Friday, Jun 16, 2006 at 13:41
I love all these people who say all these compressors are identical. They are not, even physically they are different. There are subtle differences, but they are there if you look at them side by side. I know, because I did just this.
I'm not saying that for occasional use they won't work, just don't go buying them expecting the exact same product as one twice the price, I will assure you it's not. I used to import electronics for a local wholesaler from Taiwan and China and the whole "made in the same factory" storey you always here maybe true on occasion, but don't think that because they use the same outter case they fill it with all the same parts. It just is not so. Beleive me or don't belive me - I really don't give a crap, but it's how it is. I had the choice on most products of different "grades" of product. Some without certain components, some with stickers rated more than the actual rating, identical looking of course. It is common practice. In fact I used to get shocked looks when I actually wanted my UPS's and Power supplies to ACTUALLY BE the rating that was written on them. ie They wanted to know if I wanted my 300w power supplies to be 200w or 250w. It was an expectation that I wouldn't want to pay for 300w ones, I would just want the stickers to say 300w.
In saying this though, I love a bargin as much as the next guy, and some of this "stuff made in the same factory" is not bad for what you pay for it, and it all depends on you're intended use.
As far as air compressors go, I had two cheap one's and melted both of them. Over here in the summer, we are always down
the beach, pumping 4 or 8 tyres up from 10-16psi in 40c+ temps is a common occourance.
I ended up going for the blue tounge, it runs everyday pumping my air
tank up to 120psi and is not too bad out on the track. Yeah it's a little slower, but IMHO slow and steady wins the race. ie I don't give a crap if it takes me 5mins longer, as long as I know I'm not going to get stuck in the middle of nowhere with 10psi in all my tyres (happened once before, you learn from you're mistakes!). Besides with my air
tank setup I get one tyre infalted "for free" from the
tank, then pump up the other 3. Because I have a dash mounted pressure guage and everything is hard wired, I just plug the tyre into the outlet and sit in the aircon till it's down. It don't bother me it if itakes a few minutes longer! It's easy, and for me, that's the important part.
AnswerID:
178783
Follow Up By: signman - Friday, Jun 16, 2006 at 15:05
Friday, Jun 16, 2006 at 15:05
Ah...sorry to say JeffM...but in this case,,they ARE identical..
We've just pulled a Bushranger branded one down (borrowed from the local 4WD
shop to see if they are different ??)...and the Aldi one...
even got down to weighing the piston & barrel..
the 'sparks' did a test on the motors....identical!!!
FollowupID:
435057
Follow Up By: Member - Jeff M (WA) - Friday, Jun 16, 2006 at 15:12
Friday, Jun 16, 2006 at 15:12
Well you can't argue with a good test, however what I said was not just reffering to the Aldi one. ie I doubt the $79 BigW or the $179 Supercheap or the $199 Repco or the MEGAGRUNT would be the same. In fact I know they are not, as the air inlet is in a different position on the Megagrunt to the Bigw and supercheap ones.
So yeah, fantastic, if the ALDI one's are identical then brilliant, I might even get one as a second compressor and mount it in the storage box, however I wouldn't want people reading this post to go and buy a supercheap or bigw one and belive they are getting exactly the same products because someone said "they were made in the same factory".
If you get what I mean.
FollowupID:
435058
Follow Up By: Emo - Friday, Jun 16, 2006 at 15:46
Friday, Jun 16, 2006 at 15:46
Did you really pull both units apart? I don't suppose you took any photos?
I reckon I might have to have a closer look when I pick up an inverter tomorrow.
FollowupID:
435074
Follow Up By: signman - Friday, Jun 16, 2006 at 15:58
Friday, Jun 16, 2006 at 15:58
Nah..didn't take any pics..didn't do the exersise to justify the result to anyone..just for our own interest sake (and had and hour to spare)..
FollowupID:
435080
Follow Up By: Emo - Friday, Jun 16, 2006 at 16:12
Friday, Jun 16, 2006 at 16:12
Pity, that would have been really good. I remember someone pulling a genuine Bushranger and a clone apart a while ago and whilst the wo looked identical outside, inside they were very different.
If you reckon they are the same, then I might just have to pick one up.
FollowupID:
435087
Follow Up By: Member - Oldplodder (QLD) - Friday, Jun 16, 2006 at 17:18
Friday, Jun 16, 2006 at 17:18
I was with a company that went through the same thing over 10 years ago when we were installing a piping system in a plant. Needed some valves, so looked at aussie ones, good quality and way over specced on the type of material used. Sent same spec to China and got some samples sent back, looked the same, felt the same, but doing some metalurgy tests and quality was definitely not there. But they met the spec. They are experts at only giving you exactly what you ask for, and no more. I am not having a go at them, good on them for being able to produce a product at a third of the price on the same spec. But those valves lasted less than half of the life of the aussie ones. Was critical at the time since we had a 3 year warranty on the installation of parts.
So I am always wary now. Still buy Chinese if I can see the qulaity for the price, and it will do what I want. Just don't expect anything extra as you used to.
FollowupID:
435111