Thoughts on maximum lift & tyre size?

Hi All,

A while ago I read about NSW looking at capping suspension lifts and tyre sizes on 4wd's and it looks like they've backed off (for now). I'm wondering what others think about this because I personally wouldn't have minded some constraint here. My rig has a 2 inch lift and standard size A/T tyres that has taken me around Australia and out and about home here (close to Vic High Country). While it's not a 'weapon' off road, it does the job and I'll back off before risking damage to my vehicle or endangering my family.

Anyway, I've come across tracks around home that I couldn't even attempt because the wheel ruts are so big and the the track so badly cut-up, I'd be bottomed out from the outset. Obviously the 4wd's that did get through and cut it up were quite high with some serious rubber. The following year the track had been repaired but I wonder how long they'll keep doing this before this track too is locked up.

Now don't get me wrong I know it's fun but when is it going to stop before we need tractors to get through these tracks. I see this situation as similar to young guys hotting up there cars and then letting loose in public areas - they should be on a track where they can properly test their cars and skills against others.

Should 4wd's of certain height and rubber only be allowed on private land to 'conduct' off-roading? I don't know the answer but I do know we are becoming increasingly restricted to where we can go and I've seen the evidence of why some of this is occuring.

Cheers,

Mark.


Back Expand Un-Read 0 Moderator

Reply By: Charlie - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 15:07

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 15:07
It's a bit more complicated than that as a lot of vehicles are only modified up to the height of a stock Landrover, in the future people serious about a bit of offroading will buy a have to buy something such as a Landcruiser, Patrol or Land Rover than comes stock with big tyres. As someone who wheeled in the eighties I know exactly what you mean about the increase of rutted out tracks and these come about mainly due to the proliferation of diff locks, in the old days your didn't go and play in the mud as getting stuck all the time just wasn't worth the trouble.A small number of irresponsible user with locked vehicles have ruined it for everyone by the amount of road damage they cause going out in unsuitable weather.
AnswerID: 392186

Follow Up By: Mark Howlett - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 22:00

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 22:00
Yeah the Landrovers are pretty high standard but I think it's more the tyres doing the damage. On the reverse argument of diff-locks, used correctly they would/should mean less track damage. Doing it easy locked in as opposed to spinning your way through unlocked will mean less damage. For some though it means they can just keep going until they eventually get stuck further down the track.

Mark.
0
FollowupID: 660139

Reply By: Member - DW (NSW) - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 15:29

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 15:29
Mark

I am like you that I have traveled on a variety of roads and tracks over the years with basically standard 4wds. Currently, I have a 50 mm lift and standard size BFG AT tyres. Anything I have tried has not stopped me. I have traveled in similar locations to you.
Around here, I see a number of extreme lifted 4wds with mud tyres. How they have managed to stay upright amazes me. Apparently, the Police are dealing with those that stuff up around the area. I have noticed a few with defect notices on their windscreens.
The extreme crowd are the ones that do cause the issues with tracks. In my area, Far North Coast NSW, several councils have closed beach access due to the destroyed entrances.
The fools drive on and off the beach with full road pressure which helps to dig out the tracks. Recently, I took my off road van onto the beach for a promo' job. Easiest thing I did was let all 6 tyres down to 16 psi and no marks anywhere while another 4wd came on with a camper trailer and full road pressure and had difficulty getting off the beach leaving a very rough track to follow.
My opinion is that there is no need for high lift if you are prepared to drive to the conditions and respect the environment.
There are places to go to destroy vehicles such as Landcruiser Mountain Park. If people want to play there are these appropriate locations.
It is amazing what vested interests, such as magazines and manufacturers, can encourage. An easy way to extract money from the owners.
Cheers
DW
AnswerID: 392189

Follow Up By: Mark Howlett - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 22:11

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 22:11
On one outing I watched a guy in a sky high SWB GQ Patrol with a beaut sounding V8 make his own track up the side of a mountain. I didn't think he would get to wherever it was he was going but it just kept going, spat plenty of crap out behind him...would have loved the local Ranger to have sprung him doing that.
You're right, they can do that in private parks that are designated/designed for it.

Mark.
0
FollowupID: 660141

Reply By: Member - Tony V (NSW) - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 16:12

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 16:12
In NSW tyre size is restricted, and has been since November 2003 to +15mm diameter.
To see or read VSI 09 click here

Suspension height is a difficult and subjective subject.

All other states are looking to VSB 14
To see or read VSB 14 click here

VSB 14 supports a 2" or 50mm lift on "Self Certification" . Above 2" that an Engineers certificate is required.

(Note: body lifts in all states require an Engineers Certificate).

NSW in the original VSI 50 wanted Engineers certificates from 0 to 50mm, and no, that is NO lifts higher than 50mm except for certain compliance, E.G. to and from an event.

