Dead pom
Submitted: Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 13:28
ThreadID:
9130
Views:
2952
Replies:
13
FollowUps:
22
This Thread has been Archived
Member - Bob
I just read about the 35 yo guy who died after being found walking 70 km from Punmu. I am guessing that he was to the East of Punmu which would put him at the edge of
Lake Auld. The article said he fuelled up at Punmu, got bogged, then set off on foot to get help. I can only imagine that it would have been as hot as hell. Makes you wonder if he had a death wish - solo traveller, December, no comms. I wonder what else he did "wrong".Bob
Reply By: Willem - Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 14:24
Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 14:24
The mind boggles.
Marble Bar and environs is known to be one of the hottest
places in Australia
This is a reminder to all of those people who post questions on this
forum about travelling around in the summer months in the Outback of this country.
Take heed all ye fair travellers.
The sage has spoken!
Bob, when are you going on your cross country trip which you spoke about a while ago?
Cheers,
Willem
Always going somewhere
AnswerID:
40128
Follow Up By: Member - Geoff & Jen - Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 18:39
Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 18:39
We had best not be too hard on the poor bloke as he was from foreign field. Take a look at the "I'll be right mate" attitude we have in Australia. We had a cityslicker doing 120klm along our narrow road here and hit a beast, it flew up on the bonnet and squashed the roof of the commodore. He was hurt but it could have been a lot worse. His motive was the beast should have been behind fences. Doesn't he think a roo only need to wipe out a fence in an instant, and the whole herd could be on the road. Too much positive thinking can cause a disastrous negative. Jen
FollowupID:
257772
Follow Up By: Willem - Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 20:22
Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 20:22
So if you went to
Siberia in the middle of winter and started a trek to look for the stinted kelpi and perished you would expect the Russians to declare "Don't be too hard on the poor girl as she was from foreign field" ??????
There is no cure for foolhardiness or stupidity. You screw up, you pay for it !!!
Willem
Always going somewhere
FollowupID:
257774
Follow Up By: Member - Geoff & Jen - Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 20:50
Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 20:50
Yep, the old commonsense pays, yet again, actually it was irresponsible to travel solo. What I was getting at was he is dead, gone, and yet there will be another to follow, even from our own country, because of the " it will never happen to me, I know it all" attitude. Jen
FollowupID:
257776
Follow Up By: Member - Bob - Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 08:42
Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 08:42
Willem,
our trip next year is at
Easter. I've booked the flight home from
Broome on Anzac Day. We are having a planning meeting this week, but the route looks like it will leave the Stuart Hwy and cross the top of SA, into WA at Wingellina, north to the GCR then SBJ Rd to
Kintore, then left along the
Gary Junction Rd, then the Wapet Rd to Sandfire Flat RH. I'll leave some messages in bottles for you :-) Bob
FollowupID:
257785
Follow Up By: Willem - Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 10:56
Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 10:56
Bob,
You had better drop in for a cuppa at
Peterborough on your way through. If you care to you may contact me willem@kempen.id.au
Cheers,
Willem
Always going somewhere
FollowupID:
257787
Follow Up By: Member - Bob - Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 10:42
Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 10:42
Thanks Willem,
I will contact you closer to the time.
Bob
FollowupID:
257840
Follow Up By: peck - Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 19:39
Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 19:39
Willem,
I'd like to know how Bob gets on getting a permit for travel to S. G. corner via Amata etc. Got turned back there by S.A. police in '94 and tried hard but couldn't get a permit in 2001. I'd like to know his secret.
Peck
FollowupID:
257892
Follow Up By: Willem - Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 20:24
Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 20:24
I believe that you can get a permit to travel up that way but not to SG Corner. I read somewhere on this
forum a while ago of travellers out that way. Anyway, ask Bob directly and you may get answer you are looking for. You must have been dead unlucky to get spotted by Police in that remote area. A lot of this stuff is just pure luck. If you know some of the elders of the areas you wish to visit you may get permission directly from them. Going through the normal bureaucracy is fraught with problems as every little tin pot soldier would like to add his/her stamp of authority. I also believe that within 5 years you are going to see permits become a thing of the past as Outback Communities open up their country for tourism so that they may enjoy a sustainable future.
Willem
Always going somewhere
FollowupID:
257894
Follow Up By: Member - Bob - Tuesday, Dec 16, 2003 at 08:18
Tuesday, Dec 16, 2003 at 08:18
One of the aspects of our trip is to formally visit the art centres in remote communities. It is on this basis that we have been able to visit some otherwise inaccessible areas.Bob
FollowupID:
257945
Reply By: Brad - Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 14:54
Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 14:54
Tragic...those who live in small cool countries have no concept that a line on a map with a road name next to it doesn't mean you can 'just drive down it'.
tourist death
AnswerID:
40130
Reply By: Truckster (Vic) - Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 19:03
Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 19:03
Did you see the other one on the news, about the second one that was found just nth of
Broome I think...
