Tuesday, Oct 23, 2007 at 19:28
Beau ,
I was sent this info from a good mechanic in WA .
AGM (Absorbed Glass Matt) batteries have huge advantages over conventional deep cycle batteries in most circumstances, but which one will best suit your needs?
Hopefully with all the reading and research you have done you will have come to an understanding that deep cycle batteries are the way to go when it comes to auxiliary batteries, but for some people AGM (Absorbed Glass Matt) batteries will have a huge advantage over the conventional wet cell deep cycle battery.
Although this will get a little long winded, it’s
well worth understanding the virtues of both types of batteries, and how you can put them to best use, I won’t go deeply into the technical details of these batteries, just point out some of their advantages, and why.
Basically it starts with how you intend to recharge your batteries, I am talking about your main recharging source here.
If you are going to be using any of the smart charging solutions, like solar panels and a quality smart regulator, or a smart 3 stage mains (240v) battery charger, or the Christie Honda petrol charger (set to hi charge), then in most cases the conventional wet cell deep cycle battery will serve you
well.
If treated correctly (and few are) conventional deep cycle batteries can outlast AGM’s, but only if they are
well maintained and cycled within their design perimeters, with both correct discharging/charging and equalising (now that a whole other story) and with keeping electrolyte (water) levels up.
However if your main source of charging is from your vehicles alternator, or you need to place the batteries in
places that are less than optimum for safe battery storage, keeping in mind that wet cell batteries give of hydrogen (explosive) gas as they are charging, then you should consider using AGM batteries as they are totally sealed and spill proof.
Did you know that if our good quality wet deep cycle batteries have been discharged fairly deeply, it can take 8-12 hours of continuous engine running to achieve just 70-80% charge?
A bit about Alternators.
Standard car and truck alternators are designed, for various good reasons to recharge car batteries to only 70-80%, and this works very
well for normal cars and trucks, but when it comes to charging our storage batteries, where of course we need as full a charge as possible, that same 70-80% is not very helpful at all.
Really, standard alternators are designed primarily to top up quickly the surprisingly small amount of energy that is removed from the battery by the starter-motor on engine start up, and then to keep up with all your accessories, radios, head lights etc, they were never designed to recharge deeply discharged batteries, and they fall short in this area unless modified or replaced with a specialised charging alternator, and smart multi stage regulator.
Automotive battery chargers suffer from much the same less than perfect regulation as car alternators, and achieve much the same results, and take a much much longer time to do it.
As an example lets imagine you have a 100 A/H(Amp Hour) battery, and you main charging source is you vehicles alternator or a standard automotive battery charger, now both of these will only charge this battery to about 75% (75 A/H), and you should not discharge your batteries below 50% (50 A/H in this case) of their capacity (see note below) if you want them to last, so all you can really safely use of this 100 A/H battery is 25 A/H, not much eh?
Note. Have you heard that you can drain deep cycle batteries all the way down, and then recharge them?
Have you been told that this is what deep cycle batteries are all about?
I hear this almost everyday that people have been told this, and by some battery sales people that should know better.
This line of thinking is totally wrong.
All conventional deep cycle battery manufactures say that their batteries are designed to be cycled to 50% of their rated capacity!
So each and every time you take these batteries below this 50% you are shortening their lives, and if you do it regularly and deeply you will even more dramatically reduce their lives.
Ok OK !! I can hear the cry's from here "but I get many more amp hours out of my deep cycle battery than what you say I can!".
The truth is that most people discharge their batteries far too low, way down until their fridges cut out, or their lights start to dim (does this remind you of anyone ??), at this point they have discharged their batteries so low that they are doing serious damage to their batteries, and consequently won't get anywhere near the life out of their batteries that they could and should normally expect if the batteries were cycled within their design perimeters.
Now remember the 100 A/H battery with only 25 A/H useable? A huge gain can be had if you are using any of the smart charging solutions, like solar panels and a quality smart regulator, or a smart 3 stage mains (240v) battery charger, or the Christie Honda petrol charger (set to hi charge), you can expect close to 100% (100 A/H) charge,
So 100 A/H capacity, discharge to 50% (50 A/H), that’s now 50 A/H useable, twice what you had before!
