Trailer buyers beware
Submitted: Friday, Oct 17, 2003 at 21:39
ThreadID:
7900
Views:
2890
Replies:
7
FollowUps:
6
This Thread has been Archived
Willie
I bought my heavy duty off road trailer second hand from a mate. It is a good trailer and serves me
well. This trailer is manufactured by a
well known company in
Adelaide. As I am going on a long trip next week I decided to buy a spare wheel bearing. I emailed the company to ask for details of the wheelbearing. Their one word reply was "B-type" So I emailed again to find out what type of hub and they replied 'Landcruiser'. So I repacked the bearings and whilst doing so got the bearing number. Went to my nearest Repco
shop only to find out that it is a Holden bearing and that the hubs are Holden. The trailer company gets blank wheel hubs and fits Landcruiser stud patterns to them. A bit of a con,eh? Must send them an email and see what the reply is.
Willie
Never a dull moment
Reply By: Brett - Saturday, Oct 18, 2003 at 08:11
Saturday, Oct 18, 2003 at 08:11
My trailer also has Landcruiser stud pattern but is fitted with a "slimline" bearing.
These are readily available. On my trip which covered a heap of corrugated road and no road work I made a tralier wheel bearing
check as part of my daily vehicle
check. Its easy , just grab the top of the tyre and shake it like crazy. Then it is easy to nip up the bearing if loose.
If I needed to tighten the bearing more than 4 times I would change it. and at only 20 bucks a throw its cheap.
Plus it gives me something to do when the fish are off the bite.
Brett
AnswerID:
34249
Reply By: Bob Y. - Qld - Saturday, Oct 18, 2003 at 17:37
Saturday, Oct 18, 2003 at 17:37
G'day Willie,
Was advised by a bloke from Bearing Service, to use Falcon bearings, rather than holden, as the ford b'rgs are bigger. Never did as he advised, because you can even get Holden kits at some Kmarts.
Think your case is a real rip-off, the only plus being that replacement bearings would be a lot cheaper than tojo equivalent. Safe travelling...
Hooroo...
AnswerID:
34281
Follow Up By: ramp - Sunday, Oct 19, 2003 at 03:18
Sunday, Oct 19, 2003 at 03:18
hi bob,i have a bcnu camper trailer and the bearings in it are ford from manufacture. i always thought
john who builds the trailers did so to heavy off road conditions and now you have convinced me even more cheers rob
FollowupID:
24712
Reply By: Member - Donald_L - Saturday, Oct 18, 2003 at 18:20
Saturday, Oct 18, 2003 at 18:20
Hi Willie,
Allow me to comment: I come from a very strong engineering background where bearing failure diagnostics was a daily event & I understand the problems with bearing overload when only grease packed. High loading, Loose & Over tightening of the bearings as
well as mixing different types of greases can lead to premature failure.
Recently I was in a caravan/trailer spare parts store & I was buying some hubs to allow me to have mechanical brakes on my simple box trailer. There was a large choice of stud patterns. Holden 14" Pre HQ, Holden HQ onwards, Ford passenger, 6 stud suit Land Cruiser etc and Un-Drilled Blanks. Ford 14" passenger is the common rim & stud pattern that is universal on most new caravans & commercial basic box trailers.
The hub selection were for 3 catagories, plain hubs, mechanical brakes, electric brakes.
ALL were the same casting/Machining and all used the same bearing designation.
Not sure what bearing combinations were fitted but it was for ease of manufacture that options were generic.
It would be fair to say that they are designed for normal road & highway conditions...not off road or aggresive dirt roads.
I have an off-road trailer similar to you and after every trip in the scrub I find the bearings loose so it is a discipline you must have in maintaing the rig. Even if you had larger bearing load capacity they do take a pounding but granted if they are better designed you can have a longer run between maintenance.
I think there are a lot of assumtions made when the trailer manufacturer asks for hubs to suit a Landcruser etc. The supplier just delivers the generic application off the shelf.
I had bad experiences with trailer design as in my case the
suspension failed hence there is little total engineering consideration in some brands of trailers.
Hope it is getting better for all our sakes.
Cheers
AnswerID:
34287