Tuesday, Jun 15, 2010 at 18:56
You should be pretty safe, relays, solenoids and coils give of EMF when de-energising the coil, basically the energy stored has to go somewhere and the best place is to earth.
Resistive Relays are better to a certain extent as they are non polarity device, just the same a a normal no protected relay but the will have a larger loading across the coil then a non protected or diode protected one.
In non protected relays EMF will be measurable but in most cases you have the battery to absorb the energy.
Most spike/surge protected relays are switched from direct out puts from the ECU or BCM, ECU's and BCM's will still survive being use with non protected relays as all ECU's and BCM's have their own spike/surge protection.
BUT.....the ECU, BCM inbuilt spike/surge protection may work 5000 times and them the 5001 time the spike/surge will get through causing expensive damage....bear in mind this is the same for protected relays....you hope their protection will last for ever but you just don't know.
We use diode protected relays in all the stuff we do...just in case + dealing in new vehicle we don't want to get caught out, the price difference is about $5.00 a relay.
FollowupID:
691152