Now lets look at some of the direct advantages of these AGM batteries.
these batteries are totally sealed, ‘transport’ classed as spill proof, never needing topping up with water, ever!
because of this they can be mounted inside a car, caravan, motorhome etc and only need to be vented to atmosphere, they do not need to be in a sealed box vented to the outside like wet batteries, and can be mounted on their sides or ends if needed.
because of their very low internal resistance these batteries will fully charge at a lower voltage, and accept a much larger charge current, so when charging from a standard car/truck alternator these batteries will all but fully charge, and fast too, in about 2.5 to 3 hours!
they can be discharged much much deeper than conventional deep cycles without major damage.
these batteries when left unattended only self discharge at the rate of up to 3% per month, and even after 12 months sitting idle can be recharged and put back into full service without any ill effects. On the other hand a standard deep cycle battery if treated the same way will have destroyed it's self, it will no longer hold a good charge, and is sadly ready for the rubbish tip and recycling, not cycling!
AGM batteries were originally developed for the military, they are very robust and will take a real pounding.
The original AGM batteries were made in the US, brands like Odyssey, Concord, Lifeline, all excellent batteries, used extensively also in the aircraft and in the motor racing fields, but hugely expensive, there are now a lot of these (AGM) types of batteries coming out of China, and some are just rubbish.
My battery supplier (ALCO Battery Sales Australia) has found a couple of company's over in China that has been in production for many years, and have been selling batteries into the European market for a long time and have built up very good reputations, ALCO now import these batteries into Australia and are selling them through their own outlets and dealers like myself.
These AGM valve regulated batteries (also called SLA or Sealed Lead Acid) offer very good value, and when compared to standard deep cycle batteries in a dollar per useable amp hour format, they come out
miles ahead, plus all the added advantages that I have already outlined, but there is still more.
Lets look at it in dollars and cents.
Using a 100 A/H deep cycle Trojan (the best), my price $295.
Useable capacity if charged with smart charging system............................ say 50 A/H, cost $5.90 per A/H
Useable capacity if charged from the alternator or auto charger only........say 25 A/H, cost $11.80 per A/H
Using a 120 A/H AGM Battery, my price $395.
Useable capacity if charged with anything.............................................. lets say 100 A/H, cost $3.95 Per A/H
Now lets look at the space saving
Lets say you needed 100 A/H useable capacity from your batteries, and your main charging system was from the vehicles alternator.
Now with conventional deep cycle batteries because you would only have 25% of your battery bank useable you would need 400 A/H of battery bank, now there are a few ways you could do this, but the least expensive way would be four x 225A/H 6 volt Trojan batteries at a cost of $1,000.
Now with AGM batteries you could have just two x 90 A/H giving you 180 A/H total, so there is your 100 A/H with plenty in reserve, and only 2 batteries at a cost of $680 all up.
So with space and money saved, and with the many other advantages of AGM batteries, they really are a very good option for most people.
Personally I will never muck about with messy, cantankerous, wet cell batteries ever again for my own needs.
I have Fullriver and ALCO branded AGM batteries in various sizes.
12V 7.5A/H 151mm Long 65mm Wide 95mm High @ 2.73Kg and priced at $35.00.
12V 12A/H 151mm Long 99mm Wide 95mm High @ 4.20Kg and priced at $55.00.
12V 20A/H 181mm Long 77mm Wide 167mm High @ 6.44Kg and priced at $95.00.
12V 33A/H 196mm Long 131mm Wide 155mm High @ 11.00Kg and priced at $145.00.
12V 45A/H 198mm Long 166mm Wide 174mm High @ 15.00Kg and priced at $200.00.
12V 60A/H 229mm Long 138mm Wide 212mm High @ 18.30Kg and priced at $260.00.
12V 80A/H 260mm Long 170mm Wide 215mm High @ 28.50Kg and priced at $320.00.
12V 90A/H 307mm Long 169mm Wide 215mm High @ 30.60Kg and priced at $340.00.
12V 120A/H 331mm Long 175mm Wide 220mm High @ 35.00Kg and priced at $395.00.
12V 200A/H 530mm Long 209mm Wide 220mm High @ 65.50Kg and priced at $695.00.
12V 260A/H 521mm Long 269mm Wide 225mm High @ 89.00Kg and priced at $890.00.
Note...sizes listed are approximate, please
check with us for exact sizes
I have a deal with my battery supplier who has outlets in
Brisbane,
Sydney and
Melbourne and a few other
places in between, so I can ship these batteries from any of these outlets, and offer these batteries to you for much less than you would have to pay for them over the counter, works for me ;-)
Please email me if you need help sizing up your battery requirements
Please note, my comments in this article are for batteries that are to be used in recreational vehicles etc, and are used for the odd weekend away and a few weeks a year, AGM's used in this way have a design life of 5 to 8 years.
