Portable Generators - follow up question

Submitted: Saturday, Jan 22, 2011 at 11:18
ThreadID: 83818 Views:3524 Replies:2 FollowUps:6
This Thread has been Archived
I have been reading the thread 18th Jan about Portable Generators and the "discussion storm" it generated. It seemed to get well off track for the question asked albeit the points stressed about legalities and dangers were valid and should be taken note of. But let's face it - most people are just going to do what they need to do to get power in the RV / Camper.

Can I ask some questions of those that are obviously experienced elctricians in that discussion that may help the original question which is nothing to do with wiring, modifying, or doing anything dangerous.

This in a nutshell is what I have been told about generators:

1. the honda's EUi models are inverter type generators in that they electronicly generate good clean "pure sine wave" output that is well regulated and "friendly" to the more sensitive electrical and electronic appliances, and can adjust themselves according to load so they can run quieter on low loads.

2. standard armature type generators do not produce clean "sine wave" output but are similar to poorer quaility inverters that produce an output that "approximates a sine wave" and are not well regulated in that the voltage can fluctuate with the motor and are not so "friendly" to sensitive equipment.

So questions:

1. if you were concerned about looking after your sensitive devices (camera's, laptops, TV, etc) as well as running your air con and microwave you would purchase an EUi albeit at a higher cost - bearing in mind also it must be large enough to cope with the high current devices (2.4 or better as per discussions) and you will generally have a quieter running unit?

2. if you only wanted something to really run the high current devices like Microwave and Air Con would you be OK to go with the cheaper gen set or is there proven examples of damage to equipment using these gen sets?

3. is there a difference between cheap and more expensive gen sets (non electronic) in so far as the quality of the output power - comparing something like a Honda and a cheap import?

I know there will be a lot of "we have used a cheap generator for years and had no problems" type comments, and that will probably be the majority case.

Ken
Back Expand Un-Read 0 Moderator

Sponsored Links