Sunday, Mar 04, 2018 at 13:21
Yes, a manual transmission is better than a torque-converter-style transmission, when it comes to really heavy loads, and constant, steady loads under high ambient temperatures.
Planetary-type automatic transmissions with a torque converter develop substantial amounts of heat, and the transmission oil has to have the capability to deal with it.
You do this by substantially increasing the oil capacity of the tranny, and/or installing adequate heat-dissipation systems, by way of oil cooler/s.
In America, aftermarket manufacturers are already producing a deeper-profile cast aluminium sump ("oil pan") for the 6R80 transmission.
This aftermarket fitment is of advantage in two areas - one, it holds nearly 3 litres more in oil capacity - and it possesses increased heat radiation capabilities due to its increased surface area, and the good heat-transmission abilities of aluminium.
The extra oil capacity gives the ability to absorb more heat. Oil is not only a lubricant, and the operating fluid of the transmission - it is also a coolant, carrying away heat. The bigger the quantity of oil, the cooler the transmission runs.
Manufacturers specialise in reducing the amount of oil needed for the transmission to operate effectively, to keep costs down.
Then they reduce or eliminate oil changes to keep costs down again, and to remain "competitive" with other manufacturers - as oil change costs are factored into annual running/maintenance costs, when comparisons are made.
All this penny-pinching works against those who buy a vehicle to work, pulling maximum loads in what are many times, adverse conditions.
The manufacturers brag about "tested under Australian conditions" in their marketing hype - but the reality is, they are testing to see what is the minimum they can spend, to get a product onto the market, that will work under average load/speed/ambient temperature conditions.
I'd suggest purchasing one of the American cast aluminium deep-profile transmission oil pans, for your new transmission, might be a good move.
Cheers, Ron.
FollowupID:
888960