Again Car bogged, but this one wrote SOS in the sand and was found by Coast Watch..
AnswerID:
40137
Reply By: Coops (Pilbara) - Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 22:00
Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 22:00
I've been out there a couple of times (both with issues also) as I'm sure some of you have too and it strikes me odd that people get bogged in the sand out there. Mud - yes, sand - No !!!
Recently two blokes perished in same area after getting bogged and I believe it was only a matter of letting the tyres down to drive the vehicle out. This is possibly the same scenario which makes it extremely unfortunate indeed.
We forumites are mostly an educated/experienced lot but I often wonder what there is that we can do to prevent this happening to overseas tourists again.Allyn
Some days we are the flies; some days we are the windscreen.
AnswerID:
40151
Follow Up By: Truckster (Vic) - Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 22:02
Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 22:02
One of the 2 stories on the news tonight, was a 2wd, like a Prarie van thing... there was sand everywhere.. Phuk nose what he was doing there.
FollowupID:
257777
Follow Up By: Coops (Pilbara) - Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 22:06
Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 22:06
I did see the car and wonder to myself what on earth he was doing but you'd have to still be pretty safe in
Broome .
Not many coastwatch planes fly over the desert though.
What are these people thinking ?Allyn
Some days we are the flies; some days we are the windscreen.
FollowupID:
257778
Reply By: Eric Experience. - Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 22:41
Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 22:41
Bob.
When the German woman died near lake eyre the vehicle leasing companies were critiized for not supplying instructions on how to drive and servive our deserts, I think that the recomendations that the corenor made must have been ignored by the vehicle hire industry. We as suposedly responsable people must try to prevent this sad incident from becoming more fuel for the anty 4x4 brigade, May be necesary to force hire car companies to show customers a video in there language of choice about driving techneques and servival stratergy. Eric.
AnswerID:
40156
Follow Up By: Member- Rox - Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 23:16
Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 23:16
I was just thinking about the viedio as
well & think it compulsary.1991 80Series Std Diesel
2003 Down Under Camper
FollowupID:
257779
Follow Up By: Member - Les & Clare (SW WA) - Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 23:51
Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 23:51
Yeah..I agree totally the video should be compusory before overseas tourists can hire or drive 4WD's in offroad and remote areas. If it only saves one life it will have been time and money
well spent.
LesHave beast - will travel!
FollowupID:
257780
Follow Up By: Member - Les & Clare (SW WA) - Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 23:54
Saturday, Dec 13, 2003 at 23:54
Yeah..I agree totally the video should be compusory before overseas tourists can hire or drive 4WD's in offroad and remote areas. If it only saves one life it will have been time and money well spent.
LesHave beast - will travel!
FollowupID:
257781
Follow Up By: MikeyS - Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 13:24
Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 13:24
Perhaps before showing a video, give people a page of recent newspaper cuttings about tourists perishing in the desert. The audience might be a bit more attentive then.
MikeyS
FollowupID:
257858
Reply By: Brian - Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 10:09
Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 10:09
As tragic as this is, and I for one am glad it wasn't me or anyone I know, it should be kept in perspective. He was "out-of-his-depth" here. And unfortunately, here in the great land of Oz, the powers that be seem to be promoting a line of "rest the blame elsewhere for your stupid mistakes". So, in the other case in question, the German lady at Lake
Eyre, the hire companies are at fault????? or at least partly because they didn't provide enough tuition? Again this is a very tragic scenario, but people should "Take Responsibility For Their Own Actions!!!!"
The guy in
Broome, albeit lucky to be stranded near the coastline, did the right things. The guy in the
Great Sandy Desert didn't! And according to the story..
"was attempting to drive from the coast of
Western Australia to
Alice Springs, in the
Northern Territory, a distance of about 1,200
miles.
Instead of taking the paved highway from
Perth to
Alice Springs via
South Australia, he chose to follow rough bush tracks through the forbidding
Great Sandy Desert, a vast area of scorched, treeless scrub."
Did he know what he was doing? Did he know what he was getting himself into? If he did, he made bad decisions.... if he didn't, he shouldn't have been there. Either way.... before starting out, would it not have been prudent to get educated on what he was planning to do?
IMHO you can't dive in the deep end of
the pool and then blame
the pool owner because you can't swim!
Just my opinion
Cheers
Brian
AnswerID:
40169
Follow Up By: Coops (Pilbara) - Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 22:08
Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 22:08
Instead of taking the paved highway from
Perth to
Alice Springs via
South Australia, he chose to follow rough bush tracks through the forbidding
Great Sandy Desert, a vast area of scorched, treeless scrub."
