Friday, Mar 05, 2010 at 10:55
There are australian standards on tyre repair and they are called up by most states. haven't checked WA.
Sidewall repairs on radials are specifically outlawed by the standard and as I understand this came about due to:
The number of failures of repairs and
The sidewall works so hard that "its a matter of when not if". Quote from one of my instructors.
The info came from the tyre industry and VicRoads
VSI 16 tyre repairs
The other question is where to put the tyre you are worried about.
Testing has shown that the least unsafe place is to put the suspect tyre on the front. If it goes flat (or disitegrates) you develop a massive understeerr problem and difficulty with braking but the vehicle "tends" to go in a straight line while slowing down. You will still have some steering and braking control even if it is compromised.
If a rear tyre goes flat or disintegrates there is a much greater risk of loss of directional stability that can lead to oversteer then wheel dig in and rollover. The loss of directional stability is much faster when a rear goes down as the vehicle is suddenly effectively steering from the rear.
Directional stability is one of the reasons that vehicles have designed in understeer. It is also regarded as safer to hit things head on rather than sideways or rollover because the safety systems are designed that way.
Peter Wherret RIP demonstrated this years ago on his TV show when they used a system that blew a hole in the side wall of the tyre while it was being driven around a corner. They did it for each tyre position to demonstrate the effect and even the
test driver couldn't catch the slide caused by the ouside rear being blown.
Of course the stability issue doesn't play as big a role when the vehicle is traveling in a straight line as it does when cornerring. Worst case scenarion is a blowout on the outside rear while cornering hard at speed.
One of the reasons that tubeless tyres are safer that tubes is that they usually go down relatively slowly when punctured whereas tubes lose the pressure very rapidly. (Of course this doesn't account for rocks taking out sidewalls)
What does it all mean?
best tyres on the rear for stability.
Save your repaired tyres for true offroad or low speed work so that if (when?) it fails you are going slowly enough for it not to cause problems.
If you do get caught by the cops with repaired sidewalls don't be surprised if they ground you.
regards
A
AnswerID:
407358
Follow Up By: Alloy c/t - Friday, Mar 05, 2010 at 11:14
Friday, Mar 05, 2010 at 11:14
The dynamics that can cause a roll-over have not changed but tire technology and repair of same has improved not necessarily in leaps and bounds but to the extent that the 'standards' regulations need an upgrade , some regulations concerning tires have not been reviewed /or upgraded since Peter Wherret was still in the closet as a cross dresser. [ no offence intended to those who feel the need to cross dress].
FollowupID:
677269
Follow Up By: Andrew - Friday, Mar 05, 2010 at 11:49
Friday, Mar 05, 2010 at 11:49
Unisex clothing has solved my dressing problem. LOL and no offence intended.
I guess if the standards no longer represent the state of the art, then it only comes down to a legal liability problem. If some one got hurt who would have to prove the standard was inadequate and what you did was acceptable. I would think it is now down to those who say thay can be repaired to put their case to the standards committee or at the very least publish their reasoning so it can be analysed.
I agree that standards don't always (ever) stay up with the latest technologies but they do provide a "safe" position that consumers etc are supposed to be able to rely on. Going beyond the standards
places the liability on the users shoulders and most people can't access enough information to weigh all the risks.
Having said that I would still rather have a repaired tyre to crawl out of the bush on rather than no tyre at all.
The other part of the issue is telling the "good" repairs from the "bad" ones..
regards
A
FollowupID:
677275
Follow Up By: Rod W - Friday, Mar 05, 2010 at 12:06
Friday, Mar 05, 2010 at 12:06
I just knew we'd get one of these, someone coming and saying you can't do bit.
FollowupID:
677277
Follow Up By: Andrew - Friday, Mar 05, 2010 at 13:22
Friday, Mar 05, 2010 at 13:22
Hi Rod
Don't think I said you can't do it. I just tried to show the implications and issues if you do.
I don't pretend to have all the answers, but I do like to get people thinking instead of just repeating what the bloke down the road said. comes from 40 years in the automotive and road safety industries and dealing with what happens when it all goes wrong.
I'm sorry if you thought it was negative, it wasn't meant to be.
regards
A
FollowupID:
677295
Follow Up By: Member - mazcan - Friday, Mar 05, 2010 at 16:19
Friday, Mar 05, 2010 at 16:19
hi all
another main reason that repairing tyre side wall damageisnt done very often
is that the tyre companies would much rather sell you another new tyre
after all is'nt that why they are in the business
i have had 3 seperate sidewall repairs done over the years on 4wd tyres and ran the tyres without any problems until worn out in each situation and had no balance problems either
so it's nothing new
FollowupID:
677322