The NSW law has not gone away and is still being negotiated in the background by 4WD NSW & ACT Inc (The 4WD Association) and AAAA and the MTA.

If you chave not yet filled in the Survey you can still do it its is on the front page of Association web page.

This can be filled out by people from all states, even if you have no lift and standard tyre, please fill it in, the statistics are important.

This gas also been taken up by each state 4WD Association and the ANFWDC (National Association).

AnswerID: 392193

Reply By: Member - Gavan F (WA) - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 16:33

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 16:33
Hi All

We appear to be a society that is ruled and controlled by the 1% ers.

15 years ago my range rover had 10R15 tyres,and I had trouble keeping up with the rebels with 33" monster boots and 2 " lifts .

Now our 33's are dwarfed by those big 35's and so on .

I have now got 35's a 4 " lift and dual lockers. Where once I had to rev my machine a bit and use momentum to concur ,I now Lower my pressures bit more ,activate the lockers and crawl up those mountains.I reckon we have all spun our wheels on a gravel track at some point or to get over a rock step. Probably cars equipped with HT and AT to a larger extent then MT's.

So really we are talking about the 1% ers that ruin it all for every one else . Be they on 30" Tyres on a Zook or 35's on a Cruiser .
So the real question is why don't people that should know better, lower there tyre pressures or why don't cars that are ill prepared take the (alternate track)instead of chewing up the harder ones..

Why do people in all different makes and models of cars with different sized tyres and Suspension , drive past a guy that is lowering his tyres to get on to a beach and doing the right thing , because they are the 1%er's ,I hope you drove out past them while they were digging with there thongs and you informed them about the virtues of proper 4wd preparation.

Lives not about going backwards or taking away from ,it's about working out how to go forward.

As long as things are properly engineered and developed then why not progress.

My 2 C worth

Gavan

AnswerID: 392198

Follow Up By: Member - Gavan F (WA) - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 16:37

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 16:37
Sorry guys ,spell check killed me in the above comments.
0
FollowupID: 660101

Follow Up By: Shaker - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 17:28

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 17:28
It is a well worn & flawed argument.

How do tyres dig holes deeper than they can reach.
It is obviously the massive tyres that are digging these deep trenches.

I live on the edge of the High Country & I regularly see these hoon vehicles driving back & forth through muddy sections of track, why? ......
Because they can!

0
FollowupID: 660104

Follow Up By: Member - Gavan F (WA) - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 18:43

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 18:43
The whole discussion is flawed from both sides.

If we didn't have 35+ . Then the Subaru owners would be complaining about the common 265x70x16 and so on and so forth.

This winter I saw 50 odd cars tackle the Powerlines track in Mundaring during the day .That night it literally bucketed down and by the next morning you would not have even known they had been.Environmental damage by people using Bobcats on this track is another issue:(.

Limited tracks is a big concern as listed below.

Vehicle safety for occupants and other rd users of vehicles that have had dangerous un-tested modifications made to them is the real problem.
0
FollowupID: 660113

Follow Up By: Member - Robert G (WA) - Monday, Nov 23, 2009 at 12:07

Monday, Nov 23, 2009 at 12:07
I am with you Gavan. There are always meatheads in amongst the real people and that applies to all walks and activities. I understand what is being said/asked, but I don't like the inference that big tyres equals irresponsible drivers. I have a 3"ish suspension lift, 25mm body lift and am trying out some 35" tyres now. I normally run 33" but some situations have convinced me to try the 35s for awhile and see how I go. Heck, I may end up running two different sizes depending on circumstances and destination. Anyways, I am certainly not a hoon or even close and I see plenty of irresponsible behaviour from people in non modified or modestly modified vehicles. I do my best to promote responsible off roading and camping on my travels. A big concern is that tyre rules do not address these individuals. I think education is a prime long term factor in addressing this and the government should be looking at this as a long term commitment. How many TV ads do you see promoting responsible off road driving and camping etiquette? Because there is no money to be made or saved you'll never see any either. Whilst I can see the argument here I don't believe that any tracks anywhere will be kept open as the sole response to legislation of tyre sizes able to be used.
0
FollowupID: 660228

Reply By: Robin Miller - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 16:45

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 16:45
I think a lot of it is the other way around Mark, as our technology level now means less need to spin wheels.

Track closures and a huge increase in 4wd numbers simply means more cars per track and more wear.

A solution is more tracks, not less.
AnswerID: 392200

Follow Up By: Mark Howlett - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 21:55

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 21:55
You would think Robin with this technology it would mean people don't need big rubber and lift as much as previously. I reckon I read here last week a 200 Series owner with KDSS claiming it just as capable or more so, than a GU with a 2inch lift. I wonder if that was Captain?

More tracks is certainly one solution but I can't see that happening if the existing ones keep getting destroyed by the minority.

