NRMA and Wheels, Wheels, Wheels
Submitted: Wednesday, Mar 16, 2011 at 10:13
ThreadID:
85037
Views:
3958
Replies:
6
FollowUps:
13
This Thread has been Archived
Member - David S (NSW)
Dear Patrolman # 1
Many thanks for changing the front near side wheel on 8th March at Frenchs Forest. It was a busy and narrow road and I was uncomfortable about getting under the truck.
I have been trying to get a message to you since then without any luck as you see the wheel came off approx 30klms later at night on Mona Vale Rd. Luckily it hung to the last 5mm of the hub gently swaying in the breeze. Am sure you would agree the sight of a GU front wheel travelling at 80 Klms on a busy 6 six lane road would be a little scary and could even be fatal. It would also result in some unnecessary modifications to the
suspension of the truck. Consequently I have been trying to get a message to you to throw away your little
orange cordless rattle gun.
Of course I take full responsibility. I have always double checked whenever anyone with a rattle gun in their hands even looks at the truck, but alas this time I forgot. So again I ask that you put it in the garbage bin. I really don’t want to think about the possible results of changing a wheel on a car full of kids.
Its unfortunate that your employer (NRMA) has no record of your call out. Of course if I was a suspicious person I would think that maybe there is another reason.
Dear Patrolman # 2
Many thanks for putting the wheel back on that night. As discussed the guys at Traction 4 have checked out everything and there is no damage other than some gouges on the inside of the wheel but please don’t insult my intelligence by telling me it was impossible that the first incident had anything to do with the wheel coming off.
And finally to Mr Nissan. Many thanks for last year’s recall wherein you fitted the wheel stud caps with the arrows on top. To be honest I have not got into the habit of walking around the car everytime I get in it to
check the direction of the arrows and I am intrigued as to why you fitted only 3 of the 6 wheel nuts on each wheel. Maybe the others cannot come off. Perhaps you welded them on...I had better go
check.
Reply By: Rangiephil - Wednesday, Mar 16, 2011 at 12:07
Wednesday, Mar 16, 2011 at 12:07
Funny, the same thing happened to an NZ couple in a Navara ute with mags the year before when we were going along the
Mitchell Falls road.
He stopped next to us as we were taking some photos and commented on the mad Toyota drivers speeds.
One k on there he was with one rear missing . Unfortunately many of his studs were mangled, and he had a real problem.
One of my friends had one rear go on his GU after a wheel rotation replacement in
Barcaldine. They never found the wheel.
I guess the common theory is that the wheels are too tight on the spigot and jack as they go on, and are not tight against the hub.
Never heard of it on Land Rover sas they have 16MM studs with a 6.5inch PCD so more leverage.
Regards Philip A
AnswerID:
448420
Follow Up By: Rangiephil - Wednesday, Mar 16, 2011 at 12:27
Wednesday, Mar 16, 2011 at 12:27
So I wouldn't blame the NRMA entirely.
It is a known problem with GU's unless extreme precautions are taken, hence the issuance of the bolt indicators etc.
Regards Philip A.
FollowupID:
720716
Reply By: Snoopyone - Thursday, Mar 17, 2011 at 11:52
Thursday, Mar 17, 2011 at 11:52
Had a similar happening a few years ago when in
Cairns.
Got the wheels rotated on our Berlina and next day getting down the road was getting a clunking when turning from side to side. Had done a fair distance before wondering what it was as was getting worse.
Jacked car up and rear wheel was loose.
Reason the mags are a tight fit on the hub and the
young guy who did it had put them on a bit crooked and they hadn't gone on all the way.
Cost the company an new set of studs and nuts as had ruined them.
Luckily didn't ruin the mag or us if it had come off.
AnswerID:
448468