Roof top tents
Submitted: Sunday, Apr 18, 2004 at 21:11
ThreadID:
12168
Views:
10380
Replies:
6
FollowUps:
4
This Thread has been Archived
Highlands
We saw at the
Sydney Show today 3 or 4 brands of roof top tents - Howling Moon, Eezi Awn, Aussie Traveller, Maggliolina and Columbus. We drive a Pajero NP. We are 60 and 55 and not sure whether one would really suit us. Has anybody had any experience with any of these? We are interested in their stability, ease of use, comfort and whether they cause a lot of noise when you are travelling. We would be very grateful for any advice.
Many thanks in anticipation
Lionel and Jan
Reply By: Member - Bob L - Sunday, Apr 18, 2004 at 22:26
Sunday, Apr 18, 2004 at 22:26
Hi Lionel and Jan
We purchased a 2nd hand Shipshape several years ago and have kept it even though we now have a Tvan.
On the plus side
- they are quick to put up,very comfortable.
- No need to find a perfectly level spot ie a
rock or a bit of spade work soon levels vehicle.
- Bedding stays up top leaving more room in vehicle.
Disadvantages.
- Need 2 strong people to lift onto racks (a pully system would make it easy).
- Base camps are difficult. We use a small dome tent to save repacking vehicle and to reserve
camp site.
- Increased wind resistance in high winds (usually not a problem).
- Need to dry out at
home if packed up wet. Plastic sheet over mattress keeps bedding dry.(No worse than a tent)
We have thoroughly enjoyed our experiences with a roof top tent and still keep it for high country trips where use of the Tvan would be inadvisable.
Shipshapes and Aussie Travellers are similar and use a full size mattress, I cant speak for the fold in half types.
Stabilty- Weighs 55kg - no problems on GU Patrol.
Ease of use - Easier and quicker than a tent.
Comfort - Bed on wheels - great
Noise - No Noise at all, Head wind feels like the brakes still on.
Hope this helps
Bob L
AnswerID:
54897
Reply By: TonyT - Monday, Apr 19, 2004 at 15:05
Monday, Apr 19, 2004 at 15:05
For what it's worth we have a Maggiolina on the Jackaroo- for the 2 of us it's perfect-
cook out the back of vehicle, or preferably usually over a fire- always have a very comfortable dry bed waiting at the end of the ladder- just wind up/down- not for everyone, but after a lifetime of tents, sleeping mats, folding up/down, rain etc- this is the best compromise for us. Dear though. Cheers TonyT
AnswerID:
54974
Follow Up By: Member - Errol (York WA) - Monday, Apr 19, 2004 at 17:37
Monday, Apr 19, 2004 at 17:37
I,m with you Tony ! We reckon our Maggiolina is the bee,s knees . Even through we brough ourself,s a small van , we use the maggi 90% the time . Just for the record , we,re geting up there age wise , and we still think its the best .
FollowupID:
316687
Reply By: Billy - Monday, Apr 19, 2004 at 17:42
Monday, Apr 19, 2004 at 17:42
As you can see, we have a Howling Moon on the GU. We had it on a trailer before that for an extended trip that included some base camping.
I agree with what has already been said, but would re-inforce that you need to be mobile to be able top get up and down with confidence.
They are definitely NOT suited to base camping and we only use it for touring where camps are pretty much eat/sleep/move affairs. We use an OZtent for base
camp trips.
The HM has sail tracks on the base so you an rig a pretty quick lean-too off the side for more shelter if it rains.
We have foiund the HM to be excellent quality.
One thing that has not been mentioned, it is very quiet sleeping up top, warmer in winter and cooler in summer. At ground level, you hear every noise in the night, are down with the cool air in winter, and out of any breeze that may be about in summer.
AnswerID:
54989