Saturday, May 20, 2006 at 17:19
Hi Rod,
My experience, all different driving conditions over tens of thousands of km....
All land cruisers - pretty much factory with a bulbar:
Litre per 100km
V8 - 14.95 (50% time with Thule roof box)
TD - 13.85
D - 14.65
V8 Best actual range (not estimated; actual) was 1060km on both tanks.
Average calculated range based on consumption – V8 - 958km, TD – 1051km.
V8 is amazing in the sand, doing dunes at
coral bay in the V8 the TD wouldn’t have a chance at………
Mate has got a 6cyl 4500 that is very thirsty, when towing a car trailer he used both tanks in 300km! 48 L/100km (driving it very hard but)
Cheers,
Barks
-------------------------------------
This is what I posted a few weeks ago…
I've had both a TD and V8 cruiser.
did 230k in the 80 series TD and I'm up to 50k in the 2003 V8.
For work I am currently driving at new (5000km) standard diesel 100 series that gets worse econ than the V8.
The V8 is cheaper to run (overall) than the TD and way cheaper than the naturally aspirated D.
I took a showroom TD for a
test drive the other day to pass some time - what a noisy, rattly, SLOW and unenjoyable experience......
TD econ
Pilbara family stuff - 13.85 l/100km - (many long trips at 110 kmh)
V8 -
Bendigo town - 14.99
V8 - Camping CT and roof box - 16.64
V8 towing 4T boat and roof box - 25.63 (1000km trip, 100km/h full noise - great fun!!!)
Check out the NRMA website go to vehicle, operating costs - get a surprise!!
--------------------------------------------------
Fuel costs (not including service costs) for 50,000 km with ULP $1.30 p/l and Diesel $1.40p/l:
V8 Cruiser $9746
TD Cruiser $9692
Std D NA 100 series cruiser $10,253 (I drive one for work for two weeks every month - brand new Thrifty (up to 30thou km) absolute pigs.
My gutless 2WD 4cyl pertol Mazda ute $6500.
Estimate V8 cruiser on gas $7500 (gas at 60cpl) (not worth it?)
VL calais 6 cyl - $8340
Mates 2.8L TD Patrol - $9751 (13.93 k/100km - he sold after 8 mths from new)
-----------------------------------
TD Cruisers are a lot more expensive to maintain - nearly 80% of the service manual is for the TD - and not the cheap stuff either. V8 is oil every 10k, with a 40k major that cost me about $380 at Bgo Toyota (from memory?) anyway it was pretty reasonable.
Depreciation? -
check out the NRMA website as depreciation is included in the operating cost calculations.
Insurance - I think
mine is about $500 - $600 pa? something like that...
When Diesel gets to be about 80% the price of ULP (if it ever does) then I will think about going back to a TD.
AnswerID:
173676