Thursday, Sep 20, 2012 at 17:53
This is a copy of the response from Isuzu
Apologies for the perceived delay - the last communication between yourself and IUA was on the 7th September advising that you had made the decision to escalate the situation to Fair Trade, and as you may be aware by doing so the process becomes quite complex. IUA must wait for initial contact to be made by Fair Trade in order for the case to proceed.
We (IUA) were advised by Isuzu UTE
Darwin that they have not had any further instructions from you with regards to your vehicle and in turn it still remains at the dealership with the cylinder head removed. We do wish to assist you with your repair even though this is not a manufacturing defect of the vehicle - Isuzu UTE Australia is willing to assist you within reason if we can.
The failure of the engine is attributable to the fitment of the Aftermarket “Steinbauer” power module, therefore we suggest that you contact Steinbauer and explain your dissatisfaction and resulting engine damage. The Steinbauer power module is installed in series to OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) injector wiring harness and utilises a signal from Accelerator Pedal Position (APP) Sensor to judge drivers intent or request.
The module, according to Steinbauer’s information gives a 20% increase in power and torque. As you may know, to increase the power in a diesel engine via the
fuel system it can done in one of two ways: either increase
fuel pressure so more
fuel enters the cylinder for the given injector open time; or make the injector stay open longer – both result in more
fuel entering the cylinder than the Engine Control Module and OEM
fuel map. The sales invoice clearly states this is an aftermarket accessory, the warranty policy outlined in your warranty and service booklet states the Isuzu D-Max warranty does not cover damage due to alterations.
Isuzu engine designers invest considerable time and money to develop a
fuel map which delivers optimum power, performance and
fuel consumption whilst meeting strict emission regulations and ensuring that the engine meets the requirement of the Federal Government with regards to CO, NOX, Particulate Matter (PM) and Hydrocarbons which are released into the atmosphere. Altering the OEM
fuel map and power output will alter these elements and often introduce component failures due to excessive stress and combustion temperatures.
The Steinbauer module, alters the injector opening duration allowing excess
fuel into the combustion chamber giving the resultant 20% increase in power however, their own literature provides a warning about the operation. Quote – “Due to original tolerances of manufacturing the pre-set characteristic map of the Steinbauer additional electronic may offer too much or too less power enhancement. An inflated characteristic map causes more soot creation, engine misfires, bumpy idle running (variations of revolution speed), “bucking”, stop or emergency mode of engine (severe less power) or flashing of defect control lights”. Unquote
The pictures supplied by
Darwin Isuzu UTE of your disassembled engine clearly illustrate that the resultant damage is due to over fuelling - #1 cylinder piston crown has melted due to increased combustion temperature caused by excessive fuelling which has also lead to erosion of the exhaust valve due to the abnormal combustion temperature, cylinders #2 and #3 shows signs of washing of the
bore and piston crowns resulting in no carbon present and cylinder #4 also shows signs of
bore washing.
All the information which has been made available proves the engine failure is a direct result of the non-genuine Steinbauer power module and accordingly is not eligible to be claimed as a warranty repair. Isuzu UTE Australia stand strong behind the vehicle warranty and if a fault in manufacturing had have been determined, the warranty would have been honoured and the repairs carried out in the quickest possible time. This however isn’t the case.
As I have said previously IUA do sympathise with your situation, especially given your circumstances and would like to be able to offer a gesture of goodwill, with this being said, please clarify what it is you would like IUA to do to help resolve this to your satisfaction.
I await your response.
Kind Regards,
AnswerID:
495317
Follow Up By: Dust-Devil - Thursday, Sep 20, 2012 at 23:00
Thursday, Sep 20, 2012 at 23:00
Interesting.
(1) Isuzu have categorically stated in writing that the addition of the aftermarket SB-Chip is the root cause of the issue at hand due to altering the OEM ECU mapping, leading to over fueling and subsequent piston melting.
(2) Their stated justification for this assertion is (a) observations (b) pictures and (c) SB-Chip manufacturer self disclosed tech specs of the subject chip.
(3) At face value it looks like a done deal, however, this is not necessarily so.
(a) Isuzu have conveniently non disclosed the data from the ECU log which may or may not substantiate their stated claims.
(b) The mention of the SB-Chip altering OEM anti pollution settings is another red herring issue altogether and can only be considered once any ECU log data is produced.
(c) Isuzu have not stated that they have eliminated all other possible scenarios that may have caused the subject damage.
As stated by Isuzu you now have to wait for the Govt Agency/s to get their act into gear so to speak.
Just as an aside. I have had a JEEP Cherokee 05 CRD since new and added a Chip after approx 30,000Kms. Increased the performance exponentially, however, caused top and bottom turbo/I-cooler hoses to split and send the ECU into limp mode.
When adding that 'plug & play' chip a competitor (Ex mechanic wk
shop owner) I know quite
well in the 4x4 winch competition fraternity, advised me not to do so as it would result in blown turbo hoses and other issues. Doh! Doh!
After the JEEP went into limp mode (cylinder misfires) with my wife driving one day, there was serious, robust dialogue between her and myself that resulted in the subject Chip being removed for ever more. There has never been another issue with engine or anything else for that matter.
Just in case your wondering - No! I'll never 'Chip' another vehicle. Learnt my lesson and seem to have got away with it.
Regards
DD
FollowupID:
770992