These aren't the rough bush tracks that you might think they are Brian. They are in fact quite accommodating other than when washouts form, they're just not tar. The sand dunes that are there really aren't that bad and correct tyre pressures should see the greater majority of all vehicles get through. I actually had to retrieve my vehicle from within about 50 km's where this guy died and did so with a car trailer. So we got through in an old troopy towing a car trailer with an 80 series on the back - all with about 25 psi in the tyres.
To travel through the Great Sandy, on his own AND in scorching temperatures was indeed foolish and this is the type of thing that we as 4WD'ers should try to prevent if at all possible. Your point on education is so absolutely
spot on. Hire companies should be accountable here as should local shires. For instance the entrance to Kidson Track has no signage whatsoever indicating what may lie ahead for the unsupecting traveller. All they can see is this well maintained dirt track heading off into the horizon. Add a little bit of arrogance and adventure to the ignorance and these poor buggers don't stand a chance.Allyn
Some days we are the flies; some days we are the windscreen.
FollowupID:
257815
Follow Up By: Brian - Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 06:56
Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 06:56
Allyn
I didn't "think" they were "rough bush tracks", I don't know because I haven't been there. If I ever go there, I will research it so I know what i am getting into. This guy apparently didn't. The part in my post about "rough bush tracks" is a copy-and-paste from the story. I take it as the writer pointing out that he made an error in judgement and paid the price. And yes, I advocate education for ANYTHING that people want to attempt that it out of the norm for them.... whether it is 4X4ing across
Australia or playing Bingo! One must learn the rules and the protocols.
But, I believe that it is the responsibility of the individual to seek the education, not the responsility of the council or the hire company or whoever/whatever to provide. The current trend towards blaming everyone else for something that is one's own fault is simply not taking responsilility for one's own actions.
We did hire a 4X4 over twelve months ago.... we asked so many questions about what could go wrong that we ALMOST changed our minds about the hire. But we learned just enough to enjoy a few days of fun with that hired 4X4 and that led us to buying our own etc etc..... our learning curve is still going and will for a long time.
A long time ago, Australian's would "cop it sweet" if they f####d up... now they look to blame someone else for what they got themselves into. I teach my kids to accept the responsibility.
Just my opinion
Cheers
Brian
FollowupID:
257825
Reply By: Member - Mike (SA) - Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 12:37
Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 12:37
Re Videos etc - FYI SA Tourism Commission and SA Transport have made a video (following the tragic Lake
Eyre incident which, I believe was completely due to incorrect tyre presssures) for our international visitors contemplating a trip into the outback. Whilst not brilliant it does try to get the point across.
I am not sure if hire companies have it as compulsory viewing
regards
Mike
Too little time in the bush!
AnswerID:
40177
Reply By: Member - Peter (WA) - Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 16:42
Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 16:42
why not a small booklet in each glove box with some basic sevival tips and recovery procedures ,plus a safety check list ,this cant cost the hire companys much and could lead to saving a life or a law suit ,maybe the 4wd assotiation could provide them free as a good will exerciseThis is not my car anymore
Peter
York 4x4
AnswerID:
40179
Reply By: Martyn (WA) - Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 20:01
Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 20:01
Bob,
The guy who survived stayed with the vehicle which is the golden rule as far as I'm concerned, I think that all hire vehicles should have an
EPIRB installed as srandard hire gear, this would be a great help. The guy who survived was a
survival specialist according to out newspaper reports so if he had done the wrong thing what hope have the majority got.
It's a horrible sensation being stuck, one time I've been stuck on my own I found it particularly stressful because I had the rest of the family with me and my daughteris assuring my wife and step son that "daddy will get us out of here", yea right put the pressure on, I was only in the sand dunes at Lancelin, I got stuck in the bottom of a pudding bowl type dune. I just couldn't climb the wall, luckily I let the
tyres down to about 10 psi and managed to climb out successfully, the
tyres where originally at road pressures, so it was my fault no problem there. sand is very difficult to drive on and reading dune contours is difficult sometimes with the sun direction and shadows etc.
The guy was recovered in two minutes by the hire company when they towed him out so he can't of been that stuck in my opinion and looking that the photos, letting down
tyres clearing sand from the right
places would of helped, the news report tells us the guys says he moved 'tonnes" of sandm where from? anyway it doesn't really matter he's safe now, he was lucky, the other guy who went walkabout wasn't as lucky, so sad. Keep the shiny side up
AnswerID:
40189
Reply By: Member - NOBBY - Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 20:02
Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 20:02
I would think that a good idea for all 4WD hiring business would be to include an
EPIRB in the car kit. The hirer should be informed on how to use it and the consequence of mis-use. This would have saved our English mate and all for the sake of $300.
