Thursday, Feb 26, 2009 at 18:07
GPS Fleet tracking of assetts is already available and the more vehicles the cheaper it gets! That said it isn't cheap, around $1800 per vehcile for the unit and then the tracking costs for moving maps etc.
I have a couple of them in my boat and 4wd etc - and was able to track my vessel all over the estuary at mandurah and out to sea as well.
Can't see why it wouldn't work for the fire brigades controllers with a few exceptions like heavy tree canopy cover obscuring sattelite tracking signals and the aforementioned smoke etc.
Having said all that....
Even "experts" in nav - those trained and qualified like pilots and skippers - have to do HEAPS of practical training in real world situations - to gain whats called "instrument proficiency", i.e. the ability to fly a plane (or navigate a boat) at night in total blackout (new moon) conditions - for pilots inside full cloud cover for ex on instruments alone.
Even then, pilots and skippers sometimes still get "disorientated"....technical speak for fricken lost!
I know it happened to me once entering Balla Balla creek in the
Pilbara at night on a new moon night - the entire waterway has no navigation aids - no lights, no marker posts, nothing as a point of reference - your on your own - you, your chart plotter and a pitch black sky.
Even tho I had been in there a LOT of times in various conditions of light and dark, this one occasion - I managed to get inside the creek mouth from the ocean OK, my
young fella on the bow with a big torch, had heard in the day prior about a big crock that had moved into the creek - and so instead of guiding me to the mooring and ramp - as we'd discussed, he started scanning around for "crock eyes"....and suddely i became disorientated, even tho i had a chart plotter I was travelling slow and it's updates were a bit slow and next thing Im doing circles, and headed back out to sea instead of up river...to the mooring - it took a good look at the sky (
southern cross) to get my bearings again and get my shiate back together...
That out the way we had no further dramas - but pitch black or smoke out conditions are VERY disorientating even for trained pros..
Put that same scenario down to volunteers, who aren't qualified/ trained to navigate, in smoke out conditions in a fire, and I really don't think the "technology solution" is the "magic bullet"
solution that many think.
I did do 8 years as a Forester / pro fire fighter here in WA's southwest and largely we didn't have that GPS technology available to us.
We fought some big pine fires and yes we lost equipment (low loader trailer) but luckily no lives at that time...and yes a couple of our crews got caught with wind changes and had their trucks burnt - but all survivied.
Non of them said afterwards that a GPS would have got them out of trouble, more often than not, they got bogged in a creek and the fire caught up to them or couldn't turn around on narrow tracks in steep country to go backl the way they came etc.
I'm not saying such trucks shouldn't have such equipment as a GPS / chart plotter - car navigator call it what you will - I would just be a bit sceptical about the average volunteers ability to use such equipment to any great effect under emergency situations as described.
Theres probably other things they could be doing like using heat refelective sheilds and watersprays etc to survive that relying on a electronic gadget in a panic.
Simple errors like wrong datum for the chart / map can put you off a track in meters on steep narrow track forest country and driving thru impenetrable smoke by GPS sounds like a recipe for collision head on with other firefighting vehicles or personell.
Just some observations from the real world about GPS and what it can / can't do and what operators might / might not be capable of.
They are good but not infallible....lots of professional fire fighters fought a LOT of fires for a lot of years without it....
Yes it'd be handy - but not some magic bullet IMHO.
Even GPS can get you into strife no matter how good you think you are!
A panic situation in a forest fire isn't a good time to start to learn what you don't know about GPS nav IMHO.
How much time and $ do the CFA and volunteers have to invest in becomming expert navigators and when those volunteers leave the organisation - what skills and value of training experience has been lost?
CFA here can'keep their people, they would do better IMHO to focus their energys on keeping the staff they have rather than wishing for gadgets for the truck.
Case in point - my own eldest son was for a long time a volunteer SES & CFA member in our local town.
We have the longest river in the southern hemisphere, in our area (Blackwood) which has flooded in the past cutting people off for days, we have had 4wd tragedys with kids drowned trying to cross the river in flood etc etc
Of course - who gets called out when theres a tragedy?...
Yep the volunteers - to traffic accidents, floods fires drowings fishermen lost off the rocks and so on.
At a traffic accident - mother trapped in her car after a crash, pinned by the legs - out comes "the state of the art jaws of life" - yeah a $2 hacksaw from Bunnings!
Ever sat trying to comfort someone injured while cutting them out of a wreck with a hacksaw for HOURS!
Thats what the authorities think of their volunteers - supply half azzed equipment!
The same SES organisation decided to supply a rescue craft for floods etc. Eldest son is a qualified skipper - so he researches the SES specifications, for rescue craft and gets pics of vesels supplied for up north where creeks flood about once every 10 years...RIB type alloy things with twin donks etc etc - al the safety gear for the operators!
Makes recommendation to HO thats what they need!
What do they get?
A pressed tin punt and outboard from some mate of the guy in charge at HO!
Not fast enough too counter the current of our river in flood, no flotation, not structurally strong enough to stand up to water pressures in a flooded river, meets NON of the SES own specifications for rescue vessels.
Son told them to whack their boat, refused to operate it and resigned as a volunteer in protest and the rest of the SES team joined him - now there NO SES unit it left in that town.
