Bilstein or Old Man Emu LTR's
Submitted: Monday, Aug 04, 2003 at 19:18
ThreadID:
6361
Views:
16019
Replies:
5
FollowUps:
10
This Thread has been Archived
Big John (QLD)
I am currently running Bilstein shocks on my 100TD Cruiser. I intend to replace these for my trip to the Canning next week and then take these as spares. I have had no problems with the existing Bilstein's which have seen some pritty tough work and lots of corrugations. I am at two odds as to whether to go Bilsteins again or fit Old Man Emu LTR's. Has anybody have any comments on the Old Man Emu LTR's. Yes I know the LTR's ($1800.00 fitted) are more expensive than the Bilsteins ($1200.00 fitted) but cost is not a problem, I want the best.
Thanks
John.
Reply By: B.P.L. - Monday, Aug 04, 2003 at 21:18
Monday, Aug 04, 2003 at 21:18
John
Bilstein are a far more advanced shock than OME.
OME shocks are made in Brazil with most other shocks around the world. Bilstein are made in Germany and are used in many prestige vehicle manufacturers.
The LTR's have the seperate oil canister for holder more oil. More capacity means lower operating temperatures - therefore reduced shock fade. In my opinion, more things to hit, or brake, or damage etc.
The Bilstein shock doesn't need this garbage because of its superior valving technology. The original shocks arn't too bad on the 100s anyway. Going to OME would be a downgrade.
AnswerID:
26791
Follow Up By: Big John (QLD) - Monday, Aug 04, 2003 at 21:39
Monday, Aug 04, 2003 at 21:39
BPL
You are correct about the origional 100 series shocks, we originally fitted Koni's and distroyed all 4 on our last trip to WA, we refitted the original toyota shocks that we were carrying as spares and they out performed the Konies.
john
FollowupID:
18333
Follow Up By: Billowaggi - Monday, Aug 04, 2003 at 23:17
Monday, Aug 04, 2003 at 23:17
Hi B.P.L. where did you pick up this rubbish that OME are made in Brazil! The are made in Australia to ARB,s own specification [stamped into the body of the shock MADE IN AUSTRALIA] They are a top shockie I have used them on three CSR trips and two
Gibb River Road trips with no failures.Also accompanying vehicles on these trips [Patrols and 80 series Cruiser and HiLux were fitted wity OME also no problems.
Regards Ken.
PS how many German prestige vehicles make it to the
Canning Stock Route or
Simpson Desert. I am shure Bilstein are great on the Autobahn!
FollowupID:
18352
Follow Up By: Member - Raymond - Tuesday, Aug 05, 2003 at 09:14
Tuesday, Aug 05, 2003 at 09:14
Big
John
I am surprised that you had problems with the Koni's. Did you take them back and find out what failed, as they have an excellent warranty. Used Koni's for years on F100's and was getting 350000klms per set. Went to OME on Toyota getting 100000klms before they were stuffed, the GU has the Koni's back on and not problems in 70000klms and that with the vehicle with camper on and we used it through the
Kimberley's with no problems.
Ray wanderin' in retirement. victor 2010
FollowupID:
18360
Follow Up By: B.P.L. - Wednesday, Aug 06, 2003 at 19:39
Wednesday, Aug 06, 2003 at 19:39
Sorry to dissapoint you. However, if you do your "real" reearch you will find that OME is out of Brazil. OME
test and design the shock in Aus. but hey are made O.S.
And mate, how many Brazilian 4WD's do you see cruzin' around the Cape???????????
FollowupID:
18496
Follow Up By: Billowaggi - Thursday, Aug 07, 2003 at 08:58
Thursday, Aug 07, 2003 at 08:58
If they are made in Brazil how have they got away wity stamping them MADE IN AUSTRALIA for all these years. Is'nt that illegal ? I know for a fact that they are made by Monroe for ARB to there specification in Australia.
By the way, last year I took my Brazilian made Ford F250 to the
Mitchell Plateau the only part that let us down was the after market Rancho shockies!
Regards Ken.
FollowupID:
18537
Reply By: Member - Bill- Monday, Aug 04, 2003 at 22:13
Monday, Aug 04, 2003 at 22:13
Read a mag a while back where Ron Moon ran shotgun on a shock
test trip for the IFS cruiser. The takeaway was the Bilstein was the best shock on the
test for the particular application, way better than OEM fitment and OME (XGS?). Having read a number of these type of things it appears certain shock construction and manufacture seems to suit certain types of
suspension and vice versa and generalisation is dangerous. Koni's are known to outperform most others on Patrols but not so good on IFS cars, Bilstein seem good on IFS cars (spring and torsion bar) being able to cope with the higher speed movements. Bilstein, being a monotube shock should be protected from stone damage on the rear. One trick is to coat exposed surfaces with a thick layer of silicone.Regds
Bill
AnswerID:
26800
Follow Up By: Truckster (Vic) - Monday, Aug 04, 2003 at 22:43
Monday, Aug 04, 2003 at 22:43
TJM XGS shocks..
FollowupID:
18343
Follow Up By: Big John (QLD) - Monday, Aug 04, 2003 at 22:59
Monday, Aug 04, 2003 at 22:59
Bill
We were with Ron when when he did that
test on the the IFS cruisers we were 1 of the 4 TD cruisers, though on that trip no vehicles were fitted with OME LTR's that's why I asked the question about the LTR's. On reading the above coments I think I might stick with the Bilsteins.
As the old saying goes " When your on a good thing, stick to it"
Thanks
John
.
FollowupID:
18350
Follow Up By: Member - Bill- Tuesday, Aug 05, 2003 at 07:53
Tuesday, Aug 05, 2003 at 07:53
Well,
well, how about that. Shame on me for the mix up on the OME/TJM XGS (athough I do remember they were not LTR's) but there have been a few reds consumed since I read that piece, what, nearly a year ago?
I'd love to do a trip like that, must have been a blast.
Also, as they say "if it 'ain't broke don't fix it"Regds
Bill
FollowupID:
18356
Reply By: bigboy - Tuesday, Aug 05, 2003 at 19:28
Tuesday, Aug 05, 2003 at 19:28
i think you should buy some enforcer 4x4 shocks
i buy shocks from L.C 4X4 PARTS 07 46696639 .
HE SELL SHOCKS THAT HAVE RRP $120-00 FOR ONLY $75-00 EA
plus about $50-00 or so to fit them
$75-00 x 4 = $300-00
+ $50-00 for fitment = $350-00
alot cheaper than $1200-00
AnswerID:
26860
Follow Up By: B.P.L. - Wednesday, Aug 06, 2003 at 19:37
Wednesday, Aug 06, 2003 at 19:37
Enforcer shocks (from Carroll Springs) are just about the most budget, crappy shocks you can buy.
FollowupID:
18495