I have a beef with all of you who claim to know something about 4wd tyres.
For the record I don’t claim to know much about them myself. I have learnt a lot about all things 4wd on EO and I really appreciate that, but tyres,
well that’s another story.
I know people will always have different preferences, but I have lost all confidence in what people say about tyres.
In a recent 4x4 Aust mag a group retracing an overgrown Len Beadell track were travelling through difficult scrub (“razor sharp fire hardened stumps”) and only “MRF 14ply” tyres offered any resistance to punctures. That is to say, all common tyres have problems at some point.
When tyres are said to have performed badly or failed, readers need to know what type of terrain they were travelling through, what the tyre pressure was, was the vehicle heavily laden (what vehicle?), how many km had tyre travelled, was it a side wall
puncture, etc. If a tyre performed great, you got 90000km out of it, what % off-road, what type of off-road terrain has it mainly travelled etc.
And what about the tyres themselves, I was looking at the new Cooper ATR’s on the Cooper website. They come in 6, 8 and 10 ply, light truck and non light truck. But all of these variations have just one name – “Cooper ATR”. How can anyone say how good/bad these tyres are when they come in at least 5 distinct packages? And if you had a new 4 ply tyre fail in extreme conditions, that's more a reflection on you not the tyre.
If you’ve had a bad experience with tyres I am sure everyone's wants to hear about it - but we need to know the basic facts.
I have a suggestion for EO. Can a table (say like the one for fuel data) be set up for tyres listing of the facts? Instead of vehicle category (as for fuel), there could be a table for each tyre brand.
I heard a story a few weeks ago that a road was littered with damaged BFG’s along the side – the point of the story was that this meant nothing, just (may be) that BFG’s have the lion’s share of the market. Not sure how to deal with that. Perhaps market share information could be provided with each table (tyre and model)?
Any thoughts anyone????