I think you know more about this subject than me. I've spent the last couple of months researching and trying to learn as much as I can on the subject. The main thing I've learned is that everyone has an opinion on batteries and charging..... and they are all different!
As to charging AGMs in parallel with normal vented lead acids, many people do it, but the detractors say they are not getting a full charge and just don't know it.
Some isolator manufacturers (Redarc is one) now state that you should not do it.
Three ways I am aware of to mix batteries, but avoid the problem are:
1. Use a Rotronics isolator, which never connects the batteries in parallel.
2. Use an inverter and 3 stage charger as you would at
home. This one is particularly useful when the AGMs are in a trailer or caravan. It reduces the impact of voltage drop over the long distance and you still get a full charge. There are some inefficiencies with this system, but they are minor in practice as AGMs charge quickly. A 3 to 4 hour drive will generally get you to full charge.
3. Use a solar system and a good regulator for the aux, but you will need to have it set up to use while driving (ie on top of vehicle or caravan).
All of these are more expensive than a normal solenoid system, but my 'research' suggests they will work better.
Number 2 has the advantage that you now have an inverter for other use when camping and a 3 stage charger for maintenance charging when you have access to 240V. Number 3 gives you a solar system for when you are camping. If you would have one (or both) of these arrangements anyway to meet your camping needs, they are probably good systems.
I still haven't installed
mine yet, but am leaning towards the inverter and 3 stage charger. Need to get my skates on as I've got some big trips planned for August and September. At the moment, I just have a 120AH AGM in the back to run the fridge. I make sure I have 240V available every couple of days to recharge. I have also recently bought a Kipor 1KVA inverter generator which extends my time if necessary. I guess that is a 4th system which may be OK for some people.
Happy to hear your comments. I've been doing lots of reading and listening, but have little practical experience on this issue.
FollowupID:
371983