Friday, Apr 11, 2008 at 19:11
There is obviously a lot of differing
views on this question, until I purchased my current vehicle I'd never owned a diesel before, mine is a CRD.
I thought I'd do some the research so that I was more informed. Research I have undertaken indicates that it is fairly clear adding petrol, either mistakenly or deliberately, to diesel fuel of a common rail diesel engine is HIGH RISK.
From what I have read the "lack of lubricant in petrol" can very quickly kill the CRD's high pressure pump. CRD engines have a finer tolerance in the injector parts because of the higher pressure and it is critical that these parts are lubricated, diesel also acts as a lubricant.
Petrol will also cause damage to gaskets, "o" rings and seals. I also read that while kerosene may not cause as much damage as petrol it is still hazardous to the engine.
Diesel fuel is 15% heavier than petrol and packs a bigger punch that is why diesel engines produce more torque than petrol. Petrol has a higher octane rating making it harder to explode by heating.
From the research it seems that petrol in diesel could not explode at exactly the same time as diesel and could actually decrease the density of diesel, if enough was added, which would in turn reduce the punch of diesel. Although I think that 5% would not have any effect in terms of reducing the diesel's punch.
However, I am skeptical that there would be any increase in power and I'm certainly not going to try and find out.
It also seems clear that older diesel engines can tolerate petrol more than modern CRD engines, that would be why those people who have added petrol to diesel in older diesel engines have not suffered any damage.
It is fairly clear from what I have read that if you mistakenly put petrol in the diesel of a CRD engine there is a definite point of view that you shouldn't start the engine, you should push your vehicle out of the road and drain it out or call the dealer.
What people need to be aware of is that mixing petrol with diesel either by mistake or deliberately and as a consequence damage is caused to the engine it is NOT a warranty issue you're on your own.
Depending on your insurance policy you may have a claim IF petrol was mistakenly mixed BUT when it is done deliberatly it would be contentious if a legitimate claim exists.
AnswerID:
298021