Friday, Nov 10, 2006 at 09:07
Hi Ian,
I had thoughts along those lines before I bought them, but after assurances from the vendor I went ahead. I wondered about their vibration resistance as
well.
So far the under bonnet one has lasted 6 months including the
cape york trip and roughly 13,000km. It has been down to less than 11 volts 2 or 3 times, the rest of the time it would not have been below 12. The alternator charges at 14.0-14.2 volts according to the Scanguage, and the battery retains 13.4V while at rest. When I received them, they were at 13.4. I have never had a "standard" battery retain more than 12.5 even when brand new.
My decision to use them was also based on the price - $106 delivered is pretty cheap even if the battery were to fail in a short time. I will be quite happy if it lasts 12 months, anything longer I regard as a definate bonus. So far the fact that it has run the fridge for 4 days several times and still starts the car has made it good value. Two of my travelling companions with new but acid filled batteries had acid splash up out of the lids, and one of them failed on the trip due to exposed plates. His $200+ deep cycle battery was a throwaway, the other one won't be far behind since it has been jiggled around enough on the corrugations to splash acid out and has probably had its plates exposed during this process.
The 1000cca rating starts the generator in my vehicle extremely
well :), even when the Voltage is down to 10.8.
When researching the topic of batteries, the information I found (using links from this
forum) regarding wet cell "normal" car batteries seemed to be unanimous that they have a very narrow operating band in terms of charge level and if outside that range will fail rapidly.
If you treat them to the ideal conditions that are recommended for the Dynasty, they will last 10 years, since there are no conditions causing calcification of plates. When you use them under the bonnet, and expose them to heat, deep discharge, high boost charge and vibration they will fail in 4 years or often much less. They will definately not run a fridge for 4 days and still start the car. If you run them flat once (less than 50% charge), it can be fatal for the battery. Do that 3 or 4 times and it will be the end.
All in all, the benefits are worth the risk - brilliant CCA, ability to operate in the 25%-95% charge range, and ability to run the fridge without constantly worrying, the need for a second battery in the car is eliminated, and in this case excellent price.
Cheers.
Gerhard
FollowupID:
463780