Sunday, Nov 06, 2005 at 00:46
That site is interesting reading and what he says is certainly true for many lamps.
However, Lightforce sell a driving light (the XGT I think) which is the same case, lens, reflector etc as their HID lamp but with a halogen.
It is possible to design a lamp to work equally
well with halogen and HID. Whether a particular lamp functions
well is pure luck unless designed to do so.
I have a set of Narva 175's that I have fitted the H3 HID replacements to.
1) The increase in brightness is amazing.
2) The issues noted on Daniel's website do have an effect on
the spot.
The spot is not round anymore but a vertical oval. It is still reasonably coherant however and penetrates a LONG way.
3) Fitted to the 'spread' beam appears to have had little to no effect on the beam pattern.
I'm happy with it but then again they are not the main headlights either and glare to other drivers is not an issue as you can't use
driving lights with other drivers ahead of you.
Currently in Oz, I believe, all of these fittings are not legal for road use (neither are ANY of the high output halogens with colour temps higher than 4300k either) and the H4 fitments I have seen all seem to have pattern issues etc. While very
bright and with a sharp cutoff (Due to the lamp itself no doubt) the light distribution is somewhat uneven.
Interestingly Narva list in their catalog an H4 HID Hi/Lo replacement kit, so some brand names are producing theses kits. I had a look at a kit similar to the Narva which has an HID low beam and a Halogen high beam. The low beam light was
bright, reasonably even, and very white. BUT...when you switched to high beam and the HID capsule went dark and the halogen came on...It was like you had switched your headlights off. The high beam halogen was NOWHERE near where it needed to be to form an adequate high beam. The light just scattered everywhere. Yuck.
I guess the bottom line is: If you want your car to be legal don't retrofit HID capsules to ANY original equipment lights on it. Spots/
driving lights fitted after manufacture is probably OK but you are taking your chances as to whether you'll get a good result. Stick to lights available with both HID and Halogen versions where the optic of the lamp are similar/identical.
Oh and $650 is way too much to pay.
Peter
FollowupID:
391645