AnswerID:
40190
Follow Up By: Coops (Pilbara) - Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 22:11
Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 22:11
While it's a credible idea I can't see too many
EPIRB's staying with the car upon return. That little bit of extra cash could buy lord knows what !!!Allyn
Some days we are the flies; some days we are the windscreen.
FollowupID:
257817
Follow Up By: Brian - Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 07:08
Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 07:08
Totally agree.
the
EPIRB would have to be a permanent fixture in the hire car for it to not be stolen, which would add extra to the install price and not too many hire companies would be happpy with that.
Perhaps this idea?? Hire companies could hire out an
EPIRB with each 4by, the value of which is refundable with the safe return of the
EPIRB???
The company still has to fork out for the
EPIRB per car, but at least the install price is zip and the chances of it's return are dramatically higher??
I read in one of the 4by magazines some time ago of a Subaru that drove across
Australia the hard way.... a Liberty if memory serves... would the hire companies think about hiring an
EPIRB to the average hirer of an average car, not expecting them to try a similar stunt??
Just my opinion
Cheers
Brian
FollowupID:
257826
Follow Up By: Member - Melissa - Tuesday, Dec 16, 2003 at 14:09
Tuesday, Dec 16, 2003 at 14:09
I think the supply and installation costs would pale in comparison to what it will cost the vehicle hire companies in insurance, legal fees etc in the long run because sooner or later someone will sue them for failing in their "duty of care". ie. Their responsibility to provide at least a minimum level of 4WD training, a 4WD/
survival manual and basic education about Aust. harsh conditions when they willingly hire 4WD to completely inexperienced, unwitting foreign tourists. What is the extent of their "duty of care" - a legally accepted and tested interpretation is "What a reasonable person would expect in the circumstances." A legal eagle would only have to point out the spate of deaths that have occured over the last few years to prove that a 4WD hire company hiring a vehicle to someone with no 4WD or outback travel experience and providing no training or manuals etc could "reasonably" foresee the possibilty of a tragedy occurring.
:o) Melissa
:o) Melissa Petrol 4.5L GU Patrol &
Camprite TL8 offroad camper
http://members.westnet.com.au/flatdog
FollowupID:
257969
Follow Up By: Brian - Tuesday, Dec 16, 2003 at 18:02
Tuesday, Dec 16, 2003 at 18:02
Now, all we need is a legal evaluation of the term "Reasonable Person".....
One day all the "tracks" that don't have locked gates will have neon signs hovering over the blacktop and depth indicators on the edge of bridges over those water crossings we used to play in.... :-(
and this will be because we have lost the ability to take responsibility for ourselves................... the lawyers will prosper though.....
Just my opinion
Cheers
Brian
FollowupID:
257989
Reply By: Member - Des Lexik(SA) - Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 21:58
Sunday, Dec 14, 2003 at 21:58
It is always very sad when someone dies so tragically.
This site is frequently read by intending overseas visitors and we often read posts about some ambitious plan they intend to complete in the summer time. To the internationals who may be planning a remote trip at this time of year DON'T DO IT
This is a manificent country but is very unforgivingand you probably won't get a second chance out there.ne cede malis
AnswerID:
40198
Reply By: Member - Bob - Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 09:08
Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 09:08
I like the idea of the
survival book in each hire 4WD - multi-lingual. I know we have had the discussion before about whether this list should advocate various things but maybe this is a situation where the collective experience and wisdom of the members of this group might be harnessed to recommend this small step.
I also like the idea of appropriate signage at the start of remote tracks. Even the start of the Plenty Hwy, say, should inform people of what they are in for. I remeber well the sign
on the road to Port Warrender: "No potable water. Sandlies and crocodiles abound" So I slept on the roof rack :-)
Lastly, carrying an
Epirb (or satphone or
HF radio) in certain areas should be a compulsory prerequisite for entry. Only one of the devices necessary per group, but all groups must have at least one of them. There will be people who object to this, but when you consider the cost to the community of
search and rescue ops - tough.Bob
AnswerID:
40211
Follow Up By: Member - Bob - Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 09:10
Monday, Dec 15, 2003 at 09:10
I may remember well - I just can't type. A sandlie is a sandfly.Bob
FollowupID:
257832
Reply By: Member - NOBBY - Tuesday, Dec 16, 2003 at 21:16
Tuesday, Dec 16, 2003 at 21:16
surely the hire company would take a bond from the hirer and give it back when all is returned.slavekitten.jpg
AnswerID:
40424