Wednesday, Jun 07, 2006 at 23:59
Paul,
This is plain FUD: fear uncertainty and dread - what are the alleged massive failures you speak of? You are not arguing a position at all, nor making a recommendation - you see a place for Biodiesel, but can't say where.
For sure - Biodiesel can be made in my backyard or yours - in fact, in your kitchen for that matter. It will have varying properties - just as diesel from fossil fuels has varying properties. In the case of Biodiesel, this is affected by the feedstock out of which it is produced.
So, I don't expect anyone to warrant an engine or injector when I am using
my home brew (although they couldn't be expected to be able to work it out).
However, I don't use
my home brew.
All retail Biodiesel in Australia complies with the Fuel Standard (Biodiesel) Determination 2003 - there is a big financial incentive for this to happen - a rebate!
The standard, especially the testing regime is a higher standard in the applicable details than any petro-diesel sold in Australia.
Thankfully the commercial Biodiesel suppliers warrant their product, in the same way that engine failure caused by crap petro-diesel from the major suppliers (it has happened to me - the crap fuel, not the engine failure) is a problem for the supplier and not the vehicle manufacturer.
All diesel sold in France, for instance though, contains 5% Biodiesel!!! even though it still complies with the Diesel std you mentioned.
Which fuel standard equipment has been developed for is a little irrelevant - for one thing, many of the vehicles and especially the injectors, are older than the standard. For another, just because they were developed for one fuel standard doesn't mean that there will be problems using some other fuel.
The common position you mention is rather irrelevant too, because it dates back to 2000 - 6 years ago, when it said:
The world's biggest diesel fuel injector equipment (FIE) makers -- Bosch, Delphi (formerly Lucas), Denso, and Stanadyne -- just unveiled new "common position statements" warning of denials of warranty claims if fuels fail to meet certain quality standards.
NOTE THE LAST PHRASE. For sure, if they knew of the massive failures you allege, they would have made a very big point of it - and they haven't.
Sure - if there are quality standards issues, denial of warranty claims is understandable, but they will not deny warranty claims just because you used Biodiesel.
There is plenty of research indicating that Biodiesel has no detrimental effect on fuel system components. Major companies like Scania and Mercedes Benz are prepared to fully support the use of Biodiesel in their vehicles in Scandinavia and other European markets ... and guess where they get their injectors from - the same bin that supplied them to all sorts of other manufacturers.
There's always some risk in the world ... but worrying about Biodiesel's effects on my engine is not a high order problem.
Ciao for now
Andrew.
FollowupID:
433409