Tuesday, Aug 21, 2007 at 19:50
Time to "fess Up" that I don't know a lot about the latest trailer braking systems. I believe that electric brakes can be set up to have all the functions of a vacuum system including the "breakaway" but I believe you need to have a battery in the trailer to activate the brakes once the breakaway is triggered. In other words they can be set up so that there are no differences in function.
I have fitted both types (Not the breakaway type) in the early seventies and electric was considered pretty trashy (at the workshop I was in) when compared to the vacuum systems that we were installing. No doubt the situation has improved since then. Electric brakes are much easier to install in the vehicle because there is only the location of the controller and a bit of wiring to worry about. The vacuum brakes need the controller to be plumbed into the vacuum supply (inlet manifold on petrol vehicles),the brake hydraulic system, a vacuum reservoir(which needs to be fitted somewhere), and the vacuum line (probably 1/2-3/4 vacuum hose)to the rear of the vehicle. Also the hand controller needs to be connected via a bowden cable.
On the trailer the wiring on the electric brakes just goes directly to the brakes. The vacuum system needs a controller which is connected to a normal hydraulic system and to the vacuum line on the back of the car.
I suspect that even if you were able to fit a vacuum system yourself the cost may be prohibitive. It would be a good days work for a mechanic who knows what he is doing just to do the car.
Electric brakes work by energising an electromagnet which then drags on the flat part of the inside of the drum and hence forces the lever to which it is attached to apply the brake. The dragging magnet part is the bit I don't like but they appear to work OK as long as you keep the brakes adjusted (as you would on any brake) and keep an eye on your magnets. Apparently they wear out although
mine haven't yet after 15,000 Kilometres. A breakaway system needs additional bits and needs to be explained by someone who has had experience with them (ie...... not me)
Getting back to your problem, your boat trailer probably has hydraulic drum or disk brakes which are connected to the vacuum activated controller. If this is so I would do one of the following
1/ Check the legislation in relation to vehicle/trailer weight and see if an overrider type brake is OK and have that fitted if it is not there already.
2/ Fit a vacuum system to your vehicle (expensive)
3/ Have your trailer brakes converted to electric and the controller fitted to your car(also expensive)
4/ Take the rig to a brake specialist and tell them to make it legal (possibly very expensive)
I hope this helps and that I haven't confused you.
Doug
FollowupID:
519623