Friday, May 26, 2006 at 09:52
I have both at the moment, 98 2.8 TD and a 99 4.2 TD, the 2.8 isn't too bad in standard form, it lacks in bottom end power until the turbo kicks in around 2000rpm, after that it goes as
well as a 4.2, that problem was fixed with a 'motsons chip' $1500 new, 7-900 2nd hand, no more slipping clutch on
hill take-offs and goes slightly better than the 4.2 which has dump pipe, exhaust and tune-up done.
A former member on this site, 'Grungle', has a 99 GU which had a 2.8 in it with motsons and towed a KK on a regular basis, Had no problems and was a great tow vehicle for general travel, the only place it lacked was in the slower, crawl situations, he put in the lower
rock crawling tranfer ratio's, this helped, but in the end he did a 4.2 conversion as he did a lot of competition style off roading where the bottom end power of the 4.2 is better.
So unless you're doing a lot of this style of off roading a 2.8 with a motsons will not only go and tow better than the 4.2, but will also consistantly return 7 - 8 km/lt (12.5 - 14.2lt/100km) compared to the 4.2 at 6.5 - 7km/lt (14.3 - 15.4lt/100km)
The reason some of us prefer the 4.2 is the proven reliability and simplicity of the engine, as
well as the better bottom end for 'fairly serious' style off roading.
BTW, our 2.8 has 250,000 k's on it with the only problem being the injector pump, which is a common problem on 2.8's, had the spacer plate fitted, $120, this solved the problem on 90% of them, unfortunately
mine was one of the very few where the pump went again 6 months later, replaced it with one from the wreckers off a low km exchange eng $600 supply and fit, no problems since.
If you're still undecided and live in
brisbane you are quite welcome to take ours for a drive.
Avagoodn
Pezza
AnswerID:
174844
Follow Up By: Member - Pezza (QLD) - Friday, May 26, 2006 at 09:56
Friday, May 26, 2006 at 09:56
Just read your previous reply, "RACV" you obviously live in 'mexico', bit far to go for a
test drive. Maybe some-one down that way has one with a chip in it?
Avagoodn
Pezza
FollowupID:
430929