Monday, Sep 15, 2008 at 19:35
Hi Mike
>are you saying that even if you are a member of VKS 737 and have
>permission to use their frequencies, that you are not allowed to TX
>RX on your Yaesu Radio ?????
Yes that's correct. Only "Type Approved Land Mobiles" are, legally, permitted to be used on VKS737, it's a similar situation with CB.
There is some sense to this; in order to obtain "Type Approval" for a radio the major requirement is that it be "Channelised" ie. the user is technically prevented from transmitting anywhere other than the frequencies approved for his system - VKS737, CB, etc. Whereas an Amateur Radio will allow the user to transmit anywhere on the band.
For people who are technically inept this is, probably, a good thing but for those who are able to handle a modicum of technology (can you programme your VCR etc?) it's needlessly prohibitive and enables manufacturers/resellers of Land Mobile HF radios to charge a significant premium for their product. NB Codan/Barrett et al produce a quality product but it is seriously overpriced.
In reality what happens is that many people who understand these things buy an Amateur Radio to use on VKS737 and those who don’t buy Codan etc. No one polices the situation. Amateur Radios usually lack Selcall but a Jenal mike will fix that.
Jenal
Finally: someone mentioned his Land Mobile covers the Amateur Bands… not really it doesn’t. Sure it’s possible to programme specific frequencies into it but Amateur Radio is not channilised and having fixed frequencies is virtually useless eg. I have a regular schedule on 3.682MHz but if that frequency is busy we’ll go to 3.677MHz or 3.563MHz or 7.105MHz or…? You cannot change the programming in your Codan to accommodate that.
Mike Harding
mike_harding@fastmail.fm
FollowupID:
592536