how many volts is too many ?
Submitted: Tuesday, Aug 21, 2012 at 10:01
ThreadID:
97551
Views:
3142
Replies:
6
FollowUps:
7
This Thread has been Archived
Member - wicket
I bought a 12v car charger the other day and after using it for a couple of hours the laptop gave up the ghost turns out the main board is fried.
The laptop has a nominal input of 12 volts and when I
check the output of my ac adapter it has an out put of 12.25 volts. On checking the output of this new unit it has an out put of 13.7 volts even though it says it is 12v.
So my question is ...........is the 13.7v enough to damage the laptop ie fry the main board?
cheers
Reply By: Andrew - Tuesday, Aug 21, 2012 at 12:28
Tuesday, Aug 21, 2012 at 12:28
Hi Wicket
Supplying a voltage higher than the system is rated to receive can definitely do damage. Depending on how the laptop is set up internally it could have cooked a battery or blown the internal power circuitry, both of which I have seen before. Seems strange to do the motherboard as I thought the other things would get in the way first, however have no specific knowledge of your product and some of the tech experts on site might have a better idea.
It is also worth checking that the charger is actually limited to 13.7 as if that's only averaged you may be seeing peaks much higher than that.
I would assume that the original unit output is pretty
well controlled and matched to the laptop.
regards
A
AnswerID:
493324
Reply By: Allan B (Member, SunCoast) - Tuesday, Aug 21, 2012 at 21:15
Tuesday, Aug 21, 2012 at 21:15
Hi Wicket,
If you measured the new charger without the computer connected (no load) then I would expect that its output could be 13.7 volts, or even more. This would drop to around 12 volts when loaded. So there may be no voltage problem with the new charger.
There could be other than voltage problems with it however. It may have a high 'ripple' in the DC output or it may be producing spikes. This is especially so if it is a cheaply-priced unit.
Whoever told you that the "main board" is fried should be capable of testing the car charger and advising if it is suitable or not.
AnswerID:
493361
Reply By: Member - wicket - Wednesday, Aug 22, 2012 at 10:16
Wednesday, Aug 22, 2012 at 10:16
I rang my local laptop repairer and he felt that new car charger at 13.7v would be ok and probably did not cause the damage , the fact that it happened the first time I used it was more than likely just a coincidence. The repairer though thought it would probably be cheaper to buy a new one rather than attempt a repair ( he doesn't sell them though just repairs them )
He did
test the ac adapter and it was 12.25 whereas I tested the new car charger and it was 13.7, as mentioned above there was no load on either so the new (cheap) charger may
well come down to around 12v when on load.
I have always used a pure inverter with the ac adapter in the past with no issues I just bought the car charger for convenience more than any thing else.
Anyway it's a moot point now as I've bought a new one, a much lighter Acer netbook from OW for $308. ( love the way they do business ! )
I will not be using a car charger in the future though ( coincidence or not ) but will continue to use the inverter.
thanks to all those who replied.
AnswerID:
493382