What's this noise after Troopy clutch replacement?
Submitted: Tuesday, Jun 09, 2009 at 18:12
ThreadID:
69662
Views:
11578
Replies:
9
FollowUps:
9
This Thread has been Archived
Phoenix Owners Group
Posted this on another
forum but thought I'd throw it to a wider audience.
Had a new Daikin clutch installed in the Troopy ('02 TD, 115,000kms). The clutch now makes a noticeable chattering type noise when the pedal is out. Goes away when depressed. It's easily heard in the cabin.
Here's the noise recorded underneath very close to the gearbox after warm up. Starts with clutch in, then out, then in and so on...
clutch noise
Whole new clutch kit installed including throw out bearing and flywheel was machined. The clutch pedal has always been VERY heavy in this truck, it is VERY much lighter now to push in after replacement.
Been back to the mechanic (used before and Exploroz recommended) who had a listen with the steoscope and says the noise is 'gear rattle' and assures me it will do no harm.
Daikin say they're constantly being grilled about this chatter noise issue from 70, 80 and 100 series owners who have replaced clutches.
It's damn annoying and I still can't get used to it after 3wks. I'm also sure it would affect resale. Still wondering if I'd fitted OE whether it would be as bad.
Anyone had a similar thing?
John
.
Reply By: tim_c - Tuesday, Jun 09, 2009 at 19:12
Tuesday, Jun 09, 2009 at 19:12
Hi
John, had something similar on my old 1982 Jackaroo, but usually after/during a long trip. It would gradually fade away from constant city use, and come back after a couple of hours on the highway?!
The transmission mechanic said it was gear rattle caused by
the springs in the clutch plate being too heavy. Between the clutch friction material (outer part of clutch plate) and the gearbox input shaft spline at the centre of the clutch plate, there are a series of springs that serve to absorb the uneveness caused by the power strokes of the engine (ie. the engine by it's nature doesn't supply constant power but only on combustion which means the power is produced in a series of 'bursts' , each 'burst' corresponding to the power stroke of one of the cylinders, each in turn (ie, for a 4 stroke 6 cyl, you will get 6 'bursts' for each 2 engine revolutions - think of a pushbike where you're only pushing down on the pedals - in that case (2 stroke!) you get two 'bursts' of power for each full revolution of the crankset). If these said springs are too stiff, you get gear rattle.
However, having listened to the recording, it's unusual to hear this sound without load on the gearbox/drivetrain (ie. when you are just idling, as recorded). I also wouldn't expect it to be *that* noticable. Generally, if you get noise when releasing the clutch in neutral it indicates that the bearing on the gearbox input shaft needs replacing.
BTW: the sound of that diesel engine idling is music to my ears (at least until you released the clutch!).
AnswerID:
369178