Submitted: Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 07:55
ThreadID: 22214 Views:2430 Replies:11 FollowUps:2
This Thread has been Archived
I intend purchasing a tent to keep in our caravan for times we venture "off the beaten track" which is not suited for the van.

I have always intended purchasing a tourer Teepee style tent for this purpose, but it now seems that Igloo's are the in thing.

I know Igloos are lighter and easier to carry, but thought the Teepee would be much easier to erect and more functional.

What are your thoughts.

Brian DJ
Back Expand Un-Read 0 Moderator

Reply By: ev700 - Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 08:48

Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 08:48
Brian D J
Go to a camping store and have a look at the tents bundled up. The canvas ones are bulky and heavy - but look and make up your own mind.

The synthetics are easier to store through less risk of mould. Get one that is easy to erect. Usually the really cheap ones present difficulties and not the middle range or above. Look at Black Wolf, Coleman or similar.
AnswerID: 107499

Reply By: Member - bushfix - Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 09:01

Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 09:01

yep, "igloos" (domes) are lighter but "teepees" (centre pole) canvas tourers are much more durable and faster to set up. For two to six people and from around $350 to $1500 and beyond, depending on brand and size. Ducks' guts woud be Southern Cross (12oz?) canvas made in Aust while lower end of market would be something like Oztrail (10oz) (Australian owned, made in China) which are still very good tents and great value, although would probably not outlast an SC. Freedom, COI etc. are other reputable brands.
Centre pole tourers pack into a square if you leave the roof frame in. Very easy to set up. One person can do it in a few mins, just four pegs and the centre pole for friendly conditions or a few more minutes for extra pegs, guys and awning. I highly recommend them, just do your research on what is available and what use you think you will get out of it.
wot I reckon anyway.
AnswerID: 107501

Reply By: Member - Alan- Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 10:47

Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 10:47
I've just bought an Oztrail centre pole tent for the same reason. It looks well made and weighs about 19 - 20 Kg with the extra frame to allow removal of the centre pole.
That will go in the racksack on top together with other sleeping gear while we leave the van in Broome and do the GRR in May -June.
I wanted to get a Southern Cross because it's made in Australia but the cook reckons I won't get the use out of it to justify the cost!
Wonder if she's got something planned for my early demise?
Happy camping.
AnswerID: 107513

Reply By: Member - iMusty (VIC) - Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 11:07

Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 11:07
We bought the biggest dome tent available when we bought one 8 years ago.

It was a beauty.
We used it about 10 times
I thought they were the ducks guts. I mean ... "I knew".

It cost $700 ?? or something like that. We dont use it anymore, it's kinda on the market. BUT... I wont sell it to anyone here for 4 reasons.

1. Its just too damn hard to put up compared to a 'centre pole type tent'
2. They are not as durable. Strong etc.
3. It takes 2 people and 20 mins (time not including the tent fight) to put it up.
4. I like the people here and I wouldn't want to stich any-one up.

If you're in Melbourne come over and we can set it up from scratch. You'll see.

: )

AnswerID: 107517

Follow Up By: Member - bushfix - Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 11:52

Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 11:52
bugger all those bloody poles springing all over the place, go the centre pole. If we are at home and the kids want to camp out the back, I grab the centre pole tourer in place instead of the little 3 person dome, so much easier to put up and take down.
FollowupID: 364409

Reply By: howie - Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 11:11

Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 11:11
just had a look at a freedom tent yesterday ( in perth), very impressed with quality.
centre pole job $999 or with extension bit $1399. a bit pricey but will last forever.
main worry about cheap centre pole jobs ($400ish) is the floor, which will not last long in rough areas.
but you have to compare them and ask yourself how many times will i use it and storage space needed. i have not seen an igloo with a decent floor yet.
AnswerID: 107519

Follow Up By: Member - bushfix - Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 11:49

Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 11:49
I picked up an Oztrail 10 plus at the Camping show for $330! Very happy with it. No issue with the floor as I layer shade cloth on the ground first to protect tent from sharpies and rocks, and to provide a bit of a moisture barrier. I consider the floor strong enough for any "in tent" items. Can lay a canvas tarp strip across the entry for stepping in with boots if necc or across the whole floor. A canvas floor is warmer that the PE yep. Time will tell but the equivalent SC is $1495 and I cannot afford that, too rare second hand Reckon the Oztrail is good for a few years.

FollowupID: 364406

Reply By: flappa - Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 11:11

Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 11:11
How many times are you likely to use it ?

For how Long ?

