Port Smith or Barn Hill?

Hi all, thinking of taking a weekend trip to either Port Smith or Barn Hill. Which did you prefer, where did you catch the most fish mainly. LOL. My server isnt letting me log onto either places websites so cant really decide, can only go off what info i have gathered off locals and they dont really know either. Do both of them have boat hire? I am pretty sure Port Smith does, and it has a creek so will get to do some crabbing and fishing for Jacks and barra. Any advice, will only be rolling a swag so as long as there is some shade im happy. Would prefer a place where i dont have to drive on the sand too much and where its easy to get to the water at high tide.

Cheers