Mark.
0
FollowupID: 660137

Reply By: Paul G K (vic) - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 17:32

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 17:32
The main issue with modifications to tyres and suspension on modern vehicles is the problems they will/ can cause to all the electronic controls ,ie ABS , traction control, electronic stability control etc..

Regards

Paul
AnswerID: 392206

Reply By: baldman - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 19:16

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 19:16
Can't they just legislate and set a maximum tyre size that is allowed in National Parks and State forests.

Let's say if they set the maximim tyre size at 33" then any vehicle found in a National Park or State Forest with bigger tyres would be fined in the same way you are fined for driving on a closed track.

If people want to fit anything above 33" ,then they need to drive in commercial 4wd parks or in competitions.

I drive a 4 runner and have had to go up to 32" tyres to be able to go out 4wding without having to snatch on rutted sections.

Unfortunatley there is not much we can do abut the mentality of drivers with 35" tyres that insist on traversing the same bog hole 6 or 7 times in either direction on the same outing.

AnswerID: 392218

Follow Up By: baldman - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 19:19

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 19:19
Sorry I will re phrase the last commet,

Unfortunatley there is not much we can do abut the mentality of drivers with ANY SIZE tyres that insist on traversing the same bog hole 6 or 7 times in either direction on the same outing.
0
FollowupID: 660115

Follow Up By: Mark Howlett - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 21:51

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 21:51
I think your solution has merit baldman. A limit in public areas makes sense for as you said (and mine above) you can't go 4wdriving where people have been with bigger tyres so you have to up-size your own tyres just so you can get through.

Mark.
0
FollowupID: 660136

Reply By: Member - Gavan F (WA) - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 19:38

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 19:38
Why don't we just pay a Lic fee that allows us to use the tracks.(like a Fishing Lic)
Money generated goes into Restoring and managing the tracks properly .Even Grading (Hard Med Soft etc).Then fine the 1%ers that are killing it for all.
AnswerID: 392222

Reply By: Member - Tony V (NSW) - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 20:41

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 20:41
The NSW (RTA) VSI 50 changes have nothing to do with going off road.

The RTA believe the press, that you buy a 4WD and it can do all those things in the adverts by the manufacturers.

The RTA main concern is safety.

The concerns are quite obvious.

1. Raised vehicle may be less stable in cornering.
2. That the raised height may cause issues in braking (see tyres later).
3. The raised height may cause vision issues.
We have all seen the 10" lift with no sway bars leaning over going around a bend. These are the 4WD's that non 4WD'er's remember. Same as the little old lady who only see's a big bullbar in her rear view mirror.

The second part with raised suspension is.

1. If you hit a pedestrian the person is morel likely to go UNDER the vehicle if it is raised.
2. If you hit another car side on the bull bar may go through the window, missing the side intrusion protection and hitting occupants.
3. If you hit a standard car head on that the raised 4WD may go over the standard vehicles airbag points, or crumple zone. (This has happened where a raised 4WD (about 10") hit a car above the airbag pods, touching first part way along the bonnet. the driver had more serious injuries than expected if the bags had gone off.

Tyre....

The concern with tyres are the 35 or 37" muddies on a 10" lift truck.

The concerns are:
1. That children may get dragged under a vehicle if clothing gets caught on the tyre lugs.
2. Wheels protruding outside the bodywork.
3. That breaking systems are designed for certain sized wheels and tyres and steering and breaking may be affected.

The RTA don't care that you want to go off road.

SUSPENSION. They do not understand that you and I may:

1. Improve your suspension to cater for carrying you camping gear.
2. Improve your suspension for towing purposed.
3. Improve your suspension to prevent suspension fade (shockers) for outback travel.
4. Improve your suspension to stop vehicle roll when cornering

TYRES.

We change tyres for a multiple of reasons.

1. Change from road rated tyres to the stronger Light Truck tyres, this is for safety.
2. Tread pattern, Highway Terrain, All Terrain, Mud Terrain. This is your choice and for what you intend to do.
The reason why tyre sizes change is easy, to change from a road tyre to an LT often means a change of tyre size, this may only be a few mm, but in some cases this can be 12 to 25 mm.

Again the RTA DO NOT UNDERSTAND THIS....

That is why the Suspension Survey is so important.4WD Association Suspension Survey

It is important that even if you do not have raised suspension or different sized tyres, that you fill this in.

This is being compiled and shared by all State 4WD Associations to fight the battle.
AnswerID: 392231

Follow Up By: Member - Tony V (NSW) - Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 23:25

Sunday, Nov 22, 2009 at 23:25
The one item that I missed was that heavy trucks have already been through this.

You will notice that most of the newer trucks are between 300mm and 450 mm off the road with the common rear protection bars to stop you going under the back but also the side ones or boxes on the trailers to reduce the possibility.

Truck under run laws this was introduced in September 2009



Woolworths version with under run protection.


,
0
FollowupID: 660163

Sponsored Links

Popular Products (9)