Nissan Xtrail
Submitted: Saturday, Jan 15, 2011 at 13:52
ThreadID:
83677
Views:
5796
Replies:
9
FollowUps:
3
This Thread has been Archived
the nugget
Hi Guys,
Have been looking at Nissan XTrail 04/05 and an wondering if there are or were any issues with them. I was told that they did have a clutch problem.
As to whether they did I don't know and am sure there are quite a few Xtrail owners out there. Would appreciate some info about them.
Cheers, Nugget
Reply By: StormyKnight - Saturday, Jan 15, 2011 at 19:48
Saturday, Jan 15, 2011 at 19:48
a couple of issue that may arise....mainly if driving in sand. I have the newer body shape Xtrail for work. I think the running gear is the same though...
No low range so clutch gets a work out
The 4wd system is not mechanical. It like an electric clutch & distributes torque to the rear wheels (normally just front wheel drive), it can overheat & shut down leaving you with front wheel drive only until you turn the car off & on & the unit cools. You may then only get 10 minutes from it before it happens again.
Other than that the only issue I have is that the steering is a little odd. Its electric but so is our Fiesta & the steering between the two is chalk & cheese. The Xtrail doesn't seem to centre properly & you find yourself wandering down the road. It may just be my car, I don't know?
Getting 9.2l/100km mostly highway (average speed by trip computer is 61km/h)
Minor issue, the car just buzzes if you leave the lights on. They don't turn off when you take the key out. You have to turn the lights off to stop the buzzing noise. My Prado from 2001 has proper light switching!
Car if quite to drive & is comfortable on the open road with the
suspension doing a good job. AC works
well too.
Cheers
AnswerID:
441966
Follow Up By: the nugget - Monday, Jan 17, 2011 at 19:16
Monday, Jan 17, 2011 at 19:16
Thank you to all those that replied. Certainly food for thought.
Cheers and Happy 4wheel driving,
the nugget
FollowupID:
714223
Reply By: Member - Phil G (SA) - Sunday, Jan 16, 2011 at 00:42
Sunday, Jan 16, 2011 at 00:42
We've got two Xtrails we've had since new - 2005 manual with 90,000k and a 2007 auto with 40,000k - zero problems with either, but we don't 4wd and we don't tow with them.
The problems with the catalytic converter, and the screws dropping in the air intake were sorted by 2005.
The Jan2006 models onwards lost 9Kw because of the clean air laws.
I've not heard of any clutch problem.
AnswerID:
441999
Reply By: happytravelers - Sunday, Jan 16, 2011 at 08:17
Sunday, Jan 16, 2011 at 08:17
The Clutch is very weak and does not last long, especially towing or 4wding. My workshop has replaced many X trail clutches and it's not a cheap exercise. If you're looking at buying one, get an auto, which have very few problems and are a good reliable vehicle. If you're looking at getting a car for 4wding, consider something else. X
trails are not really a 4wd, they're a front wheel drive vehicle with an electro magnetic clutch on the rear diff. which is designed to disengage if it gets too hot which it usually does when driving in sand etc. Mitsubishi Outlanders and several similar vehicles also use this system. Great if you're trying to get out of an icy driveway in Europe but I wouldn't class it as a 4WD.
Regards Jon
AnswerID:
442006