Monday, Jan 06, 2014 at 17:11
Helmut,
There are a myriad of filters available for use as a pre filter, after market filters aren't generic and often they are made to specifically do certain tasks. They vary from about
2 micron size up to 30 micron size. The 30 micron is pretty useless when talking about a CRD engine and won't dewater the fuel to any extent so fibreglass flywire is probably as good for a CRD.
The idea is to have one which Filters close to the fineness of the OE filter, has a dewatering ability, can catch drops of water which collect in the bowl and has a flow rate far greater than the OE filter so it has a reserve of "free water collection" and crap collection capacity before it begins to restrict flow.
It should also not negate the sensors which detect fuel flow, ie restriction or water detection provided by the manufacturer.
Although you can use a very fine filter as a PRE, it has to have a huge filtering area for it NOT to cause a restriction to normal flow. If fine but small filter medium area it will have a short service life before it blocks or restricts.
Some vehicles have an intank pump and others are purely suction into the high pressure pump unit.
Some Watch for Water and are branded that way and are good at it but they don't attempt to filter emulsified water out of the fuel or really filter the fuel. You have to take immediate action or (before that if possible) to prevent emulsified water from going into the system.
The OE system should have warned if water was there and it appears it has but also allowed some through if HP pump and injector damage has resulted.
I agree the insurance or fuel company may be at fault but also the performance of the OE filtering is SUS if allowing it to happen so easily. Always get a receipt and keep it. A digital
pic of the servo if possible, people hate neg publicity.
There are a few things which you can do to maximize your filtering but they aren't what others normally recognize or endorse.
Under a BT50 there is plenty of room to fit two parallel plumbed additional filter units to dewater, prefilter fine rubbish, catch water drops, and still provide far more flow than just one filter can.
That maximizes the filtering because the filters have twice the area and the flow through rate is halved and the filters have twice the dewatering ability and catch ability and also provide half the restriction a single filter unit would cause. not much anyway.
That leaves the OE filter to do it's designed function without being bombarded with water and crap and leaves all it's sensor ability still operational as intended.
Many filter fitters, even some "professional ones don't observe all the operational concepts and don't fully understand how the system works and sometimes their recommendations aren't as good as they intend.
Perhaps they don't make themselves fully aware of what they are working on.
If held up in the scrub with dodgy fuel just replacing one filter can get you going and proper service can be done later, and not in the desert.
Under $300 for the gear will have you on your way with two spare filters.
There is lots more in depth concepts to consider not shown at the moment.
Just remember, nothing is perfect and anything can fail, it just shouldn't under normal use.
Cheers
Ross M
AnswerID:
523987
Follow Up By: Member - Leigh (Vic) - Monday, Jan 06, 2014 at 18:14
Monday, Jan 06, 2014 at 18:14
Hi
Ross, I am surprised that 30 micron pre-filters will not de-water the fuel to any extent. I use a Cat pre-fuel filter of approx 150 micron on my CRD that is specifically designed for this purpose. It is also alarmed with clear bowl. I should say that the filtering capacity was not the driver behind this choice.
FollowupID:
805574
Follow Up By: Ross M - Monday, Jan 06, 2014 at 18:50
Monday, Jan 06, 2014 at 18:50
G'day Leigh
If your filter is designed to, dewater, then that is excellent but most normal filters of 30 micron, ie, as fitted to a 60 series or CAV generic and other are not designed to dewater and they are around the physical size and cost many consider. Lots of them don't dewater.
The dewater isn't necessarily associated with micron size though and I did include the two functions in the one line as a general example, maybe a bit misleading.
When you begin to talk about specific functions the rules change.
FollowupID:
805578
Follow Up By: Member - Leigh (Vic) - Monday, Jan 06, 2014 at 19:32
Monday, Jan 06, 2014 at 19:32
Thanks
Ross, I appreciate your response. Cheers, Leigh
FollowupID:
805579