Thursday, Oct 30, 2008 at 20:40
Hi Flywest,
Here is my thoughts on your post. Please don’t take offence to what I’m about to comment on.
Firstly you say that ” i don't think i would PAY to be a member of a
forum that is so heavily "moderated".
I don’t believe people come here just for the
forum, although some probably do, I am a member for all the great resources that this site offers, not just the
forum.
1; Your first point; I agree with 100%
2; Being a contributor takes effort: Yes it does, there are so many factors to consider, they are too many to list, Background of other posters, age, sex, just to name three. ‘ summarily thrown in the bin - irks the contributors’ So are you suggesting that it be open slather? Sorry, there are rules, but isn’t life full of rules. If contributors feel they can not contribute any more may be the
forum is not for them.
3; Not relevant. Sorry it’s not
4; “I don't NEED to pay to post something at someone else’s forums” Paying
membership is not just about the
forum. It is the members that alert the moderator to the post. It is not the moderators trolling through each thread looking for anything that breaks the terms and conditions that you agreed to, it’s your peers that bring it to the moderators attention. It’s not just you Flywest that has this idea that it is moderators editing and deleting posts. It’s a miss understanding that a lot of people are struggling to get their heads around. “grammar, spelling etc meets with politically correct thought” I don’t believe you would get pulled up for spelling, politically correctness, maybe if it was offensive.
5; obviously you are not a member of Whirlpool. This system works very
well, as much as some hate it, it works. If it breaches
forum rules, that is justification alone. In the site I just mentioned, if your post has been hidden, you are not notified, why? It has breach
forum rules. That is enough, isn’t it?
6: I hope you not serious in this comment, because if the person you just described did breach
forum rules it does not matter what physical or mental disability or handicap he or she has, if they post and their peers find it offensive and it is in breach of the
forum rules it should be hidden or deleted.
7: If it is off topic, it is off topic; again you are jumping at shadows. I don’t believe a post would be deleted because the poster held a political view one way or the other. “Differing opinions is what makes people interesting” Yes you are right, that is what makes life so much fun,
It’s not just your post, but a lot of other people are confused about the moderators roll. As I understand it, A Visitor or Member finds a post Offensive, inappropriate, or it breaches the term & conditions Alerts a moderator, the moderator takes a look at the post. They then deicide if it has breached the rules and it is dealt with. If the moderator does not believe it as breached the terms, it stays. I’m sorry I can’t explain it any better.
May I add? I don’t have a problem with moderation. I’ve never had a problem with being judged by my peers.
FollowupID:
600607