Canvas tents are big and Heavy. Where do you intend to store it ?

Dome tents are light and pack small . . . chuck it under a bed, or seat.

$$$$$ is another factor.

I'm a big fan of the Touring tents . . . Southern Cross, Freedom etc, but , in this instance , I think a decent Dome tent , would be a better option. Lighter, Cheaper , and easier to store. For a couple of nights they would be suitable. Easy to put up , and pack up, and hold up pretty well in most conditions.
AnswerID: 107520

Reply By: Member - Andrew O - Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 12:31

Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 12:31
I've owned an Oz trail tent for a year now, and probably spent about 40 nights in it. Here are my experiences:
1. First centre pole replaced (with no real problems) under warranty as it slipped about 5cm during the night - no matter how hard I tightened it
2. Second centre pole had the screw threaded - obviously a design problem - so I retapped it and replaced it with a 5mm (or 6??) bolt - now works a treat
3. One of the corner straps that holds the peg came out one night - I was able to do a bush repair, but the ultimate repair was taking it to a local canvas shop where they restictched the entire base, twice all round and four times on the corners - with a much better quality thread, and gave me a 5 year warranty on the job.

I'm now confident the tent won't let me down in a major way again - so in that regard its good. I also put shade cloth underneath it to protect the floor.

For the money spent, I still think its a good tent ... just beware of what probably will go wrong with ectended use. Having said that, my next one will be a SC.

AnswerID: 107531

Reply By: Member - Phil G (SA) - Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 13:53

Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 13:53
Check out the Microfast range of spring up tents marketed by Oztent. They come in all sizes.

I don't own one but have been away with people who do, and I've been very impressed by their strength and how well they handle the wind and the weather.

And for a caravanner like yourself, they are lightweight and take up very little room, which I'd expect to be an issue for you with the heavier canvas tents.

AnswerID: 107539

Reply By: Lone Wolf - Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 19:20

Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 at 19:20
As an owner of a few tents, like perhaps most of the others here, here is my concerns..........

I have a Black Wolf Turbo 300.

Good if Tracy & I are going together, because you can stand upright in it. Erection & takedown is quite acceptable.

I also have a Microfast M I 4.

Now, whilst it says the number 4, don't be fooled.........
However, it IS a good, quick, & VERY waterproof tent. I have had mine erected up at the top of a mountain, during a storm, and the wind would sometimes blow the thing flat onto my face, only to have it pop up again.......... no dramas.

Black Wolf takes a lotta room though..........

AnswerID: 107579

Reply By: Sand Man (SA) - Thursday, Apr 21, 2005 at 00:16

Thursday, Apr 21, 2005 at 00:16

If you are looking for the best tent providing the most practical living arrangement, the OZTENT RV would have to be hard to beat.

How many people find themselves in a hopeless situation when the heavens open up and you are trying to cook.

IMHO any tent must have a sizable awning to provide under cover living space.

I like the idea of having the tent backing up to the vehicle. This allows practical access to the back of the vehicle, under cover living space and the tent area at the rear, for sleeping (etc) in.


I'm diagonally parked in a parallel Universe!

My Profile  My Blog  My Position  Send Message

AnswerID: 107624

Reply By: Member - Melissa - Thursday, Apr 21, 2005 at 00:23

Thursday, Apr 21, 2005 at 00:23

Plenty of comments made already re the pros and cons of both style of tents but I'll add my 2 cents worth anyway. Over the years we've owned two canvas pyramid style tents and a synthetic dome style tent. Having used the latter for about 5 years in many different conditions, climates and in every state of Aust. we would not go back to canvas tents. The obvious benefits of the synthetic dome tent are that they pack up much smaller and are significantly lighter than a comparable sized canvas tent (in your caravan you could tuck it away and never know it was there). When damp they dry out much more quickly than canvas and are less prone to mould. In hot humid weather you can leave the fly off and you'll find the tent itself breathes much better than canvas. Get one with plenty of windows you can sleep comfortably in even the most hot, humid conditions. Also, IMHO the dome tents can stand up to windy conditons better - remember that the tunnel/dome tents actually originated in mountaineering where they were specifically designed to stand up to the harshest of conditions. As for long term durability, you get what you pay for regardless of whether its canvas or synthetic. Buy a good tent, look after it and it should last you for many years. We bought a good dome tent and found that it was wearing on a comparable level to our previous canvas tents. Hope my comments are of some help.

:o) Melissa
AnswerID: 107626

Sponsored Links

Popular Products (9)