Automatic 4wd for me any time, any place.
Submitted: Sunday, Apr 20, 2008 at 21:29
ThreadID:
56832
Views:
3835
Replies:
13
FollowUps:
20
This Thread has been Archived
Best Off Road
Autos are so much easier, and safer IMHO.
Proviso: I don't claim to be an experienced 4wd expert driver. I've been doing it for 15 years, but not to a very high level.
Other than engine braking, the Auto has it all over the manual in all stuations that I have experienced. On severe downhill declines, I have always been happy with the job the brakes do.
Autos take away the need for reverse
hill starts, allow gear changing on the move without loss of momentum and are overall far more forgiving than a manual.
Sure, there may be some very experienced drivers who can make the most of a manual, BUT, for most, the Auto is a bettter way.
On the road, give me a manual performance car any day. But that is not the issue here.
Jim.
Reply By: Stephen M (NSW) - Sunday, Apr 20, 2008 at 21:46
Sunday, Apr 20, 2008 at 21:46
Hi Jim, after having both I must say I do like the auto especially when I have been up to
stockton beach, plant the foot and go and no loss of momentum when trying to climb the sand dunes where in the lux I would lose a lot of go mind you doesnt take much in a 2.8D hilux as everyone knows. Where I think the manual is better and especially in diesel form is down
hill STEEP stuff. The hilux had brilliant low range. Dont know what the ratios are between the prado and lux, but the I have found the lux was alot better in low range 1st crawling. I fing the auto wants to try and creep up in speed and I definately use the brakes more. Same around town, give me a auto any day in start stop traffic (M4 here in
Sydney can be like a
carpark in peak hour) but open road driving and hilly bendy stuff I love the manual. In saying the above I have seen the new 200 series in action in auto and must say the
hill decent system they have is brilliant but will need to win lotto before I get to have the experiance of being the one behind the wheel LOL. Regards Steve M
AnswerID:
299529
Reply By: Member - Barnesy - Monday, Apr 21, 2008 at 03:57
Monday, Apr 21, 2008 at 03:57
I love my big diesel 5 speed.
I can see why people like autos but I think being in total, direct mechanical control of the vehicle gives the best feel for the car and terrain, especially when towing off road.
The engine braking of a big diesel in low range first gear is second to none. All of these other situations where autos have an advantage are good but having a manual won't really do any serious damage.
But if you're on a steep, slippery slope with a trailer in tow and the bloody auto just won't slow down without applying brakes it can make you crap yourself. Especially if that slope is on the side of a mountain with a long fall below.
Not for me. I'll stick to my old fashioned, tried and trusted combo and risk geting bogged easier and get practice doing
hill starts. I don't like crapping myself.
Barnesy
AnswerID:
299551
Follow Up By: Top End Explorer Tours - Monday, Apr 21, 2008 at 14:05
Monday, Apr 21, 2008 at 14:05
I'm with you Barnesy.
Cheers Steve.
FollowupID:
565805
Follow Up By: marcus - Monday, Apr 21, 2008 at 15:10
Monday, Apr 21, 2008 at 15:10
Must be why the real tough as you like 70series toyota and defender only come as manual with no auto option.Cheers Mark
FollowupID:
565812
Follow Up By: Member - Roachie (SA) - Monday, Apr 21, 2008 at 15:28
Monday, Apr 21, 2008 at 15:28
I'm with Barnsey too.....but just because I prefer a manual behind my 6.5 Chev V8, doesn't mean I am not in complete agreeance with the original post. An auto box IS better than a manual in 99% of situation you'd be likely to find yourself in.
If you do drive an auto, there is a way of safely tackling a very steep downhill track......and it DOES involve using the brakes PLUS the accelerator (both at the same time). I'd be very nervous about trying it, but the driver training/instructor course I've done went through it. I was being assessed as an instructor, by a qualified DTU bloke from the SAFWDA. He was sitting in the back
seat and I was in the front passenger's
seat, while I had to explain to this poor coota how to drive HIS auto disco down a steep
hill. He needed to place the vehicle in low range 1st gear, build the revs up to about 1500 with his left foot on the brake pedal. Then when he was ready, he gradually released some of the pressure on the brake pedal with his left foot, while maintaining his right foot in it's fixed position; pressed sideways against the kick panel for some stability.
The idea is that the torque converter works when you give it some juice, so the vehicle is trying to drive down the
hill under power and the brakes are used to control the descent.
It worked really
well.....but I still love the Marks Adaptors Transfer Case gears and the engine-braking capability of the Chevvy....
FollowupID:
565815
Follow Up By: Cairns Offroad Training & Tours - Tuesday, Apr 22, 2008 at 11:32
Tuesday, Apr 22, 2008 at 11:32
Hi Roachie as an instructor I have never been able to understand that method. It seem unnessessarily?complicated. With the car in drive it is driving the wheels anyway and its not going to stall so why not use your most experienced right foot to do the braking? Momentum should be controled right from the start by braking progressively. By adding just a couple of clicks of hand brake you also encourage the LSD to work.
Teaching poeple to brake with the left foot while accelerating down a steep slope makes no sense to me I am afraid ;-(
FollowupID:
565959
Reply By: KSV. - Monday, Apr 21, 2008 at 08:56
Monday, Apr 21, 2008 at 08:56
Another troll. Everyone knows that 4WD must be manual to be useful. Furthermore I believe that there should be law about this, thus all 4WD (actually any car with GVM more then 1.5t) must be diesel, manual and with both live axles and as least leaf spring on the back (front OK as
well). No electronics inside. No ABS or airbags. (Do you know such car? LOL). This is beautiful for people who need 4WD-ing, towing or carry extra load, but became useless as Toorak Tractor. As result smells from greenes about “big ugly truck polluting out city” eventually vanished.
I suggesting make petition to government about this idea.
Serg
AnswerID:
299578
Follow Up By: bbuzz - Monday, Apr 21, 2008 at 10:00
Monday, Apr 21, 2008 at 10:00
HJ60 is what you are after. Slow on the hills too. Sailors steer clear as
well!
FollowupID:
565775
Reply By: Mainey (wa) - Monday, Apr 21, 2008 at 09:01
Monday, Apr 21, 2008 at 09:01
Yes, autos are so much "easier", and "safer" if your not really happy or proficient at using a manual in harsh and severe off road conditions, however as you say Jim "on the road, give me a manual performance car any day" it will also save having two (2) different vehicles when your happy driving a manual in tough off road conditions too.
I replaced my Asainwarner auto trans with a solid lock-up Borgwarner auto and had all the ‘blade’ tips curved to deliver maximum torque before I left
Melbourne (1996) to do my (unfinished) lap of
the block.
The difference is unreal, it’s (almost) as controllable as a manual in sticky situations.
But… I find the GF’s 5 speed Diesel Troopy is simply a joy to drive in the bush for the obvious reasons.
Mainey . . .
AnswerID:
299581