Tuesday, Nov 21, 2006 at 09:08
Went through the same decision process about 12 months ago.
Trying to decide between GPS, PDA and laptop.
Already had laptop and oziexplorer.
Rethinking all possible uses I went through the following:
1. Fitting in the car. Laptop too big to fit in the front, didn't want to go to the hassle of setting up remote screen, and wife not that computer literate.
So it came down to GPS or PDA for me.
So set budget figure of $1,000.00
2. Is it only for car use, or also for some bush walking? If bush walking is it worthwhile getting a good GPS unit. I do some bush walking but normally mostly tracks, chances of getting lost pretty slim. Still PDA or GPS. But decided weight and size not such an issue since I wouldn't be taking it every time. If required, I could get a little cheap GPS later.
3. PDA and GPS can both be with 3.5" screens.
4. Cost - large screen GPS and PDA about the same.
5. Maps - did I want to run Garmin etc proprietry maps or run more than that.
Decided on more than that, since I wanted street software for work. Go to an address type stuff. So it could be between a tom tom or garmin street type GPS or a PDA.
6. So being able to run co-pilot or such like, do I also want to run other maps such as Heema desert tracks, top end, fraser island maps? Garmin and others almost as good as the 1:250,000 natmap series, but a lot are based on the 'whereis' mapping base and loose accuracy when out west. Decided on other maps.
So ended up with a PDA, with co-pilot street software, and oziexplorer CE.
PS. Using the street software with voice, on our first run visiting friends in
Townsville, the gps a couple of times said turn right, and I kept going straight on. It didn't look right. GPS said "you missed turn", and wife following on map said "I agree, you are out voted". So be warned, it will be 2 against one if you get one. Wife is now getting used to it and refers to the GPS as a 2nd check as to our position on the map quite often now. She is thinking the 'yet another toy' is maybe not so bad, but it has taken 12 months. I tihnk my getting the GPS was taken as a comment on her navigation skills, which are normally pretty good.
PPS - that 3.5" screen is small, and sometimes hard to read with glare in the front of the car. Have cut a bit of thin black plastic to act as a shield, and having a map as
well helps to give the wider view. A lap top would be better in that regard.
AnswerID:
206060