However if you need a battery bank that will be in constant daily discharge cycle use all year round, then your battery bank should be sized so that your daily depth of discharge is about 20 to 25%, this applies to all types of deep cycle batteries if you want them to last for many years
Val Rigoli
Fridge & Solar
Internet orders welcome
we freight all our products Australia wide
If you would like to place an order please go to our >>ORDER page<<
I can only hope it is all correct - I have no knowledge on the batteries .
Cheers ,
Willie
AnswerID:
268008
Follow Up By: Mike Harding - Tuesday, Oct 23, 2007 at 19:45
Tuesday, Oct 23, 2007 at 19:45
I can only hope you find a better mechanic Willie.
Mike Harding
FollowupID:
530448
Follow Up By: Geoff M (QLD) - Tuesday, Oct 23, 2007 at 20:08
Tuesday, Oct 23, 2007 at 20:08
Mike Harding ..... I can only agree with you 100%.
There is so much B/S on batteries out there ( specifically on the internet) it's just a joke.
If you really want to understand DC batteries, then I suggest a read of Collyn River's publications (
Site Link) or do some research through various universities.
Geoff
FollowupID:
530459
Follow Up By: Member - Willie , Epping .Syd. - Tuesday, Oct 23, 2007 at 20:25
Tuesday, Oct 23, 2007 at 20:25
Mike ,
would you be kind enough to tell me where the BS is in this .
Thanks ,
Willie .
FollowupID:
530466
Follow Up By: Mike Harding - Tuesday, Oct 23, 2007 at 20:41
Tuesday, Oct 23, 2007 at 20:41
Hi Willie
Sorry but no.
I am fed up with posting to this
forum about electrical things and constantly trying to counter statements from people who have little knowledge of what they're talking about.
There are, clearly, half a dozen or so experts in these areas who now post to this
forum and I suggest you, and others, take heed from these people and ignore the "Internet Experts".
Mike Harding
FollowupID:
530479
Follow Up By: Crackles - Tuesday, Oct 23, 2007 at 21:38
Tuesday, Oct 23, 2007 at 21:38
Willie the statistics you've shown are extremely broad & certainly don't reflect real life experience, particually in my case.
I use 130ah Trojan batteries which in the real world recently cost me $230 each. After camping for a few days, a 4 to 5 hour drive charging solely off the altenator brings my batteries up to around 85% (measured by volts & hydrometer). I regually discharge to 30% and a few times have accidentally discharged to 10% yet on the last pair of batteries have got almost 5 years out of them.
So the numbers.......
130 ah......charged to approx 110 ah (85%)......usable capacity 77ah (70%)......Cost $230... =$3 per ah.
Hey look, cheaper than an AGM ;-)
Cheers Craig.............
Twin 130ah Trojan batts.
FollowupID:
530505
Follow Up By: Member - Willie , Epping .Syd. - Tuesday, Oct 23, 2007 at 22:27
Tuesday, Oct 23, 2007 at 22:27
Thanks Craig ,
Mike had time to poo poo it , but did not want to waste his time telling me the facts .
Willie .
FollowupID:
530517
Follow Up By: Member - Mike DID - Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 10:37
Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 10:37
"Standard car and truck alternators are designed, for various good reasons to recharge car batteries to only 70-80%,"
Twenty years ago yes, with modern Alternators, no.
FollowupID:
530569
Follow Up By: Mainey (WA) - Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 16:43
Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 16:43
IMO to suggest.... "Standard car and truck alternators are designed, for various good reasons to recharge car batteries to only 70-80%"
...... is totally wrong !!
This message implies ALL batteries would therefore be less than 100% charged, UNLESS charged by Solar, or some form of "smart charger"
What voltage is a 12v (wetcel) battery when "70% charged" ???
70% of what . . . the total voltage ??
When 100% charged a wetcel battery is . . . 12.66 Volts !!!
70% charged is therefore only about . . . 9 Volts ?
(with-out the benefit of a calculator)
To
check, measure the VOLTAGE of your (wetcel) battery, charged ONLY by an Alternator, you may be amazed to see it's close to 12.6 Volts... AT REST, if it's in reasonable condition and even allowing for some parasitic load.
Yes, some-how it's close enough to 100% charged by the Alternator, no-where near 70% or 80% charged
As they say 'miracles (obviously) do happen'
In the 21st century it's normal to have a "fully charged" battery, that's the sole reason the Alternator has a voltage "REGULATOR" inbuilt or externally fitted to maintain the battery at 100% charged, not over-charged or even under-charged.
My Alternator is only 55 Amps, the "modified" external 'voltage regulator' delivers 14+ Volts, this actually fully charges all 3 x DC batteries, when driving.
I know this because my 2 x AGM's voltages are shown on a digital LCD gauge and if they get below 12.8 Volt I (always) want to know why !!
