Thursday, Dec 30, 2004 at 12:36
Brew, I think you must realise that a "study" can produce any result that it wishes. Many studies factor in the initial purchase price difference which is considerable in the case of most vehicles but not for Prados on which I based my case. I have had 2 V6 Prados and now have a TD. I have kept detailed fuel use records and service costs. The additional servicing amounted to $96.50 at 25,000km and the 30,000km service cost $234.70. A 30,000km service on my first V6 cost me $168.40 in August 1998. Given that that was over 6 years before the comparable service on the diesel I suspect that there is very little difference in servicing costs. The real saving comes in fuel. I average $5.00/100km as said before. Additional savings come in much higher resale value (remember that the initial purchase of the TD is the same as the V6. Not so important if you keep them for a long time but I change at about 18 months. Then there is the driving pleasure off road as the diesel just cruises over difficult areas where the petrol needs the extra revs and sucks up the fuel off road. An example of off road fuel use in a Simpson crossing - I was driving a V6 and mate had a diesel (not turbo) cruiser. Our fuel use to
Oodnadatta was comparable (about22mpg).
Oodnadatta to
Birdsville I used 120l and he used 95l. We travelled exactly the same distance at the same speed. Apart from the difference in cost at the bowser in
Birdsville, the most significant difference is the greater range he had from a given amount of fuel. I know that his tanks were smaller than
mine (135 v 159) so my range in the V6 was much the same as his but imagine the range of my current TD. If I had to I could go
Oodnadatta to
Birdsville and return without filling LOL.
Now all of this is of little relevance to you if you use your vehicle as a shopping trolley / kids taxi as most people do, but to a keen off road traveller like me it has great signifance.
FollowupID:
349304