Quite frankly - the quality of professionals we have running our volunteer units who seem to have been able to wheedle themselves into PAID positions, don't have the ablity / skills knowlege or traning to do the job properly, and as a result put the volunteers lives needlessly at risk in many situations thru faulty or innapropriate gear!
Who would be a volunteer in this scenario?
Trust me that the CFA, SES call em whatever you want - have FAR bigger problems than lack of GPS units in their trucks...
Even if they could get GOOD people as volunteers - those with half a brain would leave before some wannabee dipstick in charge gets them killed, thru lack of experience, knowlege or half azzed equipment.
Quite simply the volunteer units of CFA and SES etc couldn't keep good people if they got them because there seems to be a preponderance of half whits with no experience or idea in charge, who for some strange reason seem to make a career out of running the volunteer service and somehow get paid for it!
The inept leaders on the payroll are the reason the volunteers wont stay!
GPS or lack thereof is the last of their REAL problems.
Can you imagine a SES leader teaching the son who is already a qualifed skipper - hence expert/qualified navigator, how to navigate around the bush?
The SES instructor doesn't have his skills or qualifications or experience - and worse hates being corrected by a "kid" in his eyes - yet the SES teacher is barely more than a "scout leader" level of experience in navigation.
Its an insult to the volunteers intelligence to participate with "leaders on the payroll" without the qualifcations or experience to lead a group of cub scouts, trying to teach them life threatening situation survival skills.
Our Volunteer
Services have real problems to deal with.
Nuthing wrong with a nice GPS unit if funds allow, but far more important issues to deal with first in the volunteers associataions...IMHO.
These days very few "experts" with real world experience are allowed to "teach" anyone anything!
The darn school teachers have the whole TAFE system constrained such that ONLY a qualified tyeacher can teach anything - even if they have NEVER had to do it in the real world.
Unless you have a teaching degree, you can't teach anyone anything, so a master mariner can't teach recreational skippers tickets - but a school teacher who never sailed more than a bar of soap in bathtub can!
This is why our industry and work forces etc are so screwed for people with "experience".
Experience doesn't count for anything any more - its all about pieces of paper, that in the real world sometimes mean very little.
Time we got back to basics IMHO.
GPS is a nice to have as a backup but should NEVER be your primary source of navigation - the box the GPS comes in will tell you that!
Too many people place too much reliance on technology these days.
Theres a difference between "nice to have" and "must have" equipment at a fire.
GPS falls into the nice to have category, we shouldn't forget that!
Heck I remember a WA based bushtracks website selling routes for 4wders to follow along the southcoast, but because some of his routes were recorded in a different datum than the maps it displays the route against, half the route was in the southern ocean, not on land, when the route was plotted!
My 2c and thensome!
Cheers
AnswerID:
351183
Follow Up By: Robin Miller - Thursday, Feb 26, 2009 at 18:58
Thursday, Feb 26, 2009 at 18:58
Hi Flywest
You put some time into that post - and I , and I suspect you, experience some of that stuff even now - I put my effort directly where I think its required and like in this present situation I will simply go to some wrecked tracks and clear some myself while others are discussing it.
I don't volunteer any
services these days even to 4wd clubs as despite 40+ years of experience clearing trees with chainsaws I don't qualify to clear trees after some of our dissasters unless I've done 3.6hrs of offical training and most importantly have a document to say so.
FollowupID:
619463
Follow Up By: Member - Chris & Sue (QLD) - Thursday, Feb 26, 2009 at 19:59
Thursday, Feb 26, 2009 at 19:59
G'day Flywest,
That sounded like it was coming from both the head and the heart. Well done.
I think you've pointed out what I've long suspected - that bureaucracy and political correctness have triumphed over experience and common sense in this country. I wonder if there's any way we can get back to the latter attributes? A good friend's policy is 'Ignore the morons and do what you know is right', but it doesn't always go down too well with those in positions of authority (AKA 'Little Hitlers'). :-(
Just a small point - "the longest river in the southern hemisphere" is in WA? Not wishing to start an East vs West Coast war, but what ever happened to the Murray at 2,375 kms (1,476 mi), the Cooper at 1420kms or the Warburton at 1400kms?
Cheers,
Chris
FollowupID:
619479
Follow Up By: On Patrol & TONI - Thursday, Feb 26, 2009 at 21:44
Thursday, Feb 26, 2009 at 21:44
G'day Flywest
Well put, a long but worthwhile read.
Some years ago I was asked by my employer to attend a course over 6 nights @ 3hour's each on a subject I was considered by my peers to be very very good at, I attended all the same as my employer deemed it nessisary, for me to continue doing my job of 17 years, the teacher was a lad half my age that I had taught myself some years earlier, he was since the author of a manual that became an industry standard, based on what I had taught him. He looked at me in his class and signed my papers as passed with top marks. Go figure???
Just a small point Chris,
the Amazon River is in the southern hemisphere too.
Cheers Colin.
FollowupID:
619511
Follow Up By: Member - Chris & Sue (QLD) - Thursday, Feb 26, 2009 at 21:58
Thursday, Feb 26, 2009 at 21:58
Touche, Colin!
Reminder to self: Stop thinking parochially! :-)
Cheers,
Chris
FollowupID:
619515