As Mike DID says in 4 of 7 be aware of .............................
FollowupID:
530646
Follow Up By: Mike Harding - Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 17:44
Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 17:44
>Mike had time to poo poo it , but did not want to waste
>his time telling me the facts .
>Willie .
You’re being rather disingenuous to me there Willie – I have made more posts to this
forum regarding batteries and things electrical than you could poke a stick at. The information I posted above cost someone $8600 – this
forum got it for free, just not the brands of battery tested. This is an area I understand
well and I have always made my knowledge freely available – in e-mail on many occasions as
well as on the
forum.
You posted a lengthy piece of pseudo technical drivel which is readily found on the internet; how long did it take you to do that? Two minutes? Yet, despite the fact that if you chose to search the archives of this
forum you would find many posts by me and others which refute much of your post, you expect me to spend around an hour or more going through it, finding the errors, quantifying them and obtaining internet sources and links to support my statements and explaining the whole thing in a way non-technical people can understand.
I’ll help out as much as I can Willie but I’m not prepared, or should be expected by posters here, to waste large chunks of my time overturning 2000 words people cut and paste from some nebulous internet source.
Mike Harding
mike_harding@fastmail.fm
FollowupID:
530660
Follow Up By: Member - Willie , Epping .Syd. - Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 18:49
Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 18:49
Mike ,
Disingenuous , hardly ? I'm discombobulated by your dissemination and must lodge my disaffirmation .
Let me disambiguate our readers on this .You have disembogued a 19 line post to disabuse me , telling all what a great guy you are answering people's electrical queries . However , you had no time to answer the simple question I asked you before , or explain why you wouldn't .
Your post is both disputatious and dissymetric .
I am sorry to have earned your disapprobation and to have wasted your obviously extremely valuable time .
Willie
FollowupID:
530679
Follow Up By: Mike Harding - Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 18:59
Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 18:59
Bye Willie.
FollowupID:
530689
Follow Up By: Member - Willie , Epping .Syd. - Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 19:21
Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 19:21
Bye Mike
FollowupID:
530696
Follow Up By: Mainey (WA) - Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 20:12
Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 20:12
Willey,
In Mike’s defence, and that does not imply he needs any defence at all
you posted: “was sent this info from a GOOD MECHANIC in WA”
so how come it nominates a Company and contact information from the Eastern States?
...It's just advertising BLURB - to sell Fullriver batteries !
You then sign off by typing....
“I can only hope it is all correct - I have no knowledge on the batteries.
Cheers, Willie”
As I have pointed out the information you posted is obviously not totally correct
so now where do you stand ?
Do the battery test, see if YOUR battery is only (70%) ~9 Volts
Then you will be able to truly judge of the honesty in advertising
Stay cool :-)
You shouldn't expect people to fully explain the complete technical workings of everything to you, some people do that many times a day, and they get paid heaps for it, because it's accurate, precise and to the point.
(and very often too technical for those, as you say 'with no battery knowledge' to even understand)
FollowupID:
530717
Follow Up By: Member - Willie , Epping .Syd. - Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 20:55
Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 20:55
Mainey ,
I thought "I can only hope it is all correct - I have no knowledge on the batteries" was pretty self explanatory for the average intellect , but I will explain it for you . I thought the article may have been of some help , but having no knowledge of electrical things , I thought I had better add that qualification .
“was sent this info from a GOOD MECHANIC in WA”
The guy who sent it to me , is a tagalong operator who IS a good mechanic . It looks like he is not a good electrical mechanic though .
"so how come it nominates a Company and contact information from the Eastern States?"
The tagalong guy probably just read it on the internet site and thought it looked like good information . That's not too complicated for you is it Mainey.
"so now where do you stand ?"
I appreciated your informative post telling me of the problems with the Fridge and Solar article , but I sit in front of this computer tonight and wonder why you posted this latest piece of inarticulate rubbish - that's where I "stand" .
Willie
FollowupID:
530732
Follow Up By: Brew69(SA) - Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 21:02
Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 21:02
My mother always told me............if you have nothing nice to say then say nothing.
FollowupID:
530734
Follow Up By: Mainey (WA) - Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 21:28
Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 21:28
Willey,
I'm sorry you feel my last post was a "piece of inarticulate rubbish" I understand all the words, they are not miss-spelt, mumbled or inarticulate, but as I said some things are just " very often too technical for those, as you say 'with no battery knowledge' to even understand "
Bye Willey.
FollowupID:
530739
Follow Up By: Member - Willie , Epping .Syd. - Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 22:14
Wednesday, Oct 24, 2007 at 22:14
Could you just get my name right at least .
FollowupID:
530753