Friday, Apr 27, 2007 at 08:31
Air filters are an interesting subject and been subject of
many posts - and bottom line is that there is little difference
in air flow , and virtually no effective difference in practise.
(assume engine tuned for each)
This is because even though some tests show small differences
the difference is only effective when near full throttle.
I.E. Even if you had no air filter it would make no difference
until at full throttle because all below this you aren't restricted anyway.
So why do I use Uni-filter ?
Paper filters are just a series of small holes , and dust below this size
just goes straight thru.
One of the most dangerous things to do to an engine is get a new paper air filter
before going bush - its pores flow most then.
The filter has to be pre-loaded with dust in effect by 1000km of normal driving.
The different type of operation of oiled foam means that it works from go
and works best soon after cleaning.
The paper filter has an advantage in that it normally fails safe, it just clogs
up and chokes the engine.
The oil foam type , can get into a mode where by theres little sticky oil left
and dust passes thru.
In general the foam can be better but only provided it is maintained
well
which I find easy on trips.
By far the biggest danger is it not being installed correctly or over oiled.
If you end up with one never wash it in petrol as over time this weakens
foam and pieces could end up in your engine.
Also clean it regularly (5000km max)
Most of air filters tests I have seen via internet links do not use
dust of same characteristics as we get in Australia and results are suspect.
To validate my Patrol's air filter - I attached a vaccum hose and sucked air
thru it whilst monitoring the air flow meter voltage.
Paper and Unifilter were much the same - but playing with folding of outer layer
in various ways caused increased air flow, above that of even no filter
and so I now do it this way.
Paper filter is fixed and could not therefore be adjusted to match Uni.
Robin Miller
AnswerID:
236095