Why do they do this?

Submitted: Thursday, Sep 14, 2006 at 08:31
ThreadID: 37705 Views:3975 Replies:5 FollowUps:0
This Thread has been Archived
I was looking through the August copy of the VKS Network News.

Canning Stock Route - Wet & Wild. This caught my attention.

2 vehicles fitted out for the trip, A Defender and new Prado and were going to take 5 weeks to do the trip. So far so good.

Because of the rain they had gone from south to north to allow the track to dry out. Good move.

They were there in May, and as they say in the article they did not see many other vehicles. Someone has to be first to do the trip.

Arrived at Well 51. All the hard work is over. A run into Bililuna, then down the Tanami and home.

Not far from Well 51 is Lake Gregory. The Lake was flooded. The Lake was still flooded at the end of June when I was there. But they decided to drive through the Lake.

They walked 300mt and marked the track. Firm on the wheel tracks but soft mud just off them.

What were they thinking. When I was there, and that would have been a good 4 weeks later, and the water level would have dropped a bit more by then I still could not see where the water finished and the track started again.It was hard enough just driving through the mud to have a look at how much water was out there.

The photo that is with the article shows how much water is around. They also say that because they did not hear( via the VKS network) of any one else coming to grief on that crossing it must be alright.

That area is so flat and Lake Gregory so big that even if they had made it through the first section there would have been more water ahead.

5 days they were stuck in the mud, and they had to hand winched 150 meters to hard ground. Just as they had reached the water edge another convey turned up to assist but they wanted to finish the recovery they stated.

There is a bypass road marked on the map, that is the way we went, that still allows you to go to Well 51 and the drive around Lake Gregory. Even then there were bypasses around the bypass track because of the water.

They used the HF radio until the batteries in the vehicles went flat but kept one to keep the Sat phone charged. Both vehicles were diesel but because of water getting into the ECU of the Defender it would not start. The Prado sank to the diffs so I would think that it might have suffered the same fate.

So what did they do wrong.

Drive through a water crossing where the exit can not be seen.
Drive through a water crossing that was not necessary. There is a bypass road.
Having both vehicles in the water at the same time.

Why do they do this?

Wayne
Back Expand Un-Read 0 Moderator

Reply By: Pajman Pete (SA) - Thursday, Sep 14, 2006 at 08:37

Thursday, Sep 14, 2006 at 08:37
"They also say that because they did not hear( via the VKS network) of any one else coming to grief on that crossing it must be alright."

Because dead men tell no tales? ....
AnswerID: 194478

Reply By: The Landy - Thursday, Sep 14, 2006 at 09:08

Thursday, Sep 14, 2006 at 09:08
Wayne,

Looks like a good study in risk management, looks like they stacked the odds against themselves. Interesting about the ECU in the Defender, one of the reasons I have gone back to a TDI without the ECU.

Cheers
AnswerID: 194479

Reply By: Willem - Thursday, Sep 14, 2006 at 10:38

Thursday, Sep 14, 2006 at 10:38
Hi Wayne

Basically, they are unskilled travellers.

It just goes to show that Australia really is a lucky country, where people with little knowledge, basic skills, poor education, no nouse or very little common sense can still earn enough money to buy expensive vehicles and go travelling.

I heard of this saga when it was happening some months ago and asked the same question. Why did they not take the bypass track?

GO FIGURE as the Californians would say.
AnswerID: 194493

Reply By: traveller2 - Thursday, Sep 14, 2006 at 12:28

Thursday, Sep 14, 2006 at 12:28
Yes it beggars belief what some people do.
Reminds me of the time we were in Birdsville back in the early 90's heading across the desert and a bloke came up to our group (of two) to ask if he could tag along across the desert as he was by himself with his family in one vehicle.
We pointed out that while he was welcome subject to a few considerations we were heading up the Colson direct into Alice as you could in those days.
We also planned a few side trips and were going to be out there for at least ten days.
Upon asking a few details as to his vehicle, setup and experience, he informed us that he had an 80 series diesel, totally standard with roof rack, wife, 4 kids etc etc.
No extra fuel over what he had in the standard tanks, food for 4 days, no HF, no CB, the water was carried in 2 litre pet bottles rolling around on the floor (had twenty of them!) no extra spare tyre, puncture repair equip of extra spares or tools, was running the standard Grandtreks, no compressor or tyre pump, not even a tyre gauge.
BUT he had watched the video several times and the desert drossing would be a "walk in the park".
We advised the copper that he was an accident/recovery waiting to happen but after much discussion the copper admitted he couldn't stop him going.
He did tag along with us until out of sight of Birdsville and then took off ahead as we were travelling 'too slowly'.
We actually bumped into him a few weeks later in the Alice and he did apologise to us for ignoring advice given to him in Birdsville.
We found out that they ran out of food, water, trashed the underslung spare on the road, bludged all of the above from other travellers to get them to Oodnadatta where they arrived on the end of a tow rope after running out of fuel 10k out of town.
AnswerID: 194515

Reply By: Member - Doug T (W.A) - Saturday, Sep 16, 2006 at 10:22

Saturday, Sep 16, 2006 at 10:22
Hi Wayne
Yeh I read that too and thought it a bit silly ,Did you read Lou's story, about the last Dune on the Rig Rd;
That Group on the CSR was lucky one of them didn't come home like this
members.westnet.com.au/dtilley/camel.htm

Doug
gift by Daughter

Lifetime Member
My Profile  My Blog  Send Message

AnswerID: 194803

Sponsored Links

Popular Products (9)