Friday, Jan 27, 2006 at 12:01
Stephen F10
Thank you for raising this issue. As I responded on another current thread on this
Forum (where a respondent strongly suggested newcomers shoud read earlier postings before asking questions) the problem with doing so is that technology constantly changes - and what may have been true some years back is no longer so now.
All my early books and articles that discuss parallel charging advised not to attempt this with AGM and non-AGM batteries. At that time virtually all AGM maker warned very strongly against it.This was emphasised so strongly in their data sheets that it was not possible for a technical writer to suggest otherwise without incurring legal liability by doing so.
The main (and valid) reason was that, because AGM batteries have very high charge acceptance (ie they grab almost all of whatever current is available), they will inevitably starve (or even discharge) any non-AGM paralleled battery. There was also a suggestion that (in vehicle applications) so doing may damage the alternator.
Over time it became clear that what the battery makers were concerned about was direct parallel charging with no safeguard for the non-AGM battery. That concern still exists - and is well-founded.
In the meantime howver the widespread acceptance of
Redarc and other voltage sensing relays removed the main concern. These relays only parallel batteries for charging when the non-AGM battery (typically the starter battery) has reached about 13.6 volts.
Further, if the AGM battery does discharge the non-AGM battery, that relay opens (at about 12.5 volts) to once again isolate and protect that battery.
Some people have got away with parallel charging with no such safeguard - but in every case that I have checked of this - this is only because that the connecting cable was very long and/or light. The resultant voltage drop was preventing the AGM charging at full rate.
I am still a bit concerned that an alternator could be damaged if attempting to charge a very large AGM battery bank in high ambient temps, but in practice I am not aware of any actual such happening.
To cope with changes such as the above, all of my books on this and related subjects are printed in very short runs - and updated every three/four months if necessary. On the subject of parallel charging - they now advise much as above, as have all my published articles for the past two or so years. There will however inevitably be a few references still around to the contrary and I am grateful to you for bring one of them to my attention.
On a similar topic I receive emails every now and again re solar and electric fridges. Very early copies of my 'The Campervan & Motorhome Book' advised that 110-litres was aboiut the largest fridge that can be comfortably run from solar. But since the original publication (in early 2001) fridges have become more efficient and some 120-watt solar modules are smaller than early 64-watt modules - so that 110-litres is no longer relevant. That change too has long since been made.
I do post these changes on my website from time to time - and will be adding a comprehensive update shortly.
Collyn Rivers
AnswerID:
151261
Follow Up By: StephenF10 - Friday, Jan 27, 2006 at 23:12
Friday, Jan 27, 2006 at 23:12
Collyn,
Thanks for clearing that up.
Stephen.
FollowupID:
405015