Wednesday, Sep 27, 2006 at 02:23
Mary Anne,
I can not directly relate to your vehicle but I can relate to the subject of slide-on campers. I just purchased one, which is still in the US and on its way soon.
I have done a lot of research on that subject and my wife and myself have been looking around for some time before we made a decision. I can give you some of my opinions and criteria. We had a lengthy process of identifying what we really wanted and lots of backwards and forwards in our decision process. It is a major point for us because we are going to live with it for some time to come.
We have been looking at larger caravans first, because we wanted a bit more space to live in when on the road for several years. None of the caravans really took our fancy (we only looked at so called off-road). At the end of the day we considered a large caravan as too restrictive and once we made the step towards a slightly smaller living space the consequence was clear. We wanted to take the boat too (would have been on top of the vehicle - was not really a small boat) and so the idea was born to get a slide-on.
We have looked at Supreme (liked it - but requires tray on larger vehicle) and others but found them either too small or tray versions. I personally do not like tray tops since they sit too high on the vehicle. I want the camper to sit between the wheels and not above. That limited the choice.
Most locally available slide-ons are reasonably small for the toyos and nissans etc. and after adding the weights of what we wanted to take with us including water, petrol, our dive gear, photo gear, computers, batteries, solar panel, grill guard -- oops sorry bull bar, winch, dogs, wine cellar (very important) AND the tounge weight of a boat trailer we did not see any chance to do this with a 3/4 ton truck or even with a 1t truck like the F-250 .. the total weight would exceed the payload of the truck by far ...
consequence was .. F-350 dual rear wheel .. at the time Ford stopped producing them and had only the chassis version anyway .. not a decent trim level, bed or crew cab for that matter so we decided to go the full monty and bring in our own truck.
Now this is not about the truck but the camper. Since we decided to bring in a truck we were not too far away from bringing in a camper too ... which we did.
I went through that process... timber frame, metal frame, fiberglass, alu panels, foam insert .. you name it ... at the end I was more confused than in the beginning. Now in the US you have a selection of 30 or 40 companies doing truck campers as they are called there , Northstar is one of them and that model is sold here (there is an importer).. There are many many more .. I read forums, posted questions, talked to dealers, factory reps, people I know in the US etc etc ..
I had as many arguments pro a certain brand or constructions as I had against ...
Timber is a bit out in the US mainly in the wet areas and some brands get a bad wrap about leakage .. but to be honest .. moisture is not really a problem here is it ?
well QLD maybe .. a fiber glass shell gets the most votes for stability with an underlying alluminium frame .. but then again some have bad experience with sloppy frame construction where timber looks easier to build and has more flex ... these are the arguments I read on the forums and I get told. I have no own experience yet with
mine since it is not yet in the country, but will be soon.
Some reported cracks in the shell and would prefer panels .. Slide-on off road is not really that common even in the US...
mine is sold "built for the back roads" ..
well we will see ... it was not why I bought it ..
I have decided to buy a pretty raw version (not many extras) to fit it out myself because some items I want are not very common in the US and not available in Australia... for example .. we want a ceramic
cook top running on diesel. I do not take LP on board .. can't be bothered with a third type of fuel .. diesel for the truck and petrol for the boat is bad enough. I have not yet solved my water heating/shower issue. Still need to find a water heater I like - non LP. My research resulted in some more knowledge and tricks the boys accross the ocean do ..
very important is the tie down mechanism.. solid tiedowns and turnbuckles with solid anchors on the camper to make sure it does not move a bit or jump ..
There a rubber mats on the market (1cm thick or so .. quite dense .. water can penetrate through) which make a good underlay and give the camper a bit of a
suspension... they have to be firm though for a heavy one that you do not get too much of a spring effect ..
The differences I think are mainly in the features and extras and looks rather than the construction too much when you compare fiberglass against fiberglass or panel against panel ... at the end of the day I said .. what the heck .. if it will break I will fix it and other criteria than construction wre important to us.
Pop Top or not: Pop tops make it more versatile, smaller, lighter, easier to go
places. Cons are less insulation (hotter or colder depends where you are), less comfortable and not many shower versions available.
Well we wanted a shower and we did not want the tent top so the pop top was out ..
In the US the truck campers are mostly very big .. 10' floor space and 3400+lb
People load them on top of single rear wheel truck and I really wonder how that can work without more disasters ..
well it can not work here and especially not in the bush ... weight is an issue. They drive mainly bitumen. The smarter ones put these monsters on a dual rear wheel ... now duallys have some problems on sand and especially the stock trucks (without diff mods) are not too good in sand ...
With a truck camper on the back you are much heavier and have to be even more careful not to dig yourself in .. the US trucks have their own issues here .. but thats not important now for this subject.
My criteria was to find the lightest truck camper with the interior size we could compromise on and with the least overhang in the back ... which I found and purchased.
Now .. beeing through that process I can say that the only justification to use a truck camper is when you tow a boat .. if you do not tow you are probably better of with a smaller solid off road van or a good camper trailer ... the truck camper on my truck will give me some giref in the future , I am quite sure, and I guess when you do not use a heavy duty truck like I do you will have some grief too unless you compromise dramatically on weight or get a dual axle mod for the truck.
I am still convinced I made the right decision for myself, but we have to be prepared to leave the boat behind at times and leave the camper on its legs and take the truck on it's own for certain
places .. but that can be done with a van too (unless you tow a boat). If you do not want to be restricted in your 4wd ability you have to go as light as possible and thats probably only possible with a pop top .. but they are not cheap either here ... with a slide-on you dont have a trailer of course, no additional tires and spare, no
suspension failing ... etc .. but your vehicle will suffer and you will need airbags and better shocks ...
Not an easy subject ... I wish you
well with your decision
good luck
gmd
AnswerID:
196737
Follow Up By: Member - JohnR (Vic)&Moses - Wednesday, Sep 27, 2006 at 07:45
Wednesday, Sep 27, 2006 at 07:45
gmd, interestingly
Kimberley (the camper manufacturers) have a similar philosophy with diesel and they have a diesel hot water system too, which also gives them the opportunity to put in a heater in their Karavan. Diesel cooktop too.
Sounds massive mate. Guess an Isuzu 4by truck could have been a good option to the locomotion.
FollowupID:
455132
Follow Up By: _gmd_pps - Wednesday, Sep 27, 2006 at 13:10
Wednesday, Sep 27, 2006 at 13:10
John,
we had looked at that and a few other options .. (Unimog, Oka) but we decided against the "Real Truck" thing ... the US 1T trucks are way nicer for that application.
Sure some pneumatic seats are good too but I cannot be bothered with the general feel and characteristics of these animals.. I used to drive a Unimog and I do drive an Isuzu every other week to pick up some goods ... not really my pair of shoes..
Thanks for posting
gmd
FollowupID:
455191
Follow Up By: rolande- Thursday, Sep 28, 2006 at 14:21
Thursday, Sep 28, 2006 at 14:21
G'Day GMD,
You gave us everything other than the name of the unit you purchased?
Any site links?
Regards
Rolande
FollowupID:
455360
Follow Up By: _gmd_pps - Thursday, Sep 28, 2006 at 18:23
Thursday, Sep 28, 2006 at 18:23
Rolande,
it is a bit on purpose because I did not want to promote a specific model or brand neither did I want to "show off" what we decided on.
If you are interested for yourself you can contact me personally and I can give you all info you want including some shipping headaches :)) ...
Email me at gmd_nospam@ozshops.com
regards
gmd
FollowupID:
455408